{"schema":"xlvii.public-research-map.v1","updatedAt":"2026-11-19","description":"Historical relations, Millennium problem dossiers, and scoped calculations. Connections retain evidence and limits. No Millennium solution is asserted by this research pass.","history":{"schema":"xlvii.quantum-history.v1","updatedAt":"2026-11-19","method":{"status":"Complete; bounded independent editorial review passed. Retrieval limitations remain explicit.","scope":"A bounded primary-source map with explicit retrieval limits, not a claim of exhaustive historical coverage.","edgeTypes":["documented-influence","mathematical-dependency","empirical-test","engineering-transfer","analogy","divergence","unsupported"],"chronology":"Publication, preprint, manuscript, and composition dates are distinguished. A mathematical or analogy edge can point backward in time because it is not necessarily a historical influence.","equations":"Equations are concise modern restatements with stated domains, not verbatim historical notation.","evidence":"Source IDs resolve to public bibliographic records with checked date and inspection scope. Some records were inspected through abstracts or indexed primary excerpts, as explicitly disclosed."},"sources":[{"id":"planck-lecture","title":"The Genesis and Present State of Development of the Quantum Theory (1920 lecture)","url":"https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/1918/planck/lecture/","publisher":"Nobel Foundation","scope":"Planck's retrospective account of black-body radiation, Boltzmann statistics, failed approaches, and the quantum of action.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Indexed lecture text inspected; first-person retrospective, not a substitute for all 1900 papers."},{"id":"einstein-light","title":"Über einen die Erzeugung und Verwandlung des Lichtes betreffenden heuristischen Gesichtspunkt (1905)","url":"https://doi.org/10.1002/andp.19053220607","publisher":"Annalen der Physik / Wiley","scope":"Light-quantum hypothesis; photoelectric relation. Cross-checked against Millikan's original paper and the Library of Congress paper catalog.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher direct retrieval blocked; publication identified through the custodial catalog and cited directly in Millikan's inspected paper."},{"id":"millikan-photoelectric","title":"A Direct Photoelectric Determination of Planck's h (1916)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/pr/pdf/10.1103/PhysRev.7.355","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Frequency–stopping-potential measurements and the distinction between confirming an equation and endorsing its explanation.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Primary PDF opened; introduction, tests, interpretation, and conclusion passages inspected."},{"id":"compton-scattering","title":"A Quantum Theory of the Scattering of X-rays by Light Elements (1923)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.21.483","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Photon momentum, recoil, wavelength shift, light-element approximation.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher abstract and references inspected; abstract includes equation and experimental limitations."},{"id":"bohr-lecture","title":"The Structure of the Atom (1922 lecture)","url":"https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/bohr-lecture.pdf","publisher":"Nobel Foundation","scope":"Stationary states, transition frequencies, hydrogen spectra, and correspondence at large quantum numbers.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Indexed primary lecture excerpts inspected; direct PDF retrieval returned 403."},{"id":"broglie-lecture","title":"The Wave Nature of the Electron (1929 lecture)","url":"https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2016/04/broglie-lecture.pdf","publisher":"Nobel Foundation","scope":"Matter-wave proposal and its retrospective context.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Indexed primary lecture excerpts inspected; corroborated by Schrödinger and Davisson–Germer original papers."},{"id":"heisenberg-1925","title":"On the Quantum Reinterpretation of Kinematical and Mechanical Relationships (1925)","url":"https://www.staff.uni-mainz.de/doria/WH.pdf","publisher":"Zeitschrift für Physik; translation hosted at Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz","scope":"Observable transition quantities, product rule, and failures of old quantum theory.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Primary paper in Luca Doria's 2014 translation opened; introduction and early mathematical construction inspected."},{"id":"born-jordan","title":"Zur Quantenmechanik (1925)","url":"https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01328531","publisher":"Springer / Zeitschrift für Physik","scope":"Matrix calculus develops Heisenberg's proposal; one-degree-of-freedom mechanics and field extension.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher abstract and correction note inspected; full article paywalled."},{"id":"born-heisenberg-jordan","title":"Zur Quantenmechanik II (1926)","url":"https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01379806","publisher":"Springer / Zeitschrift für Physik","scope":"Many degrees of freedom, perturbation theory, Hermitian eigenvalue problems, angular momentum.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher abstract and dates inspected; received November 1925, volume dated 1926."},{"id":"schrodinger-eigenvalue","title":"Quantisierung als Eigenwertproblem, first communication (1926)","url":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/andp.19263840404","publisher":"Annalen der Physik / Wiley","scope":"Wave mechanics as an eigenvalue problem; acknowledgments to Weyl and citation to de Broglie.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher metadata and original footnotes inspected; full mathematical text not retrieved in this pass."},{"id":"schrodinger-equivalence","title":"Über das Verhältnis der Heisenberg-Born-Jordanschen Quantenmechanik zu der meinen (1926)","url":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/andp.19263840804","publisher":"Annalen der Physik / Wiley","scope":"Relationship between wave and matrix formulations; explicit intellectual credits and limits of claimed historical dependence.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher original footnotes inspected, including p.735 note on de Broglie, Einstein, and Heisenberg; translated introduction located."},{"id":"born-scattering","title":"Zur Quantenmechanik der Stoßvorgänge (1926)","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01397477","publisher":"Springer / Zeitschrift für Physik","scope":"Scattering and the statistical interpretation of wave amplitudes.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Indexed publisher abstract and original dates inspected; probability interpretation cross-checked in Born's lecture."},{"id":"born-lecture","title":"The Statistical Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics (1954 lecture)","url":"https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/born-lecture.pdf","publisher":"Nobel Foundation","scope":"Born's retrospective account of probabilities and continuing interpretive disagreements.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Indexed primary lecture text inspected; first-person retrospective used within its scope."},{"id":"davisson-germer","title":"Diffraction of Electrons by a Crystal of Nickel (1927)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.30.705","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Angular electron scattering, crystal structure, and comparison with h/mv.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher abstract inspected; it reports missing beams, adsorbed-gas effects, and agreement limits."},{"id":"bose-statistics","title":"Plancks Gesetz und Lichtquantenhypothese (1924)","url":"https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01327326","publisher":"Springer / Zeitschrift für Physik","scope":"Counting photon distributions in phase-space cells to obtain radiation entropy.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher abstract inspected; this source concerns radiation, not every subsequent Bose–Einstein gas result."},{"id":"dirac-electron","title":"The Quantum Theory of the Electron (1928)","url":"https://www.math.ucsd.edu/~nwallach/Dirac1928.pdf","publisher":"Royal Society; scan hosted at University of California San Diego","scope":"Relativistic Hamiltonian and electron spin structure.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Primary scan opened; introduction and initial equations inspected. Modern gamma-matrix notation is explicitly a restatement."},{"id":"dirac-radiation","title":"The Quantum Theory of the Emission and Absorption of Radiation (1927)","url":"https://wwwhome.lorentz.leidenuniv.nl/~boyarsky/media/Proc.R.Soc.Lond.-1927-Dirac-243-65.pdf","publisher":"Royal Society; scan hosted at Leiden University","scope":"Quantization of radiation and emission/absorption.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Primary scan opened; text extraction is largely bibliographic. Field formula is a modern schematic restatement, not a quotation."},{"id":"von-neumann","title":"Mathematische Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik (1932)","url":"https://gdz.sub.uni-goettingen.de/id/PPN379400774","publisher":"Springer; Göttingen State and University Library","scope":"Hilbert-space foundations, statistical states, and measurement.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Custodial bibliographic record inspected through indexing; page interface returned minimal text. Detailed measurement use cross-checked against Zeh's original discussion."},{"id":"robertson","title":"The Uncertainty Principle (1929)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.34.163","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Variance inequality for noncommuting observables.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher metadata inspected; article text is paywalled. Displayed inequality is independently derivable by Cauchy–Schwarz."},{"id":"born-oppenheimer","title":"Zur Quantentheorie der Molekeln (1927)","url":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/andp.19273892002","publisher":"Annalen der Physik / Wiley","scope":"Separation of electronic and nuclear motion in molecular calculations.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Indexed publisher record, original references, and Jordan acknowledgment inspected; modern approximation caveats supported by later chemical-dynamics paper."},{"id":"heitler-london","title":"Wechselwirkung neutraler Atome und homöopolare Bindung nach der Quantenmechanik (1927)","url":"https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01397394","publisher":"Springer / Zeitschrift für Physik","scope":"H₂ covalent binding, exchange symmetry, Pauli principle, and acknowledgment of Schrödinger.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher abstract and original acknowledgment inspected."},{"id":"hartree","title":"The Wave Mechanics of an Atom with a Non-Coulomb Central Field. Part I (1928)","url":"https://doi.org/10.1017/S0305004100011919","publisher":"Cambridge Philosophical Society / Cambridge University Press","scope":"Numerical central-field eigenvalue calculations and matching inward/outward radial solutions.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Indexed publisher extract inspected; issue date 1928 distinguished from 2008 digitization."},{"id":"fock","title":"Näherungsmethode zur Lösung des quantenmechanischen Mehrkörperproblems (1930)","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01340294","publisher":"Springer / Zeitschrift für Physik","scope":"Antisymmetric mean-field approximation for many-electron systems.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Bibliographic identifier cross-checked in publisher-hosted references; direct article retrieval timed out. Related equations cross-checked in Kohn–Sham's abstract."},{"id":"epr","title":"Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete? (1935, Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.47.777","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Criterion of reality, noncommuting observables, and completeness argument.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher primary abstract inspected."},{"id":"bohr-epr","title":"Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete? (1935, Bohr)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.48.696","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Explicit response to EPR's criterion of physical reality.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher abstract and references inspected."},{"id":"bohm","title":"A Suggested Interpretation of the Quantum Theory in Terms of Hidden Variables I (1952)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.85.166","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Deterministic alternative reproducing ordinary quantum statistics under the stated formulation.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher primary abstract inspected; nonlocality cross-checked in Bell's original paper."},{"id":"bell","title":"On the Einstein Podolsky Rosen Paradox (1964)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/ppf/pdf/10.1103/PhysicsPhysiqueFizika.1.195","publisher":"Physics Publishing Co.; American Physical Society archive","scope":"Local hidden-variable constraints, EPR motivation, and Bohm counterexample to overly broad no-go claims.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Primary PDF opened; introduction, locality assumptions, and references inspected."},{"id":"chsh","title":"Proposed Experiment to Test Local Hidden-Variable Theories (1969)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.23.880","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Experimentally applicable Bell inequality; authors Clauser, Horne, Shimony, Holt.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher abstract inspected; attached 1970 erratum is disclosed on the record."},{"id":"aspect","title":"Experimental Test of Bell's Inequalities Using Time-Varying Analyzers (1982)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.49.1804","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Photon polarization correlations and rapidly switched analyzer settings.