B08
Computation as common denominator
What would a physical implementation need to reproduce beyond the output of its simulation?

VIII.08 / QUANTUM FOUNDATIONS
Which question led each author to place information at the foundation of physics, and which sources do their arguments share?
't Hooft's cellular-automaton interpretation and Wheeler's information-centered questions offer distinct approaches to quantum foundations. The first develops a deterministic interpretive program; the second asks how physical description relates to elementary acts of inquiry and recorded outcomes. Their shared vocabulary around information does not remove their different assumptions. A useful comparison follows the mathematical objects and the measurement claims in each original text.
For a toy automaton, specify the allowed states and a deterministic update rule. Separately specify an observer's binary measurement and the grouping of underlying states that produces its answer. Track how uncertainty can enter through limited access even when the update is deterministic, then identify what further argument would be needed to recover quantum statistics.
Read one technical example from 't Hooft beside one complete Wheeler passage and document their points of agreement and their unresolved differences.
Gerard 't Hooft · A deterministic interpretive program and its formal ambitions; distinct from an experimentally selected fundamental model.
John Archibald Wheeler / university-hosted original chapter · Wheeler's information-oriented foundational questions; not a complete predictive microphysical theory.
B08
What would a physical implementation need to reproduce beyond the output of its simulation?