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher primary abstract inspected; limitations of earlier experiments cross-checked with Hensen."},{"id":"hensen","title":"Experimental Loophole-Free Violation of a Bell Inequality Using Entangled Electron Spins Separated by 1.3 km (2015)","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/1508.05949","publisher":"Hensen and collaborators; arXiv; Nature 526, 682–686","scope":"Event-ready electron-spin Bell test with locality and detection loopholes addressed jointly.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author-deposited abstract opened; Nature direct retrieval blocked. Assumptions are not converted into claims that every possible loophole is excluded."},{"id":"everett","title":"Relative State Formulation of Quantum Mechanics (1957)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/rmp/abstract/10.1103/RevModPhys.29.454","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Universal unitary description and relative states.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher bibliographic record opened; interpretive claims bounded and cross-checked with Zeh and Zurek."},{"id":"zeh","title":"On the Interpretation of Measurement in Quantum Theory (1970)","url":"https://www.thp.uni-koeln.de/gravitation/zeh/FP70.pdf","publisher":"Foundations of Physics; University of Cologne archive","scope":"Measurement coupling, density matrices, and environmental interaction.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Primary PDF opened; measurement construction and critique of statistical explanations inspected."},{"id":"zurek","title":"Decoherence, Einselection, and the Quantum Origins of the Classical (2003)","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0105127","publisher":"Wojciech H. Zurek; Reviews of Modern Physics / arXiv","scope":"Environmental monitoring, pointer states, and emergence of stable records.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author-deposited abstract opened; review written by a principal developer. Submission 2001 and final revision 2003 distinguished."},{"id":"lindblad","title":"On the Generators of Quantum Dynamical Semigroups (1976)","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01608499","publisher":"Communications in Mathematical Physics / Springer","scope":"Completely positive semigroups and bounded generators of Markovian master equations.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher fetch timed out; original paper abstract and introduction inspected in indexed PDF and INSPIRE record."},{"id":"dyson-qed","title":"The Radiation Theories of Tomonaga, Schwinger, and Feynman (1949)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.75.486","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Equivalence and practical unification of QED formalisms.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher abstract and references inspected; abstract explicitly withholds a general convergence proof."},{"id":"yang-mills","title":"Conservation of Isotopic Spin and Isotopic Gauge Invariance (1954)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.96.191","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Local non-Abelian gauge symmetry and nonlinear gauge fields.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher abstract and references inspected; historical SU(2) isotopic proposal distinguished from later QCD."},{"id":"wilson-rg","title":"Renormalization Group and Critical Phenomena I (1971)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/prb/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevB.4.3174","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Kadanoff scaling, differential flow, irrelevant variables, fixed-point conditions.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher primary abstract inspected."},{"id":"wilson-lattice","title":"Confinement of Quarks (1974)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/prd/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevD.10.2445","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Gauge-invariant Euclidean lattice formulation and strong-coupling confinement mechanism.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher primary abstract inspected; explicit absence of continuum rotational invariance in the strong-coupling limit retained."},{"id":"gross-wilczek","title":"Ultraviolet Behavior of Non-Abelian Gauge Theories (1973)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.30.1343","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Asymptotic freedom and logarithmic corrections in non-Abelian theories.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher primary abstract inspected."},{"id":"politzer","title":"Reliable Perturbative Results for Strong Interactions? (1973)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.30.1346","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Independent ultraviolet perturbative analysis of Yang–Mills theories.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher primary abstract inspected; same publication date does not imply collaboration."},{"id":"osterwalder-schrader","title":"Axioms for Euclidean Green's Functions (1973)","url":"https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01645738","publisher":"Communications in Mathematical Physics / Springer","scope":"Conditions linking Euclidean functions to relativistic quantum field theory.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher abstract and references opened; detailed reconstruction theorem not re-proved here."},{"id":"pacs-cs","title":"2+1 Flavor Lattice QCD toward the Physical Point (2008)","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/0807.1661","publisher":"PACS-CS Collaboration; arXiv / Physical Review D","scope":"Numerical QCD, lattice-spacing and quark-mass control, hadronic observables.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author-deposited abstract inspected; finite lattice and fitted physical inputs are explicit."},{"id":"hohenberg-kohn","title":"Inhomogeneous Electron Gas (1964)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.136.B864","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Ground-state density variational functional.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher abstract inspected; it states the functional and minimum principle."},{"id":"kohn-sham","title":"Self-Consistent Equations Including Exchange and Correlation Effects (1965)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.140.A1133","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Practical density-functional equations and approximations for exchange/correlation.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher primary abstract inspected; existence results and approximate functionals kept distinct."},{"id":"shannon","title":"A Mathematical Theory of Communication (1948)","url":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/j.1538-7305.1948.tb01338.x","publisher":"Bell System Technical Journal / Wiley","scope":"Message uncertainty, noisy channels, and coding.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher record opened and indexed primary reprint excerpt inspected; no semantic or metaphysical claims inferred."},{"id":"landauer","title":"Irreversibility and Heat Generation in the Computing Process (1961)","url":"https://www.cpt.univ-mrs.fr/~verga/pdfs/Landauer-1961uq.pdf","publisher":"IBM Journal of Research and Development; Aix-Marseille University hosted reprint","scope":"Logical erasure and thermodynamic dissipation.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Primary 2000 reprint opened; scanned content has limited extracted text. Bibliographic date and related Bennett analysis cross-checked."},{"id":"bennett","title":"Logical Reversibility of Computation (1973)","url":"https://www.cs.princeton.edu/courses/archive/fall04/cos576/papers/bennett73.html","publisher":"IBM Journal of Research and Development; Princeton-hosted transcription","scope":"Reversible simulation of logically irreversible computation.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Indexed primary abstract inspected; direct hosted text returned 403."},{"id":"feynman","title":"Simulating Physics with Computers (1982)","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02650179","publisher":"International Journal of Theoretical Physics / Springer; Caltech catalog","scope":"Quantum physical simulation as a computational problem.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher metadata opened; primary passages located in Caltech lecture material. Full article not retrieved."},{"id":"deutsch","title":"Quantum Theory, the Church–Turing Principle and the Universal Quantum Computer (1985)","url":"https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.1985.0070","publisher":"Royal Society","scope":"Universal quantum computational model.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Indexed original abstract and university-hosted scan identified; direct scan returned 403."},{"id":"shor-algorithm","title":"Polynomial-Time Algorithms for Prime Factorization and Discrete Logarithms on a Quantum Computer (1994/1997)","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9508027","publisher":"Peter W. Shor; SIAM / arXiv","scope":"Factoring and discrete logarithms in the quantum circuit model.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author-deposited abstract inspected; original 1994 conference appearance and 1997 expanded publication distinguished."},{"id":"grover","title":"A Fast Quantum Mechanical Algorithm for Database Search (1996)","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9605043","publisher":"Lov K. Grover; ACM STOC / arXiv","scope":"Quadratic query speedup for unstructured search.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author-deposited abstract inspected; oracle query cost is separated from real data-loading cost."},{"id":"shor-code","title":"Scheme for Reducing Decoherence in Quantum Computer Memory (1995)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/pra/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevA.52.R2493","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Quantum error correction under independent local decoherence.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Indexed publisher abstract inspected."},{"id":"shor-fault-tolerance","title":"Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computation (1996)","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9605011","publisher":"Peter W. Shor; IEEE FOCS / arXiv","scope":"Fault-tolerant operations using encoded quantum information.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author-deposited abstract inspected; inverse-polylogarithmic error bound distinguished from later constant-threshold results."},{"id":"aharonov-benor","title":"Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computation with Constant Error Rate (1996/1997; expanded 1999)","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9906129","publisher":"Dorit Aharonov and Michael Ben-Or; SIAM / arXiv","scope":"Constant noise threshold with explicit locality and architecture assumptions.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author-deposited abstract inspected and earlier quant-ph/9611025 record cross-checked."},{"id":"surface-code","title":"Suppressing Quantum Errors by Scaling a Surface Code Logical Qubit (2023)","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.06431","publisher":"Google Quantum AI; Nature / arXiv","scope":"Measured logical-error scaling between distance-three and distance-five surface codes.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author-deposited record and publisher abstract inspected; preprint 2022 and journal publication 2023 distinguished."},{"id":"dmrg","title":"Density Matrix Formulation for Quantum Renormalization Groups (1992)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.69.2863","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Density-matrix basis selection for numerical many-body calculations.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher primary abstract inspected; it explicitly credits Wilson's numerical renormalization procedure."},{"id":"chemical-dynamics","title":"Polynomial-Time Quantum Algorithm for the Simulation of Chemical Dynamics (2008)","url":"https://dash.harvard.edu/entities/publication/73120378-94d4-6bd4-e053-0100007fdf3b","publisher":"Kassal, Jordan, Love, Mohseni, Aspuru-Guzik; PNAS / Harvard repository","scope":"Electron–nuclear simulation, selected state preparation, and reaction observables.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Institutional author-paper abstract inspected; arbitrary-state preparation and measurement caveats retained."},{"id":"vqe","title":"A Variational Eigenvalue Solver on a Quantum Processor (2014)","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/1304.3061","publisher":"Peruzzo and collaborators; Nature Communications / arXiv","scope":"Hybrid classical/quantum energy minimization demonstrated on helium hydride.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author-deposited abstract inspected; preprint 2013 and journal publication 2014 distinguished."},{"id":"barren-plateaus","title":"Barren Plateaus in Quantum Neural Network Training Landscapes (2018)","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/1803.11173","publisher":"McClean and collaborators; Nature Communications / arXiv","scope":"Exponential gradient concentration for specified randomized circuit families.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author-deposited primary abstract inspected; not generalized to every ansatz or optimizer."},{"id":"no-cloning","title":"A Single Quantum Cannot Be Cloned (1982)","url":"https://www.nature.com/articles/299802a0","publisher":"Nature; Wootters and Zurek","scope":"Linearity prohibits universal exact copying of arbitrary unknown states.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Indexed publisher abstract and references inspected; direct site fetch redirected to inaccessible identity service."},{"id":"teleportation","title":"Teleporting an Unknown Quantum State via Dual Classical and Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen Channels (1993)","url":"https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.70.1895","publisher":"American Physical Society","scope":"Entanglement, joint measurement, and classical communication in state transfer.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher primary abstract inspected; original state destruction and classical message requirement explicit."},{"id":"hermetica","title":"Corpus Hermeticum I, in Hermetica (1992 critical translation)","url":"https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/hermetica/corpus-hermeticum-i/A5163B0741264BF34F2555B8C2B9BE4A","publisher":"Cambridge University Press; Brian P. Copenhaver","scope":"Ancient revelatory dialogue as a historical text, not a physical theory.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Edition metadata and translated opening paragraphs inspected; ancient composition date is approximate, not the modern edition date."},{"id":"hermetica-ii","title":"Hermetica II: General Introduction (2018)","url":"https://assets.cambridge.org/97811071/82530/excerpt/9781107182530_excerpt.pdf","publisher":"Cambridge University Press; M. David Litwa","scope":"Different manuscript traditions and the Coptic Hermetica in Nag Hammadi.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Indexed critical-edition introduction inspected; PDF direct retrieval failed. Supports textual grouping, not quantum influence."},{"id":"nag-hammadi-iv","title":"Cairo, Coptic Museum, Inv. 10552: Nag Hammadi Codex IV","url":"https://www.nasscal.com/manuscripta-apocryphorum/cairo-coptic-museum-inv-10552-nag-hammadi-codex-iv/","publisher":"NASSCAL; Tony Burke / York University","scope":"Physical witness, fourth-century manuscript date, and listed contents.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Scholarly manuscript catalog opened; physical witness date distinguished from composition date."},{"id":"coptic-library","title":"Coptic Gnostic Library Online: manuscript and tractate inventory","url":"https://scholarlyeditions.brill.com/cglo/","publisher":"Brill; edition under James M. Robinson","scope":"Coptic witnesses, multiple versions, and Hermetic tractates in Codex VI.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Critical edition inventory opened; translations requiring subscription not claimed fully read."},{"id":"kybalion","title":"The Kybalion, chapter II: The Seven Hermetic Principles (1908)","url":"https://sacred-texts.com/book/the-kybalion/chapter-ii-the-seven-hermetic-principles","publisher":"Three Initiates; Yogi Publication Society; Internet Sacred Text Archive transcription","scope":"The modern text's own seven principles and its claims.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Primary chapter transcription inspected. Self-claimed antiquity is not accepted as independent historical evidence."},{"id":"kybalion-catalog","title":"The Kybalion: 1908 edition catalog record","url":"https://onlinebooks.library.upenn.edu/webbin/book/lookupid?key=olbp51029","publisher":"University of Pennsylvania Online Books","scope":"Author pseudonym, title, publisher, and copyright date of the modern work.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Indexed custodial catalog record inspected; direct request timed out. Gutenberg catalog cross-check located."},{"id":"hermetic-dating","title":"Hermeticism, the Cabala, and the Search for Ancient Wisdom (2021)","url":"https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/magic-science-and-religion-in-early-modern-europe/hermeticism-the-cabala-and-the-search-for-ancient-wisdom/A34EAAD6820340AD3F27F1297127F506","publisher":"Cambridge University Press; Mark A. Waddell","scope":"Scholarly dating context for ancient Hermetic compositions and later attribution claims.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher historical research excerpt inspected; used only for provenance, not technical physics."}],"nodes":[{"id":"hermetic-dialogue","title":"The Corpus Hermeticum frames knowledge as a transformative inquiry.","year":200,"dateLabel":"Early centuries CE; individual composition dates remain approximate.","kind":"text","people":["Ancient authors writing under the name Hermes Trismegistus"],"domains":["textual-history","epistemology"],"summary":"The opening of Poimandres presents a revelatory dialogue about nature, mind, and divinity. Its claims belong to a religious and philosophical text; it does not supply a quantitative physical model.","equation":null,"observables":["Vocabulary and arguments within a specified treatise","Manuscript and translation variants"],"sourceIds":["hermetica","hermetic-dating"]},{"id":"nag-hammadi-witness","title":"Nag Hammadi Codex IV preserves identifiable Coptic witnesses.","year":350,"dateLabel":"Fourth-century manuscript; texts may have earlier composition histories.","kind":"manuscript","people":["Ancient Coptic scribes; individual identities uncertain"],"domains":["textual-history","epistemology"],"summary":"The catalog records a papyrus codex containing the Apocryphon of John and Gospel of the Egyptians. Dating a physical copy does not establish the date of every idea in its contents.","equation":null,"observables":["Material, dimensions, script, and page sequence","Witness-specific wording"],"sourceIds":["nag-hammadi-iv","coptic-library"]},{"id":"coptic-hermetica","title":"Hermetic tractates occur within the Nag Hammadi collection.","year":350,"dateLabel":"Fourth-century codex context; composition and transmission are separate questions.","kind":"manuscript","people":["Ancient authors and scribes; individual identities uncertain"],"domains":["textual-history","interoperability"],"summary":"Codex VI contains the Discourse on the Eighth and Ninth, Prayer of Thanksgiving, and Asclepius. This is a concrete textual overlap; it does not make every work in the collection doctrinally identical.","equation":null,"observables":["Codex and tractate location","Parallel versions and translations"],"sourceIds":["coptic-library","hermetica-ii"]},{"id":"kybalion-1908","title":"The Kybalion presents seven principles in a modern book.","year":1908,"dateLabel":"1908 edition; later electronic transcriptions.","kind":"text","people":["Three Initiates"],"domains":["textual-history","heuristics"],"summary":"The seven named principles are mentalism, correspondence, vibration, polarity, rhythm, cause and effect, and gender. This identifiable modern formulation must be distinguished from the ancient witnesses and evaluated separately from physical laws.","equation":null,"observables":["Printed edition and chapter wording","Documented quotations and transmission"],"sourceIds":["kybalion","kybalion-catalog"]},{"id":"planck-1900","title":"Planck models the measured spectrum of thermal radiation.","year":1900,"dateLabel":"1900 work, recounted in the 1920 Nobel lecture.","kind":"theory","people":["Max Planck"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","statistical-physics"],"summary":"A radiation formula linked the observed spectrum to a new constant of action. Planck's later account describes experimental constraints and his use of Boltzmann's probability ideas, rather than a complete quantum mechanics arriving at once.","equation":{"text":"uν(T)=8πhν³/[c³(exp(hν/kBT)−1)]","scope":"Equilibrium black-body spectral energy density per unit frequency."},"observables":["Spectral radiance versus frequency and temperature"],"sourceIds":["planck-lecture"]},{"id":"einstein-1905","title":"Einstein proposes light quanta and a testable energy relation.","year":1905,"dateLabel":"1905 paper.","kind":"theory","people":["Albert Einstein"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","radiation"],"summary":"The light-quantum hypothesis motivates a linear relation between light frequency and maximum photoelectron energy. A successful relation and the interpretation used to derive it can be assessed separately.","equation":{"text":"Kmax=hν−Φ","scope":"Single-photon photoemission model with a material-dependent work function."},"observables":["Stopping potential","Threshold frequency"],"sourceIds":["einstein-light","millikan-photoelectric"]},{"id":"bohr-1913","title":"Bohr connects stationary states to atomic spectral lines.","year":1913,"dateLabel":"1913 model; 1922 lecture supplies the inspected retrospective.","kind":"theory","people":["Niels Bohr"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","spectroscopy"],"summary":"Allowed states and transition frequencies organize hydrogen spectra. These postulates modify classical orbital mechanics, and correspondence applies in specified large-quantum-number limits.","equation":{"text":"hν=Em−En","scope":"Transition between atomic stationary states; this does not assert a literal classical trajectory."},"observables":["Hydrogen line frequencies","Ionization energies"],"sourceIds":["bohr-lecture"]},{"id":"millikan-1916","title":"Millikan tests the photoelectric equation while disputing its explanation.","year":1916,"dateLabel":"Published 1 March 1916.","kind":"experiment","people":["Robert A. Millikan"],"domains":["radiation","measurement"],"summary":"Measurements of contact and stopping potentials test the frequency dependence. The paper reports agreement while rejecting the then-proposed localized-energy explanation, documenting a genuine interpretive divergence.","equation":{"text":"eVs=hν−Φ","scope":"Idealized stopping-potential relation after experimental contact-potential corrections."},"observables":["Frequency–voltage slope","Surface and contact-potential dependence"],"sourceIds":["millikan-photoelectric"]},{"id":"compton-1923","title":"Compton measures recoil in scattered radiation.","year":1923,"dateLabel":"Published 1 May 1923.","kind":"experiment","people":["Arthur H. Compton"],"domains":["radiation","relativity"],"summary":"Energy and momentum transfer to an electron predicts a scattering-angle-dependent wavelength shift. The original account states why electron binding forces restrict the approximation.","equation":{"text":"Δλ=h(1−cosθ)/(mec)","scope":"Scattering from an approximately free electron initially at rest."},"observables":["Scattered wavelength","Scattering angle","Electron recoil"],"sourceIds":["compton-scattering"]},{"id":"bose-1924","title":"Bose counts photon distributions in phase space.","year":1924,"dateLabel":"1924 paper.","kind":"theory","people":["Satyendra Nath Bose"],"domains":["statistical-physics","radiation"],"summary":"Counting distributions of light quanta provides a statistical route to the radiation law. The paper concerns photons; later applications to material particles require additional sources and assumptions.","equation":{"text":"n̄(ν)=1/[exp(hν/kBT)−1]","scope":"Equilibrium photon occupation; zero chemical potential."},"observables":["Thermal occupation versus frequency"],"sourceIds":["bose-statistics"]},{"id":"broglie-1924","title":"De Broglie assigns wave properties to material particles.","year":1924,"dateLabel":"1924 thesis; inspected through later primary accounts.","kind":"theory","people":["Louis de Broglie"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","wave-mechanics"],"summary":"The relation between momentum and wavelength suggests a different route to quantization. Schrödinger explicitly credits this work as an inspiration, and electron diffraction provides a separate empirical test.","equation":{"text":"λ=h/p","scope":"Matter-wave wavelength; nonrelativistic p≈mv when appropriate."},"observables":["Electron diffraction angles","Momentum–wavelength relation"],"sourceIds":["broglie-lecture","schrodinger-equivalence","davisson-germer"]},{"id":"heisenberg-1925","title":"Heisenberg reorganizes mechanics around transition quantities.","year":1925,"dateLabel":"1925 paper.","kind":"theory","people":["Werner Heisenberg"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","observability"],"summary":"The paper replaces unobserved classical orbital quantities with arrays of transition frequencies and amplitudes. Its product rule is a mathematical change motivated by specific failures of old quantum rules.","equation":{"text":"(XY)nm=Σk XnkYkm","scope":"Modern matrix notation for the transition-amplitude product rule."},"observables":["Transition frequencies","Radiation intensities"],"sourceIds":["heisenberg-1925"]},{"id":"born-jordan-1925","title":"Born and Jordan turn the proposal into matrix mechanics.","year":1925,"dateLabel":"Received 27 September 1925; volume dated 1925.","kind":"theory","people":["Max Born","Pascual Jordan"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","operator-algebra"],"summary":"The authors explicitly develop Heisenberg's approach using matrix calculus. Noncommuting observables change the algebra, while mechanical equations yield conservation and frequency relations.","equation":{"text":"[X,P]=iℏI","scope":"Canonical commutation relation; unbounded operators require domain care."},"observables":["Energy differences","Oscillator transition strengths"],"sourceIds":["born-jordan"]},{"id":"bhj-1926","title":"Born, Heisenberg, and Jordan extend the theory to many coordinates.","year":1926,"dateLabel":"Received 16 November 1925; volume dated 1926.","kind":"theory","people":["Max Born","Werner Heisenberg","Pascual Jordan"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","operator-algebra"],"summary":"The joint paper extends matrix mechanics, connects perturbation theory to Hermitian eigenvalue problems, and develops momentum, angular momentum, and selection-rule results.","equation":{"text":"[qj,pk]=iℏδjkI","scope":"Multiple canonical degrees of freedom in modern notation."},"observables":["Spectral splitting","Selection rules","Transition intensities"],"sourceIds":["born-heisenberg-jordan"]},{"id":"schrodinger-1926","title":"Schrödinger treats quantization as an eigenvalue problem.","year":1926,"dateLabel":"1926 series of wave-mechanics papers.","kind":"theory","people":["Erwin Schrödinger","Hermann Weyl"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","differential-equations"],"summary":"A wave equation with boundary and normalizability conditions yields discrete energies. The original paper acknowledges Weyl's mathematical help and cites de Broglie; these are documented connections.","equation":{"text":"Hψ=Eψ; H=−ℏ²∇²/(2m)+V","scope":"Nonrelativistic stationary scalar wave equation."},"observables":["Bound-state energies","Spatial probability distributions after a probability rule is supplied"],"sourceIds":["schrodinger-eigenvalue","schrodinger-equivalence"]},{"id":"wave-matrix-equivalence","title":"The wave and matrix descriptions can represent the same mechanics.","year":1926,"dateLabel":"1926 equivalence paper.","kind":"mathematics","people":["Erwin Schrödinger"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","interoperability"],"summary":"Matrix elements built from wave functions connect the formalisms. Mathematical equivalence does not prove identical interpretations or a causal historical chain between their original discoveries.","equation":{"text":"Anm=⟨ψn|A|ψm⟩","scope":"Operator representation in a suitable basis; completeness and domains matter."},"observables":["Agreement of spectra and matrix elements"],"sourceIds":["schrodinger-equivalence"]},{"id":"born-probability","title":"Born interprets scattering amplitudes statistically.","year":1926,"dateLabel":"1926 scattering work; 1954 retrospective.","kind":"theory","people":["Max Born"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","probability"],"summary":"Wave amplitudes connect to probabilities of outcomes. This changes the meaning assigned to the mathematical wave, rather than merely producing another classical vibrating medium.","equation":{"text":"P(a)=|⟨a|ψ⟩|²","scope":"Ideal projective measurement on a normalized state; continuous spectra need densities."},"observables":["Repeated outcome frequencies","Scattering distributions"],"sourceIds":["born-scattering","born-lecture"]},{"id":"davisson-germer-1927","title":"Davisson and Germer test matter waves with a nickel crystal.","year":1927,"dateLabel":"Published 1 December 1927.","kind":"experiment","people":["Clinton Davisson","Lester Germer"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","materials"],"summary":"Angular scattering peaks are compared with wavelengths inferred from electron momentum. Cleaning, adsorbed gas, unaccounted beams, and missing weak peaks remain part of the experimental record.","equation":{"text":"λ≈h/(mev)","scope":"Nonrelativistic comparison used for the measured electron energies."},"observables":["Scattering intensity versus angle and voltage","Surface-condition dependence"],"sourceIds":["davisson-germer"]},{"id":"dirac-radiation-1927","title":"Dirac quantizes radiation in emission and absorption.","year":1927,"dateLabel":"Published 1 March 1927.","kind":"theory","people":["Paul A. M. Dirac"],"domains":["quantum-field-theory","radiation"],"summary":"Treating radiation modes quantum mechanically connects atomic transitions with changing photon occupation. The schematic modern notation distinguishes field quantization from a single-particle wave equation.","equation":{"text":"Hfield=Σkℏωk(a†kak+1/2)","scope":"Modern free-mode representation; interactions require an additional coupling Hamiltonian."},"observables":["Emission and absorption rates","Photon occupation"],"sourceIds":["dirac-radiation","dyson-qed"]},{"id":"dirac-electron-1928","title":"Dirac combines relativistic motion with electron spin.","year":1928,"dateLabel":"Published February 1928.","kind":"theory","people":["Paul A. M. Dirac"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","relativity","quantum-field-theory"],"summary":"The paper seeks a Hamiltonian consistent with relativity and transformation theory; spin structure emerges within that construction. It does not by itself complete interacting quantum field theory.","equation":{"text":"(iℏγμ∂μ−mc)ψ=0","scope":"Modern covariant notation for the free Dirac equation."},"observables":["Hydrogen fine structure","Electron magnetic structure"],"sourceIds":["dirac-electron"]},{"id":"robertson-1929","title":"Robertson relates variance bounds to operator commutators.","year":1929,"dateLabel":"Published 1 July 1929.","kind":"mathematics","people":["Howard P. Robertson"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","probability"],"summary":"A precise variance inequality separates state preparation uncertainty from the details of a measurement disturbance model. It follows from inner-product geometry with suitable operator domains.","equation":{"text":"σAσB≥|⟨[A,B]⟩|/2","scope":"Normalized state with finite variances and defined commutator expectation."},"observables":["Repeated-ensemble variances"],"sourceIds":["robertson","born-jordan"]},{"id":"von-neumann-1932","title":"Von Neumann organizes quantum theory in Hilbert space.","year":1932,"dateLabel":"1932 monograph.","kind":"mathematics","people":["John von Neumann"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","operator-algebra","measurement"],"summary":"States, observables, and statistical predictions receive a common mathematical language. Later measurement analyses use the system–apparatus coupling as a concrete place to inspect interpretive assumptions.","equation":{"text":"⟨A⟩=Tr(ρA)","scope":"Modern density-operator expectation formula; trace must exist."},"observables":["Expectation values","State–apparatus correlations"],"sourceIds":["von-neumann","zeh"]},{"id":"born-oppenheimer-1927","title":"Born and Oppenheimer separate electronic and nuclear motion.","year":1927,"dateLabel":"1927 paper.","kind":"approximation","people":["Max Born","J. Robert Oppenheimer"],"domains":["quantum-chemistry","differential-equations"],"summary":"Electronic structure can be solved at fixed nuclear coordinates before nuclear motion is treated. Nonadiabatic coupling shows where this separation needs correction.","equation":{"text":"Ψ(r,R)≈ψe(r;R)χ(R)","scope":"Single-surface factorization; near degeneracies and rapid nuclear motion require care."},"observables":["Potential-energy surfaces","Vibrational levels","Nonadiabatic transition probabilities"],"sourceIds":["born-oppenheimer","chemical-dynamics"]},{"id":"heitler-london-1927","title":"Heitler and London explain a molecular bond through exchange.","year":1927,"dateLabel":"1927 paper.","kind":"theory","people":["Walter Heitler","Fritz London"],"domains":["quantum-chemistry","symmetry"],"summary":"Two-electron wave functions and the Pauli principle distinguish bonding from other behavior. The paper also acknowledges Schrödinger's support, establishing an actual research connection.","equation":{"text":"Ψ±∝φA(1)φB(2)±φB(1)φA(2)","scope":"Spatial combinations; the complete fermionic state must include the compatible spin factor."},"observables":["H₂ covalent binding energy","Equilibrium separation","Spin-dependent energy splitting"],"sourceIds":["heitler-london"]},{"id":"hartree-1928","title":"Hartree develops practical radial wave-equation calculations.","year":1928,"dateLabel":"January 1928 publication.","kind":"computation","people":["Douglas R. Hartree"],"domains":["quantum-chemistry","numerical-analysis"],"summary":"Inward and outward radial solutions are matched to determine eigenvalues in a central field. Numerical organization becomes part of the theory's ability to predict complex atomic structure.","equation":{"text":"Heffφi=εiφi","scope":"Effective central-field eigenproblem; neglects full correlated many-electron motion."},"observables":["Atomic energy levels","Convergence of matched radial solutions"],"sourceIds":["hartree"]},{"id":"fock-1930","title":"Fock includes exchange in a self-consistent many-electron approximation.","year":1930,"dateLabel":"1930 paper.","kind":"approximation","people":["Vladimir Fock"],"domains":["quantum-chemistry","numerical-analysis"],"summary":"An antisymmetric mean-field description includes exchange while restricting the state space. It is a controlled starting point for comparisons, with correlation errors to be measured.","equation":{"text":"F[{φj}]φi=εiφi","scope":"Hartree–Fock self-consistency in modern notation; a single Slater determinant does not capture all correlation."},"observables":["Total energy","Orbital-dependent observables","Correlation error against benchmarks"],"sourceIds":["fock","kohn-sham"]},{"id":"epr-1935","title":"Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen challenge completeness.","year":1935,"dateLabel":"Published 15 May 1935.","kind":"interpretation","people":["Albert Einstein","Boris Podolsky","Nathan Rosen"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","epistemology"],"summary":"The argument combines a criterion of reality with predictions for separated correlated systems. Its conclusion depends on the premises; those premises become a target for later analysis.","equation":{"text":"[A,B]≠0","scope":"Noncommuting quantities are central; the original EPR argument uses continuous variables."},"observables":["Conditional predictions for correlated systems"],"sourceIds":["epr"]},{"id":"bohr-reply-1935","title":"Bohr contests the criterion used in the EPR argument.","year":1935,"dateLabel":"Published 15 October 1935.","kind":"interpretation","people":["Niels Bohr"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","epistemology"],"summary":"Bohr's response explicitly identifies an ambiguity in EPR's criterion and explains complementarity. This is a documented disagreement over descriptive conditions, not an experimental refutation by itself.","equation":null,"observables":["Specification of measurement arrangements","Which joint predictions a setup permits"],"sourceIds":["bohr-epr"]},{"id":"bohm-1952","title":"Bohm offers a deterministic hidden-variable formulation.","year":1952,"dateLabel":"Published 15 January 1952.","kind":"interpretation","people":["David Bohm"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","causal-models"],"summary":"The formulation reproduces ordinary quantum statistics under its stated conditions while retaining additional variables. Bell later emphasizes its nonlocal structure, preventing a claim that all hidden-variable theories are impossible.","equation":{"text":"v=(ℏ/m)Im(∇ψ/ψ)","scope":"Schematic spinless guidance equation away from wave-function nodes; many-body configurations matter."},"observables":["Ordinary quantum distributions in equilibrium","Predictions of any proposed departure from the stated formulation"],"sourceIds":["bohm","bell"]},{"id":"everett-1957","title":"Everett proposes a relative-state description.","year":1957,"dateLabel":"Published July 1957.","kind":"interpretation","people":["Hugh Everett III"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","measurement"],"summary":"The relative-state approach applies unitary dynamics to the combined system and observer. Its interpretive commitments should be compared with explicit alternatives, rather than described as an experimentally selected ontology.","equation":{"text":"Σi ci|si⟩|Mi⟩","scope":"Correlated system–record state after an ideal unitary interaction."},"observables":["Correlations between systems and records"],"sourceIds":["everett","zeh","zurek"]},{"id":"bell-1964","title":"Bell converts a locality question into a mathematical constraint.","year":1964,"dateLabel":"Published November 1964.","kind":"theorem","people":["John S. Bell"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","causal-models"],"summary":"The paper formulates the EPR issue mathematically and shows a conflict between local hidden-variable constraints and quantum correlations. It explicitly recognizes a nonlocal hidden-variable construction.","equation":{"text":"E(a,b)=∫dλρ(λ)A(a,λ)B(b,λ)","scope":"Local response model with a setting-independent hidden-variable distribution; subsequent formulations refine the assumptions."},"observables":["Correlations at different analyzer settings"],"sourceIds":["bell"]},{"id":"chsh-1969","title":"CHSH turns the constraint into an experimentally accessible test.","year":1969,"dateLabel":"Published October 1969; erratum 1970.","kind":"theorem","people":["John F. Clauser","Michael A. Horne","Abner Shimony","Richard A. Holt"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","measurement"],"summary":"A four-setting correlation inequality permits practical tests. Any use must state the sampling, outcome, locality, and setting assumptions that make the measured statistic comparable with its bound.","equation":{"text":"|Eab+Eab′+Ea′b−Ea′b′|≤2","scope":"Local binary-outcome bound; quantum theory permits 2√2 with suitable state and observables."},"observables":["Four correlation estimates","Sampling and setting records"],"sourceIds":["chsh","bell"]},{"id":"aspect-1982","title":"Aspect, Dalibard, and Roger vary the analyzers during a Bell test.","year":1982,"dateLabel":"Published 20 December 1982.","kind":"experiment","people":["Alain Aspect","Jean Dalibard","Gérard Roger"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","measurement"],"summary":"Photon polarization correlations violate the tested inequality with time-varying analyzer settings. The result advances experimental discrimination without closing every limitation of earlier optical tests.","equation":{"text":"S computed from measured correlations","scope":"The precise inequality and acceptance conditions belong to the experimental protocol."},"observables":["Polarization coincidence counts","Analyzer switching times"],"sourceIds":["aspect","hensen"]},{"id":"hensen-2015","title":"A separated-spin experiment addresses locality and detection together.","year":2015,"dateLabel":"2015 experiment and publication.","kind":"experiment","people":["Bas Hensen","Ronald Hanson","Hensen collaboration"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","measurement"],"summary":"An event-ready Bell test uses electron spins separated by 1.3 km. Joint control of locality and detection concerns strengthens the test; statistical and setting assumptions remain explicit.","equation":{"text":"|S|>2","scope":"Observed Bell violation assessed with the experiment's statistical protocol."},"observables":["Heralded trials","Spin readout","Space–time separation"],"sourceIds":["hensen"]},{"id":"zeh-1970","title":"Zeh examines measurement as an interaction with other systems.","year":1970,"dateLabel":"Received 1969; published 1970.","kind":"theory","people":["H. Dieter Zeh"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","measurement"],"summary":"The paper analyzes system–apparatus entanglement and challenges claims that ordinary statistical ignorance alone explains measurement. Environmental interaction becomes an explicit dynamical object.","equation":{"text":"ρS=TrE|ΨSE⟩⟨ΨSE|","scope":"Reduced state obtained by discarding environmental degrees of freedom."},"observables":["Interference visibility","Correlations with unobserved degrees of freedom"],"sourceIds":["zeh"]},{"id":"zurek-2003","title":"Zurek describes how environments select stable records.","year":2003,"dateLabel":"Review submitted 2001 and revised 2003; earlier program summarized.","kind":"theory","people":["Wojciech H. Zurek"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","measurement","information"],"summary":"Environmental monitoring can suppress interference between pointer states while preserving particular correlations. The resulting local reduced state does not automatically settle every interpretation of a unique outcome.","equation":{"text":"ρij(t)≈ρij(0)Dij(t)","scope":"Schematic decoherence factor; its form and decay depend on the interaction and environment."},"observables":["Decoherence time","Pointer-state stability","Redundant environmental records"],"sourceIds":["zurek","zeh"]},{"id":"lindblad-1976","title":"Lindblad characterizes Markovian quantum evolution.","year":1976,"dateLabel":"Published June 1976.","kind":"mathematics","people":["Göran Lindblad"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","open-systems","operator-algebra"],"summary":"Completely positive semigroups provide a precise class of irreversible dynamics. The construction is valuable for noise models but does not license a Markov approximation for every physical environment.","equation":{"text":"dρ/dt=−i[H,ρ]/ℏ+Σj(LjρLj†−{Lj†Lj,ρ}/2)","scope":"Finite-dimensional modern form of a time-homogeneous Markovian generator."},"observables":["Relaxation rates","Dephasing rates","State tomography"],"sourceIds":["lindblad"]},{"id":"dyson-1949","title":"Dyson relates the radiation theories of several contemporaries.","year":1949,"dateLabel":"Published 1 February 1949.","kind":"mathematics","people":["Freeman J. Dyson","Sin-Itiro Tomonaga","Julian Schwinger","Richard P. Feynman"],"domains":["quantum-field-theory","interoperability"],"summary":"The paper connects QED formalisms and simplifies calculations of radiative effects. Its abstract explicitly describes higher-order work as a program without a general convergence proof.","equation":{"text":"S=T exp[−(i/ℏ)∫HI(t)dt]","scope":"Formal interaction-picture series; its perturbative usefulness is not a convergence theorem."},"observables":["Radiative corrections","Vacuum polarization"],"sourceIds":["dyson-qed"]},{"id":"yang-mills-1954","title":"Yang and Mills impose local isotopic gauge invariance.","year":1954,"dateLabel":"Published 1 October 1954.","kind":"theory","people":["Chen Ning Yang","Robert L. Mills"],"domains":["quantum-field-theory","symmetry"],"summary":"A local non-Abelian symmetry requires interacting gauge fields. The original isotopic-spin proposal is a specific historical model; later gauge theories reuse and develop its structure.","equation":{"text":"Fμν=∂μAν−∂νAμ−ig[Aμ,Aν]","scope":"One common modern Hermitian-generator convention; signs change with conventions."},"observables":["Gauge-invariant correlations","Interaction-dependent spectra"],"sourceIds":["yang-mills"]},{"id":"wilson-rg-1971","title":"Wilson makes changes of scale into a flow of couplings.","year":1971,"dateLabel":"Published November 1971.","kind":"mathematics","people":["Kenneth G. Wilson","Leo P. Kadanoff"],"domains":["statistical-physics","quantum-field-theory","scale"],"summary":"Scaling near a critical point is expressed through differential flow and fixed points. An analogy between two scales is useful only after the transformation, variables, and limiting behavior are specified.","equation":{"text":"dg/dlnb=β(g)","scope":"Schematic renormalization-group flow; several couplings and convention-dependent signs may be needed."},"observables":["Critical exponents","Correlation-length scaling","Corrections from irrelevant variables"],"sourceIds":["wilson-rg"]},{"id":"gross-wilczek-1973","title":"Gross and Wilczek find ultraviolet weakening in gauge theories.","year":1973,"dateLabel":"Published 25 June 1973.","kind":"theory","people":["David J. Gross","Frank Wilczek"],"domains":["quantum-field-theory","scale"],"summary":"A class of non-Abelian theories approaches free-field behavior at short distances up to logarithmic corrections. This is a perturbative ultraviolet statement, not a proof of infrared confinement.","equation":{"text":"μ dg/dμ=−b0g³+O(g⁵)","scope":"b0>0 in the asymptotically free matter-content regime."},"observables":["Energy dependence of interaction strength","Scaling violations"],"sourceIds":["gross-wilczek"]},{"id":"politzer-1973","title":"Politzer independently analyzes reliable ultraviolet perturbation.","year":1973,"dateLabel":"Published 25 June 1973.","kind":"theory","people":["H. David Politzer"],"domains":["quantum-field-theory","scale"],"summary":"The calculation identifies ultraviolet regimes where perturbation theory improves for Yang–Mills theories. Its relationship to Gross–Wilczek is convergence of results, not evidence that the teams collaborated.","equation":{"text":"g(μ) decreases as μ increases","scope":"Only for the theory and matter-content conditions giving the appropriate beta-function sign."},"observables":["High-energy correlation functions","Logarithmic running"],"sourceIds":["politzer","gross-wilczek"]},{"id":"wilson-lattice-1974","title":"Wilson preserves gauge invariance on a discrete lattice.","year":1974,"dateLabel":"Published October 1974.","kind":"theory","people":["Kenneth G. Wilson"],"domains":["quantum-field-theory","numerical-analysis"],"summary":"Link variables provide a regulated gauge theory with a computable strong-coupling limit. The paper states that this limit lacks continuum rotational invariance, exposing a key step that later work must control.","equation":{"text":"W(C)=Tr∏links∈C Ulink","scope":"Gauge-invariant loop; a strong-coupling area law is not by itself a continuum existence proof."},"observables":["Wilson-loop expectation","Correlation decay","Dependence on lattice spacing"],"sourceIds":["wilson-lattice"]},{"id":"osterwalder-schrader-1973","title":"Euclidean correlation functions must satisfy reconstruction conditions.","year":1973,"dateLabel":"1973 axiomatic paper.","kind":"mathematics","people":["Konrad Osterwalder","Robert Schrader"],"domains":["quantum-field-theory","mathematical-analysis"],"summary":"Euclidean calculations connect to relativistic quantum theory only with suitable axioms, including positivity. A numerical table alone does not verify the required infinite family of conditions.","equation":{"text":"⟨ΘF·F⟩E≥0","scope":"Schematic reflection positivity for admissible positive-time test functionals."},"observables":["Positivity tests on chosen correlators","Continuum and volume convergence"],"sourceIds":["osterwalder-schrader"]},{"id":"pacs-cs-2008","title":"Lattice QCD calculations approach physical quark masses.","year":2008,"dateLabel":"2008 preprint; subsequent Physical Review D publication.","kind":"computation","people":["PACS-CS Collaboration","Sinya Aoki and collaborators"],"domains":["quantum-field-theory","numerical-analysis"],"summary":"Simulations calculate hadronic observables using a stated lattice spacing, volume, and action. Physical calibration inputs and quark-mass extrapolation are part of the result, not hidden implementation details.","equation":{"text":"C(t)=Σn |⟨0|O|n⟩|² exp(−Ent)","scope":"Spectral interpretation assumes a suitable transfer-matrix setting and unit conventions; extraction needs excited-state control."},"observables":["Hadron masses","Chiral fits","Finite-volume and discretization effects"],"sourceIds":["pacs-cs","wilson-lattice"]},{"id":"hohenberg-kohn-1964","title":"Hohenberg and Kohn formulate an energy principle for density.","year":1964,"dateLabel":"Published 9 November 1964.","kind":"theorem","people":["Pierre Hohenberg","Walter Kohn"],"domains":["quantum-chemistry","variational-analysis"],"summary":"The ground-state problem can be expressed using a universal density functional under the theorem's conditions. Existence does not hand us an exact practical formula for every system.","equation":{"text":"E0=minn{F[n]+∫v(r)n(r)dr}","scope":"Admissible ground-state densities for fixed interactions and particle number; representability and degeneracies require care."},"observables":["Ground-state energy","Electron density"],"sourceIds":["hohenberg-kohn"]},{"id":"kohn-sham-1965","title":"Kohn and Sham construct practical self-consistent density equations.","year":1965,"dateLabel":"Published 15 November 1965.","kind":"approximation","people":["Walter Kohn","Lu Jeu Sham"],"domains":["quantum-chemistry","numerical-analysis"],"summary":"An auxiliary orbital system supports efficient calculations, with exchange and correlation represented by a functional. Approximation quality must be tested for the observable and material in question.","equation":{"text":"[−ℏ²∇²/(2m)+veff[n]]φi=εiφi","scope":"Kohn–Sham equations in modern notation; exactness requires an appropriate exact functional and representability."},"observables":["Density","Energy differences","Sensitivity to the chosen functional"],"sourceIds":["kohn-sham","hohenberg-kohn"]},{"id":"shannon-1948","title":"Shannon quantifies uncertainty in communication systems.","year":1948,"dateLabel":"Published in two parts in 1948.","kind":"mathematics","people":["Claude E. Shannon"],"domains":["information","managed-systems"],"summary":"Probability distributions and noisy channels define limits on reliable communication. The entropy measures uncertainty of a specified source; it does not measure the truth or spiritual significance of a message.","equation":{"text":"H(X)=−Σx p(x)log2p(x)","scope":"Discrete source entropy in bits, with 0log0 defined by continuity."},"observables":["Symbol frequencies","Channel error rates","Coding rate"],"sourceIds":["shannon"]},{"id":"landauer-1961","title":"Landauer connects irreversible erasure to physical dissipation.","year":1961,"dateLabel":"1961 paper; inspected through the 2000 reprint.","kind":"theory","people":["Rolf Landauer"],"domains":["information","thermodynamics","managed-systems"],"summary":"Resetting logical alternatives has a thermodynamic cost under specified physical conditions. The familiar bound is not a claim that every logical operation must dissipate the same amount.","equation":{"text":"Qbath≥kBT ln2","scope":"Quasistatic erasure of one unbiased bit in a suitable thermal setting; correlations and nonequilibrium resources alter accounting."},"observables":["Heat delivered to a bath","Initial bit distribution","Reset fidelity"],"sourceIds":["landauer","bennett"]},{"id":"bennett-1973","title":"Bennett shows how computation can be logically reversible.","year":1973,"dateLabel":"Published November 1973.","kind":"mathematics","people":["Charles H. Bennett"],"domains":["information","managed-systems","computation"],"summary":"A computation can retain enough history to reverse its steps, separating logical irreversibility from computation itself. Real machines still have control, speed, storage, and noise costs.","equation":{"text":"(x,0)↦(x,f(x))","scope":"Reversible embedding preserves input information; resetting ancillary records needs separate accounting."},"observables":["Stored history","Reset operations","Time and memory overhead"],"sourceIds":["bennett","landauer"]},{"id":"feynman-1982","title":"Feynman asks how a physical computer can simulate quantum physics.","year":1982,"dateLabel":"1981 talk; 1982 publication.","kind":"proposal","people":["Richard P. Feynman"],"domains":["quantum-information","computation"],"summary":"Generic many-particle amplitudes motivate simulation with quantum systems. The proposal opens an architecture question; it does not imply that every useful quantum task is efficiently accessible.","equation":{"text":"dim(ℋN)=d^N","scope":"Read as d to the power N for N d-level subsystems; structure can permit classical compression."},"observables":["Simulation error","Required resources as system size grows"],"sourceIds":["feynman"]},{"id":"deutsch-1985","title":"Deutsch formulates a universal quantum computational model.","year":1985,"dateLabel":"1985 publication.","kind":"mathematics","people":["David Deutsch"],"domains":["quantum-information","computation"],"summary":"A quantum computing model makes physical simulation and universality precise enough to investigate algorithmically. Computational advantage remains a problem-specific question.","equation":{"text":"|ψout⟩=U|ψin⟩","scope":"Closed-system unitary computational step; preparation and measurement complete a protocol."},"observables":["Circuit output distribution","Simulation accuracy and overhead"],"sourceIds":["deutsch"]},{"id":"shor-1994","title":"Shor gives efficient quantum algorithms for specific arithmetic problems.","year":1994,"dateLabel":"1994 conference result; expanded 1997 journal paper.","kind":"algorithm","people":["Peter W. Shor"],"domains":["quantum-information","complexity"],"summary":"Factoring and discrete logarithms admit polynomial-time quantum algorithms in the stated computational model. This does not establish efficient algorithms for arbitrary NP-complete problems or unlimited theorem discovery.","equation":{"text":"runtime=poly(logN)","scope":"Input length is the number of digits of N; fault-tolerant implementation adds physical overhead."},"observables":["Success probability","Logical gate count","Precision requirements"],"sourceIds":["shor-algorithm"]},{"id":"grover-1996","title":"Grover reduces the query cost of unstructured search.","year":1996,"dateLabel":"1996 STOC algorithm.","kind":"algorithm","people":["Lov K. Grover"],"domains":["quantum-information","complexity"],"summary":"Interference amplifies a marked outcome using quadratically fewer oracle queries. Data access, oracle construction, and error correction must still be charged in an application.","equation":{"text":"queries=O(√N)","scope":"Single marked item in the standard unstructured-search oracle model."},"observables":["Query count","Success probability","Oracle implementation cost"],"sourceIds":["grover"]},{"id":"shor-code-1995","title":"Shor encodes quantum information to correct local errors.","year":1995,"dateLabel":"Published October 1995.","kind":"algorithm","people":["Peter W. Shor"],"domains":["quantum-information","reliability"],"summary":"Encoded states protect information without making independent copies of an arbitrary unknown state. The original construction assumes independently acting decoherence, a condition that a device must investigate.","equation":{"text":"|ψ⟩↦α|0L⟩+β|1L⟩","scope":"Logical encoding; syndrome extraction must avoid reading out the protected amplitudes."},"observables":["Syndrome statistics","Logical error rate"],"sourceIds":["shor-code","no-cloning"]},{"id":"shor-fault-1996","title":"Shor extends protection from stored states to computation.","year":1996,"dateLabel":"1996 conference paper; revised 1997.","kind":"algorithm","people":["Peter W. Shor"],"domains":["quantum-information","reliability"],"summary":"Fault-tolerant procedures control errors while gates are performed. The bound in this paper improves with circuit size but is distinct from a constant-threshold theorem.","equation":{"text":"per-gate error=O(1/(log t)^c)","scope":"Read the denominator as (log t) to a positive constant power; the statement is specific to the construction."},"observables":["Failure probability versus circuit length","Error propagation through gates"],"sourceIds":["shor-fault-tolerance"]},{"id":"threshold-1997","title":"Aharonov and Ben-Or establish a constant-noise threshold result.","year":1997,"dateLabel":"1996 preprint; 1997 conference; expanded proof 1999.","kind":"theorem","people":["Dorit Aharonov","Michael Ben-Or"],"domains":["quantum-information","reliability"],"summary":"Concatenated coding supports long computations below a threshold for the specified local noise models. The existence of such a theorem does not certify arbitrary hardware noise.","equation":{"text":"η<ηc","scope":"Threshold and overhead depend on the architecture, gates, code, and allowed noise structure."},"observables":["Logical failure rate","Spatial and temporal noise correlations"],"sourceIds":["aharonov-benor"]},{"id":"surface-code-2023","title":"A surface-code experiment measures improvement as code distance grows.","year":2023,"dateLabel":"2022 preprint; 2023 Nature publication.","kind":"experiment","people":["Google Quantum AI","Rajeev Acharya and collaborators"],"domains":["quantum-information","reliability","managed-systems"],"summary":"Distance-five logical memory modestly outperforms the average distance-three comparison in the reported experiment. Error budgets and a damaging rare event expose concrete scaling constraints.","equation":{"text":"pL(d=5)<pL(d=3)","scope":"Comparison within the reported protocol and device; not a general guarantee for every larger code."},"observables":["Logical error per cycle","Code-distance scaling","Correlated error events"],"sourceIds":["surface-code"]},{"id":"dmrg-1992","title":"White selects an effective many-body basis with a density matrix.","year":1992,"dateLabel":"Published November 1992.","kind":"algorithm","people":["Steven R. White"],"domains":["quantum-mechanics","numerical-analysis","computation"],"summary":"A density-matrix formulation improves numerical renormalization for quantum chains. Its success shows why Hilbert-space size alone does not establish that a given calculation defeats classical methods.","equation":{"text":"ρblock=Trrest|ψ⟩⟨ψ|","scope":"Retain a selected set of dominant eigenvectors; accuracy depends on truncation and state structure."},"observables":["Ground-state energy","Discarded weight","Convergence with retained states"],"sourceIds":["dmrg"]},{"id":"chemical-dynamics-2008","title":"A quantum algorithm includes electron and nuclear motion together.","year":2008,"dateLabel":"2008 PNAS publication.","kind":"algorithm","people":["Ivan Kassal","Stephen P. Jordan","Peter J. Love","Masoud Mohseni","Alán Aspuru-Guzik"],"domains":["quantum-chemistry","quantum-information"],"summary":"The proposed simulation explicitly includes interacting electrons and nuclei and identifies selected chemical observables. Efficient treatment of arbitrary input states is not assumed.","equation":{"text":"U(Δt)≈exp(−iTΔt/ℏ)exp(−iVΔt/ℏ)","scope":"Schematic first-order split operator; a complete implementation needs error, grid, and preparation bounds."},"observables":["Transition probabilities","Thermal reaction rates","Discretization error"],"sourceIds":["chemical-dynamics"]},{"id":"vqe-2014","title":"A hybrid quantum processor estimates a molecular ground-state energy.","year":2014,"dateLabel":"2013 preprint; 2014 publication.","kind":"experiment","people":["Alberto Peruzzo","Jarrod McClean","Peter Shadbolt","Man-Hong Yung","Xiao-Qi Zhou","Peter J. Love","Alán Aspuru-Guzik","Jeremy L. O'Brien"],"domains":["quantum-chemistry","quantum-information","optimization"],"summary":"A photonic demonstration combines a parameterized trial state with classical energy minimization for helium hydride. A small successful example does not establish favorable scaling for large chemistry.","equation":{"text":"E(θ)=⟨ψ(θ)|H|ψ(θ)⟩≥E0","scope":"Variational inequality for normalized trial states of the same Hamiltonian; noisy estimates require uncertainty accounting."},"observables":["Estimated energy","Measurement variance","Optimization convergence"],"sourceIds":["vqe"]},{"id":"barren-plateaus-2018","title":"McClean and colleagues identify a training barrier for random circuits.","year":2018,"dateLabel":"2018 publication.","kind":"theorem","people":["Jarrod R. McClean","Sergio Boixo","Vadim N. Smelyanskiy","Ryan Babbush","Hartmut Neven"],"domains":["quantum-information","optimization"],"summary":"For specified random-circuit families, gradients concentrate near zero as system size increases. The result motivates structured ansätze and scaling tests; it does not rule out all variational methods.","equation":{"text":"Var(∂θE) decreases exponentially in the stated regime","scope":"Circuit ensemble, cost function, and assumptions matter."},"observables":["Gradient variance","Shots needed to resolve a gradient","Scaling with qubit count"],"sourceIds":["barren-plateaus"]},{"id":"no-cloning-1982","title":"Linearity forbids universal exact copying of unknown quantum states.","year":1982,"dateLabel":"Published 28 October 1982.","kind":"theorem","people":["William K. Wootters","Wojciech H. Zurek"],"domains":["quantum-information","mathematics"],"summary":"A single device cannot perfectly clone every arbitrary unknown state. The restriction is compatible with copying a known orthogonal alphabet and with encoding information across entangled physical systems.","equation":{"text":"|s|=|s|² for an exact universal cloner","scope":"Inner-product preservation would force |s|=|⟨ψ|φ⟩| to be 0 or 1; generic nonorthogonal pairs violate that requirement."},"observables":["Copy fidelity across nonorthogonal test states"],"sourceIds":["no-cloning"]},{"id":"teleportation-1993","title":"Teleportation uses entanglement together with a classical message.","year":1993,"dateLabel":"Published March 1993.","kind":"protocol","people":["Charles H. Bennett","Gilles Brassard","Claude Crépeau","Richard Jozsa","Asher Peres","William K. Wootters"],"domains":["quantum-information","interoperability"],"summary":"A joint measurement and communicated result let the receiver reconstruct an unknown state using shared entanglement. The original state is consumed and the classical message remains necessary.","equation":{"text":"|ψ⟩A⊗|Φ+⟩BC → classical outcome m + σm|ψ⟩C","scope":"Ideal qubit protocol; correction depends on the received outcome."},"observables":["State-transfer fidelity","Entanglement quality","Classical-message arrival"],"sourceIds":["teleportation","no-cloning"]}],"edges":[{"id":"radiation-quantum","from":"planck-1900","to":"einstein-1905","type":"divergence","claim":"Quantized radiation modeling and localized light quanta are different claims.","evidence":"Planck's retrospective and Millikan's discussion distinguish the formula from the proposed mechanism.","limits":"Agreement with one relation does not uniquely establish an ontology.","sourceIds":["planck-lecture","millikan-photoelectric","einstein-light"]},{"id":"planck-bose","from":"planck-1900","to":"bose-1924","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Bose's counting supplies a statistical route to Planck's law.","evidence":"Bose's abstract constructs radiation entropy from distributions of light quanta.","limits":"It does not establish every later result for a massive Bose gas.","sourceIds":["bose-statistics"]},{"id":"einstein-millikan","from":"einstein-1905","to":"millikan-1916","type":"empirical-test","claim":"Millikan tests the frequency–energy relation.","evidence":"The original paper measures and discusses five quantitative consequences of Einstein's equation.","limits":"The author still disputed the physical explanation used to obtain it.","sourceIds":["millikan-photoelectric"]},{"id":"einstein-compton","from":"einstein-1905","to":"compton-1923","type":"empirical-test","claim":"Scattering tests a radiation-quantum account with momentum transfer.","evidence":"Compton reports angular wavelength shifts and electron recoil.","limits":"This test adds a distinct observable; it does not retroactively validate every earlier assumption.","sourceIds":["compton-scattering"]},{"id":"planck-bohr","from":"planck-1900","to":"bohr-1913","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Atomic transition frequencies use the same action constant.","evidence":"Bohr's lecture relates radiation frequency to energy differences.","limits":"Using h is a mathematical connection, not proof of identical models.","sourceIds":["bohr-lecture","planck-lecture"]},{"id":"bohr-heisenberg","from":"bohr-1913","to":"heisenberg-1925","type":"divergence","claim":"Heisenberg replaces parts of the orbital description with observable transitions.","evidence":"The inspected introduction explicitly lists failures of old quantum rules.","limits":"The hydrogen success is preserved within a changed formalism; every old claim is not retained.","sourceIds":["heisenberg-1925"]},{"id":"broglie-schrodinger","from":"broglie-1924","to":"schrodinger-1926","type":"documented-influence","claim":"Schrödinger credits de Broglie as an inspiration.","evidence":"The equivalence paper's p.735 note states the connection explicitly.","limits":"It also credits Einstein; a single edge does not exhaust the intellectual context.","sourceIds":["schrodinger-equivalence"]},{"id":"heisenberg-born-jordan","from":"heisenberg-1925","to":"born-jordan-1925","type":"documented-influence","claim":"Born and Jordan explicitly develop Heisenberg's proposal.","evidence":"Their abstract identifies the earlier approach and matrix calculus.","limits":"This supports the specified development, not every later interpretive attribution.","sourceIds":["born-jordan"]},{"id":"born-jordan-bhj","from":"born-jordan-1925","to":"bhj-1926","type":"documented-influence","claim":"The joint paper extends the earlier matrix mechanics.","evidence":"The first paper's correction note announces the collaboration; the sequel states the extension.","limits":"Received and issue dates differ and are shown separately.","sourceIds":["born-jordan","born-heisenberg-jordan"]},{"id":"bhj-equivalence","from":"bhj-1926","to":"wave-matrix-equivalence","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"The equivalence paper uses the matrix construction.","evidence":"Schrödinger cites both matrix-mechanics papers and their algebraic rules.","limits":"Representation equivalence requires the relevant completeness and domain assumptions.","sourceIds":["schrodinger-equivalence"]},{"id":"schrodinger-equivalence","from":"schrodinger-1926","to":"wave-matrix-equivalence","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Wave functions define matrix elements of operators.","evidence":"The equivalence paper explicitly constructs the connecting representation.","limits":"A basis change is not a proof that all interpretations are the same.","sourceIds":["schrodinger-equivalence"]},{"id":"heisenberg-schrodinger-origin","from":"heisenberg-1925","to":"schrodinger-1926","type":"unsupported","claim":"A direct origin story from Heisenberg to Schrödinger is not established here.","evidence":"Schrödinger acknowledges knowing the theory but denies awareness of a genetic connection to his approach.","limits":"This is the author's report, not an exhaustive judgment on all historical influence.","sourceIds":["schrodinger-equivalence"]},{"id":"broglie-diffraction","from":"broglie-1924","to":"davisson-germer-1927","type":"empirical-test","claim":"Electron diffraction tests the momentum–wavelength relation.","evidence":"The experiment compares inferred wavelengths with h/mv.","limits":"Surface films, missing weak beams, and energy range constrain the comparison.","sourceIds":["davisson-germer"]},{"id":"wave-scattering-probability","from":"schrodinger-1926","to":"born-probability","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Scattering waves become probability amplitudes.","evidence":"Born's scattering paper explicitly uses Schrödinger's form of mechanics.","limits":"A probability rule is additional interpretive structure, not a classical wave-density identity.","sourceIds":["born-scattering","born-lecture"]},{"id":"commutator-uncertainty","from":"born-jordan-1925","to":"robertson-1929","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Noncommutativity enters the variance inequality.","evidence":"The displayed inequality follows by applying Cauchy–Schwarz to centered operators.","limits":"It concerns state variances; a disturbance statement needs an explicit measurement model.","sourceIds":["born-jordan","robertson"]},{"id":"wave-hilbert","from":"wave-matrix-equivalence","to":"von-neumann-1932","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"A common operator language accommodates alternative representations.","evidence":"The Hilbert-space monograph and later measurement treatment use states and operators.","limits":"This is a formal relationship; complete historical transmission is not inferred from chronology.","sourceIds":["von-neumann","schrodinger-equivalence","zeh"]},{"id":"probability-density","from":"born-probability","to":"von-neumann-1932","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Density operators generalize pure-state probability predictions.","evidence":"Zeh explicitly uses the density-matrix formalism for statistical measurement states.","limits":"An improper reduced mixture and ignorance about an actual pure state need not share an interpretation.","sourceIds":["zeh","von-neumann"]},{"id":"wave-dirac","from":"schrodinger-1926","to":"dirac-electron-1928","type":"divergence","claim":"Dirac changes the equation to meet relativistic and spin requirements.","evidence":"The 1928 introduction identifies discrepancies and the need for a relativistic Hamiltonian.","limits":"The nonrelativistic equation remains useful within its domain.","sourceIds":["dirac-electron"]},{"id":"field-occupation","from":"bose-1924","to":"dirac-radiation-1927","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Photon occupation connects radiation statistics with quantized modes.","evidence":"The two works treat radiation quanta and emission/absorption; the displayed mode equation makes the formal relationship explicit.","limits":"This edge is a mathematical comparison, not a verified personal transmission claim.","sourceIds":["bose-statistics","dirac-radiation"]},{"id":"transition-field","from":"bohr-1913","to":"dirac-radiation-1927","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Field quantization addresses processes between atomic energy levels.","evidence":"Bohr supplies transition conditions; Dirac's paper treats emission and absorption.","limits":"A transition-frequency rule alone does not provide a complete transition rate.","sourceIds":["bohr-lecture","dirac-radiation"]},{"id":"wave-molecules","from":"schrodinger-1926","to":"born-oppenheimer-1927","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"The molecular approximation separates a many-particle wave problem.","evidence":"The molecular paper cites Schrödinger; the later dynamics paper makes the electron–nuclear alternative explicit.","limits":"Near-coupled electronic surfaces require corrections.","sourceIds":["born-oppenheimer","chemical-dynamics"]},{"id":"schrodinger-heitler-london","from":"schrodinger-1926","to":"heitler-london-1927","type":"documented-influence","claim":"Heitler and London acknowledge Schrödinger's support.","evidence":"The original acknowledgment names his constructive interest in their work.","limits":"Acknowledgment supports this research relationship, not sole intellectual credit.","sourceIds":["heitler-london"]},{"id":"bo-hl-comparison","from":"born-oppenheimer-1927","to":"heitler-london-1927","type":"analogy","claim":"The two approaches isolate different parts of molecular complexity.","evidence":"One separates electronic and nuclear motion; the other examines exchange in bonding.","limits":"Same-year molecular work does not establish one paper caused the other.","sourceIds":["born-oppenheimer","heitler-london"]},{"id":"wave-hartree","from":"schrodinger-1926","to":"hartree-1928","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Hartree solves a practical central-field wave equation.","evidence":"The original extract explicitly states the Schrödinger eigenvalue problem and numerical matching method.","limits":"A central field is an approximation to the full many-electron problem.","sourceIds":["hartree"]},{"id":"hartree-fock","from":"hartree-1928","to":"fock-1930","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Exchange modifies the self-consistent mean-field construction.","evidence":"The Hartree and Fock methods are identified in the primary Kohn–Sham discussion.","limits":"This graph does not reproduce the full 1930 derivation or prove its exactness.","sourceIds":["hartree","fock","kohn-sham"]},{"id":"exchange-hf","from":"heitler-london-1927","to":"fock-1930","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Fermionic exchange constrains both molecular and mean-field states.","evidence":"Heitler–London explicitly applies the Pauli principle; Fock supplies an antisymmetric approximation.","limits":"Shared symmetry is a formal relation, not evidence of a specific personal influence.","sourceIds":["heitler-london","fock"]},{"id":"commutators-epr","from":"born-jordan-1925","to":"epr-1935","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"EPR's argument depends on noncommuting observables.","evidence":"The EPR abstract makes noncommutation central to simultaneous reality and completeness.","limits":"Noncommutation alone does not establish EPR's additional reality and locality premises.","sourceIds":["epr"]},{"id":"epr-bohr","from":"epr-1935","to":"bohr-reply-1935","type":"divergence","claim":"Bohr directly disputes EPR's criterion of reality.","evidence":"Bohr cites EPR and identifies an ambiguity in applying the criterion.","limits":"A conceptual reply is not an independent laboratory test.","sourceIds":["bohr-epr"]},{"id":"born-bohm","from":"born-probability","to":"bohm-1952","type":"divergence","claim":"Bohm keeps the quantum statistics while changing the underlying description.","evidence":"Bohm's abstract claims the same observable results under its formulation.","limits":"Empirical equivalence in the stated regime does not establish identical ontology.","sourceIds":["bohm"]},{"id":"epr-bell","from":"epr-1935","to":"bell-1964","type":"documented-influence","claim":"Bell explicitly reformulates the EPR problem.","evidence":"The paper's introduction and title identify the motivation.","limits":"The result constrains a specified class of local explanations.","sourceIds":["bell"]},{"id":"bohm-bell","from":"bohm-1952","to":"bell-1964","type":"documented-influence","claim":"Bell uses Bohm's construction to delimit hidden-variable claims.","evidence":"The introduction cites an explicit nonlocal hidden-variable theory.","limits":"The theorem does not rule out all deterministic theories.","sourceIds":["bell"]},{"id":"bell-chsh","from":"bell-1964","to":"chsh-1969","type":"documented-influence","claim":"CHSH generalizes Bell's theorem for practical experiments.","evidence":"The CHSH abstract states this aim directly.","limits":"A realizable test still needs a valid sampling and space–time protocol.","sourceIds":["chsh"]},{"id":"chsh-aspect","from":"chsh-1969","to":"aspect-1982","type":"empirical-test","claim":"Photon correlations test Bell-type constraints with changing settings.","evidence":"Aspect and colleagues report time-varying analyzers and inequality violation.","limits":"The exact tested statistic and experimental assumptions must accompany any numerical comparison.","sourceIds":["aspect","chsh"]},{"id":"bell-hensen","from":"bell-1964","to":"hensen-2015","type":"empirical-test","claim":"Separated electron spins provide a stronger test of local constraints.","evidence":"The Hensen protocol addresses detection and locality concerns jointly.","limits":"Setting independence and statistical inference remain assumptions of the test.","sourceIds":["hensen"]},{"id":"aspect-hensen","from":"aspect-1982","to":"hensen-2015","type":"divergence","claim":"Later tests change the protocol to address earlier loopholes jointly.","evidence":"The experimental papers describe different platforms and selection conditions.","limits":"This is methodological refinement, not a claim that the earlier data were false.","sourceIds":["aspect","hensen"]},{"id":"von-neumann-everett","from":"von-neumann-1932","to":"everett-1957","type":"divergence","claim":"Relative states offer a different treatment of system–observer correlations.","evidence":"Everett's formulation and Zeh's discussion both address the quantum description of measurement.","limits":"A common mathematical setup does not settle the interpretation.","sourceIds":["everett","zeh","von-neumann"]},{"id":"measurement-zeh","from":"von-neumann-1932","to":"zeh-1970","type":"documented-influence","claim":"Zeh explicitly analyzes a von Neumann measurement interaction.","evidence":"The inspected paper names that coupling and writes the resulting correlated state.","limits":"The argument concerns a model; actual apparatus dynamics require further specification.","sourceIds":["zeh"]},{"id":"everett-decoherence","from":"everett-1957","to":"zeh-1970","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Unitary system–record correlations are compatible with reduced-state analysis.","evidence":"Both descriptions retain a combined quantum state while considering conditional or reduced descriptions.","limits":"Compatibility does not make decoherence exclusive to one interpretation.","sourceIds":["everett","zeh"]},{"id":"zeh-zurek","from":"zeh-1970","to":"zurek-2003","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Environmental entanglement underlies pointer-state decoherence models.","evidence":"The papers connect reduced states to interaction with surrounding degrees of freedom.","limits":"Suppression of local interference alone does not prove a unique-outcome ontology.","sourceIds":["zeh","zurek"]},{"id":"density-lindblad","from":"von-neumann-1932","to":"lindblad-1976","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Open-system evolution acts on density operators.","evidence":"Lindblad derives bounded generators of completely positive semigroups.","limits":"Unbounded generators and non-Markovian dynamics require additional analysis.","sourceIds":["lindblad"]},{"id":"lindblad-decoherence","from":"lindblad-1976","to":"zurek-2003","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"A Markovian generator can model a specified decoherence process.","evidence":"The master-equation framework supplies a dynamical realization of reduced-state decay.","limits":"The approximation must be checked against bath memory and coupling conditions.","sourceIds":["lindblad","zurek"]},{"id":"dirac-dyson","from":"dirac-radiation-1927","to":"dyson-1949","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Radiation quantization supports interacting QED calculations.","evidence":"The works address quantized radiation and its interactions at different levels of development.","limits":"This edge does not claim a complete derivation or convergence of the interacting theory.","sourceIds":["dirac-radiation","dyson-qed"]},{"id":"dirac-electron-qed","from":"dirac-electron-1928","to":"dyson-1949","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Relativistic electron dynamics enters the radiation theory.","evidence":"Dirac's electron construction and Dyson's radiative corrections concern compatible ingredients.","limits":"A free electron equation does not alone define renormalized QED.","sourceIds":["dirac-electron","dyson-qed"]},{"id":"dyson-yang-mills","from":"dyson-1949","to":"yang-mills-1954","type":"documented-influence","claim":"Yang and Mills cite Dyson's QED papers.","evidence":"The original reference list includes the 1949 radiation-theory work.","limits":"A citation establishes engagement; it does not quantify every component of influence.","sourceIds":["yang-mills"]},{"id":"yangmills-gross","from":"yang-mills-1954","to":"gross-wilczek-1973","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Non-Abelian gauge dynamics permits the ultraviolet calculation.","evidence":"Gross–Wilczek analyzes this class of gauge theories.","limits":"Asymptotic freedom depends on group and matter content.","sourceIds":["gross-wilczek"]},{"id":"yangmills-politzer","from":"yang-mills-1954","to":"politzer-1973","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Politzer calculates the ultraviolet behavior of Yang–Mills systems.","evidence":"The primary abstract identifies the theory class explicitly.","limits":"An ultraviolet expansion does not establish nonperturbative infrared behavior.","sourceIds":["politzer"]},{"id":"af-convergence","from":"gross-wilczek-1973","to":"politzer-1973","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Independent calculations converge on ultraviolet weakening.","evidence":"Both primary papers, published the same day, report compatible gauge-theory behavior.","limits":"This comparison does not infer collaboration from the shared date.","sourceIds":["gross-wilczek","politzer"]},{"id":"rg-asymptotic","from":"wilson-rg-1971","to":"gross-wilczek-1973","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Scale-dependent couplings organize the ultraviolet result.","evidence":"Fixed-point flow and logarithmic running provide a formal common language.","limits":"Different physical theories need their own beta functions and admissible limits.","sourceIds":["wilson-rg","gross-wilczek"]},{"id":"yangmills-lattice","from":"yang-mills-1954","to":"wilson-lattice-1974","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Lattice link variables regulate gauge fields while retaining gauge invariance.","evidence":"Wilson explicitly quantizes Abelian and non-Abelian gauge theories on a lattice.","limits":"Discrete symmetry preservation does not automatically recover continuum rotation invariance.","sourceIds":["wilson-lattice"]},{"id":"rg-lattice","from":"wilson-rg-1971","to":"wilson-lattice-1974","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Changing resolution motivates a controlled continuum limit.","evidence":"The two papers supply scale flow and a regulated gauge formulation.","limits":"This is a formal comparison, not a claim that one finite strong-coupling result proves the continuum theory.","sourceIds":["wilson-rg","wilson-lattice"]},{"id":"euclidean-lattice","from":"osterwalder-schrader-1973","to":"wilson-lattice-1974","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"A Euclidean lattice program needs suitable reconstruction properties.","evidence":"The sources distinguish Euclidean functions, positivity, and lattice regulation.","limits":"The graph states a proof requirement; it does not claim that all required axioms have been verified.","sourceIds":["osterwalder-schrader","wilson-lattice"]},{"id":"lattice-qcd","from":"wilson-lattice-1974","to":"pacs-cs-2008","type":"engineering-transfer","claim":"A regulated gauge framework becomes a numerical QCD calculation.","evidence":"PACS-CS specifies a lattice action, volume, spacing, and algorithm.","limits":"Model calibration, quark masses, finite volume, and discretization affect the result.","sourceIds":["pacs-cs","wilson-lattice"]},{"id":"asymptotic-lattice","from":"gross-wilczek-1973","to":"pacs-cs-2008","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Short-distance running and lattice calibration describe different scales of gauge dynamics.","evidence":"The papers address ultraviolet behavior and hadronic-scale simulation.","limits":"Connecting regimes requires matching and controlled extrapolation, not a visual analogy.","sourceIds":["gross-wilczek","pacs-cs"]},{"id":"lattice-reconstruction-limit","from":"pacs-cs-2008","to":"osterwalder-schrader-1973","type":"unsupported","claim":"A finite simulation does not establish a continuum existence or mass-gap theorem.","evidence":"The numerical paper reports finite parameters; the axiomatic paper imposes additional mathematical conditions.","limits":"This rejects the inference, not the scientific value of the simulation.","sourceIds":["pacs-cs","osterwalder-schrader"]},{"id":"bo-density","from":"born-oppenheimer-1927","to":"hohenberg-kohn-1964","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Fixed nuclear coordinates provide an external potential for an electronic density problem.","evidence":"The molecular separation and density functional address compatible levels of description.","limits":"The density theorem itself does not require every molecular approximation used in practice.","sourceIds":["born-oppenheimer","hohenberg-kohn"]},{"id":"hk-ks","from":"hohenberg-kohn-1964","to":"kohn-sham-1965","type":"documented-influence","claim":"Kohn and Sham explicitly develop methods from Hohenberg–Kohn theory.","evidence":"The first sentence of their abstract identifies that starting point.","limits":"An existence theorem and an approximate usable functional are different deliverables.","sourceIds":["kohn-sham"]},{"id":"hartree-ks","from":"hartree-1928","to":"kohn-sham-1965","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Self-consistent orbital equations connect the numerical strategies.","evidence":"Kohn–Sham explicitly compares its equations with Hartree and Hartree–Fock.","limits":"The effective potentials and meanings of the orbitals differ.","sourceIds":["kohn-sham"]},{"id":"fock-ks","from":"fock-1930","to":"kohn-sham-1965","type":"divergence","claim":"Density-functional approximations treat exchange and correlation differently from a single-determinant mean field.","evidence":"Kohn–Sham describes additional effective potentials and compares prior equations.","limits":"Neither approximation is uniformly superior for every observable or system.","sourceIds":["kohn-sham"]},{"id":"shannon-landauer","from":"shannon-1948","to":"landauer-1961","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"A specified logical distribution determines an entropy reduction to account for physically.","evidence":"Communication entropy and erasure thermodynamics share probability-based accounting.","limits":"Equating bits with heat requires a physical model, temperature, and boundary conditions.","sourceIds":["shannon","landauer"]},{"id":"landauer-bennett","from":"landauer-1961","to":"bennett-1973","type":"divergence","claim":"Bennett separates computing from logically irreversible erasure.","evidence":"Reversible simulation preserves information that an irreversible map would discard.","limits":"Logical reversibility is not a guarantee of zero practical dissipation.","sourceIds":["bennett","landauer"]},{"id":"bennett-deutsch","from":"bennett-1973","to":"deutsch-1985","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Reversible information flow is compatible with unitary computation.","evidence":"The reversible embedding and unitary model both preserve information before readout.","limits":"This is a structural relation, not a documented personal-influence claim.","sourceIds":["bennett","deutsch"]},{"id":"feynman-deutsch","from":"feynman-1982","to":"deutsch-1985","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Physical simulation becomes a question within a universal quantum model.","evidence":"The papers frame quantum simulation and universal computation.","limits":"Universality alone does not imply efficient solution of every physical or mathematical problem.","sourceIds":["feynman","deutsch"]},{"id":"deutsch-shor","from":"deutsch-1985","to":"shor-1994","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Shor's algorithms operate within a quantum computational model.","evidence":"The algorithm gives polynomial quantum procedures for specified arithmetic tasks.","limits":"The result is problem-specific and depends on coherent, accurate operations.","sourceIds":["shor-algorithm","deutsch"]},{"id":"deutsch-grover","from":"deutsch-1985","to":"grover-1996","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Unitary interference supports amplitude amplification.","evidence":"Grover describes phase operations that increase marked-outcome probability.","limits":"The query model does not provide free access to arbitrary real datasets.","sourceIds":["grover"]},{"id":"shor-grover","from":"shor-1994","to":"grover-1996","type":"divergence","claim":"The algorithms solve different problems under different complexity measures.","evidence":"Shor supplies quantum polynomial time for factoring; Grover supplies a quadratic oracle-query improvement.","limits":"No unconditional superpolynomial classical factoring lower bound is supplied, and neither result resolves P versus NP.","sourceIds":["shor-algorithm","grover"]},{"id":"unitarity-cloning","from":"deutsch-1985","to":"no-cloning-1982","type":"analogy","claim":"Unitary computation and no-cloning share a constraint from linear evolution.","evidence":"The no-cloning argument uses linearity; a quantum computational step obeys the same underlying structure.","limits":"No-cloning does not depend on Deutsch's later model. This is a comparison of shared constraints, not a historical or theorem-dependency claim.","sourceIds":["no-cloning","deutsch"]},{"id":"nocloning-qec","from":"no-cloning-1982","to":"shor-code-1995","type":"divergence","claim":"Quantum error correction encodes rather than making independent clones.","evidence":"Shor's code protects amplitudes using correlated code states.","limits":"A classical repetition-code metaphor fails if read as copying arbitrary quantum states.","sourceIds":["shor-code","no-cloning"]},{"id":"decoherence-code","from":"zurek-2003","to":"shor-code-1995","type":"engineering-transfer","claim":"A description of decoherence motivates measurable protection requirements.","evidence":"Shor explicitly identifies decoherence as a computational obstacle; Zurek details the mechanism.","limits":"This is a conceptual engineering connection, not a claim that the 2003 review caused the 1995 code.","sourceIds":["shor-code","zurek"]},{"id":"qec-fault","from":"shor-code-1995","to":"shor-fault-1996","type":"documented-influence","claim":"Fault-tolerant computation extends previously developed quantum codes.","evidence":"The 1996 abstract distinguishes protecting memory from operating on encoded data.","limits":"Gate-induced propagation adds constraints absent from storage alone.","sourceIds":["shor-fault-tolerance","shor-code"]},{"id":"fault-threshold","from":"shor-fault-1996","to":"threshold-1997","type":"documented-influence","claim":"The constant-threshold result explicitly improves on Shor's scaling bound.","evidence":"Aharonov–Ben-Or identifies the earlier inverse-polylogarithmic requirement.","limits":"The stronger theorem still has defined locality and architecture assumptions.","sourceIds":["aharonov-benor","shor-fault-tolerance"]},{"id":"threshold-surface","from":"threshold-1997","to":"surface-code-2023","type":"empirical-test","claim":"Logical-error scaling tests a necessary behavior for scalable error correction.","evidence":"The experiment compares code distances and reports error budgets.","limits":"It tests a device and code family, not every premise of an abstract threshold construction.","sourceIds":["surface-code","aharonov-benor"]},{"id":"lindblad-qec","from":"lindblad-1976","to":"shor-code-1995","type":"engineering-transfer","claim":"A specified open-system noise model can be compared with a code's error assumptions.","evidence":"Lindblad supplies dynamical channels; Shor's construction assumes local independent decoherence.","limits":"Correlated or non-Markovian noise needs separate analysis.","sourceIds":["lindblad","shor-code"]},{"id":"shor-hardware","from":"shor-1994","to":"surface-code-2023","type":"engineering-transfer","claim":"Algorithmic promises impose reliability requirements on hardware.","evidence":"The surface-code paper explicitly cites factoring as a motivating application.","limits":"A memory scaling experiment is not an implementation of large-scale factoring.","sourceIds":["surface-code","shor-algorithm"]},{"id":"rg-dmrg","from":"wilson-rg-1971","to":"dmrg-1992","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Effective descriptions at reduced resolution organize numerical many-body methods.","evidence":"White explicitly generalizes Wilson's numerical renormalization procedure.","limits":"The directly credited antecedent is Wilson's Kondo method, not an identity with the 1971 critical-phenomena calculation.","sourceIds":["dmrg","wilson-rg"]},{"id":"density-dmrg","from":"von-neumann-1932","to":"dmrg-1992","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Reduced density matrices select an effective block basis.","evidence":"White's construction uses density-matrix eigenvectors for truncation.","limits":"Good compression depends on the target state and retained basis.","sourceIds":["dmrg"]},{"id":"feynman-dmrg","from":"feynman-1982","to":"dmrg-1992","type":"divergence","claim":"Efficient classical approximations limit broad claims based only on Hilbert-space size.","evidence":"White demonstrates effective numerical treatment of structured quantum chains.","limits":"A useful classical method does not imply efficient simulation of all quantum systems.","sourceIds":["dmrg","feynman"]},{"id":"feynman-chemistry","from":"feynman-1982","to":"chemical-dynamics-2008","type":"engineering-transfer","claim":"Quantum simulation is specialized to molecular dynamics and chemical observables.","evidence":"Kassal and collaborators specify electron–nuclear evolution and selected readout tasks.","limits":"Preparation, discretization, accuracy, and measurement costs must be included.","sourceIds":["chemical-dynamics","feynman"]},{"id":"bo-chemical-dynamics","from":"born-oppenheimer-1927","to":"chemical-dynamics-2008","type":"divergence","claim":"Joint electron–nuclear simulation can avoid a fixed-surface approximation.","evidence":"The chemical-dynamics paper explicitly compares its method with Born–Oppenheimer treatment.","limits":"Its resource claims apply to the specified algorithm and state classes.","sourceIds":["chemical-dynamics"]},{"id":"hartree-vqe","from":"hartree-1928","to":"vqe-2014","type":"analogy","claim":"Both methods turn an eigenvalue problem into a manageable numerical procedure.","evidence":"Hartree matches radial solutions; VQE optimizes a chosen quantum-state family.","limits":"This is a comparison of problem organization, not evidence of a historical causal link.","sourceIds":["hartree","vqe"]},{"id":"chemistry-vqe","from":"chemical-dynamics-2008","to":"vqe-2014","type":"engineering-transfer","claim":"Molecular quantum computation includes both dynamics and ground-state estimation.","evidence":"The papers specify different chemical tasks and preparation strategies.","limits":"Success at one task does not establish efficient performance at the other.","sourceIds":["chemical-dynamics","vqe"]},{"id":"hk-vqe","from":"hohenberg-kohn-1964","to":"vqe-2014","type":"analogy","claim":"Variational principles support two different representations of an energy search.","evidence":"Hohenberg–Kohn varies admissible densities; VQE varies parameterized quantum states.","limits":"The same word 'variational' does not make the ansätze, errors, or algorithms equivalent.","sourceIds":["hohenberg-kohn","vqe"]},{"id":"vqe-barren","from":"vqe-2014","to":"barren-plateaus-2018","type":"divergence","claim":"A successful small demonstration does not guarantee trainable large random circuits.","evidence":"McClean and collaborators establish gradient concentration in specified circuit ensembles.","limits":"Structured circuits may behave differently; the theorem is not a universal impossibility result.","sourceIds":["barren-plateaus","vqe"]},{"id":"qec-vqe","from":"shor-code-1995","to":"vqe-2014","type":"divergence","claim":"Error protection and short coherent circuits address different resource constraints.","evidence":"Shor encodes information; VQE reduces coherent-evolution requirements through a hybrid procedure.","limits":"Shorter coherence demands do not remove sampling, bias, or optimization error.","sourceIds":["shor-code","vqe"]},{"id":"epr-teleport","from":"epr-1935","to":"teleportation-1993","type":"engineering-transfer","claim":"Entanglement becomes a resource in a concrete communication protocol.","evidence":"The teleportation paper explicitly combines EPR correlations with classical information.","limits":"The protocol consumes an input state and requires a classical message.","sourceIds":["teleportation"]},{"id":"nocloning-teleport","from":"no-cloning-1982","to":"teleportation-1993","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"State transfer does not leave two independent perfect copies.","evidence":"The protocol destroys the sender's original state while enabling reconstruction.","limits":"A metaphor of instant duplication is incompatible with the actual protocol.","sourceIds":["teleportation","no-cloning"]},{"id":"bell-teleport","from":"bell-1964","to":"teleportation-1993","type":"divergence","claim":"Nonclassical correlations do not remove communication requirements.","evidence":"The teleportation protocol explicitly requires the sender's classical measurement result.","limits":"Bell violation alone is not a faster-than-light messaging channel.","sourceIds":["teleportation","bell"]},{"id":"information-records","from":"shannon-1948","to":"zurek-2003","type":"mathematical-dependency","claim":"Records can be analyzed through correlations and information about outcomes.","evidence":"Zurek describes stable correlations retained under environmental monitoring.","limits":"An information measure needs a specified ensemble and does not assign metaphysical meaning.","sourceIds":["zurek","shannon"]},{"id":"surface-managed-systems","from":"shannon-1948","to":"surface-code-2023","type":"analogy","claim":"Reliability improves only when an observed error model supports the redundancy strategy.","evidence":"Coding and the surface-code experiment both compare information protection against noise.","limits":"Classical and quantum error models differ; redundancy by itself is not a guarantee.","sourceIds":["shannon","surface-code"]},{"id":"coptic-witness-comparison","from":"nag-hammadi-witness","to":"coptic-hermetica","type":"analogy","claim":"Physical collection membership provides an inspectable historical adjacency.","evidence":"Brill's inventory distinguishes the texts and their codex locations.","limits":"The edge records coexistence in the collection, not common authorship or identical doctrine.","sourceIds":["nag-hammadi-iv","coptic-library"]},{"id":"hermetic-coptic","from":"hermetic-dialogue","to":"coptic-hermetica","type":"analogy","claim":"Greek and Coptic Hermetic writings form a documented textual comparison.","evidence":"The critical edition identifies Coptic Hermetica and overlapping previously known writings.","limits":"The collection-level relationship does not establish direct copying from the inspected Corpus Hermeticum I passage.","sourceIds":["hermetica-ii","coptic-library"]},{"id":"ancient-modern-principles","from":"hermetic-dialogue","to":"kybalion-1908","type":"divergence","claim":"The modern seven-principle system is not the same source as the ancient dialogue.","evidence":"The dated modern edition and critical ancient edition are separately identifiable.","limits":"Ancient attribution within the modern book does not independently prove its claimed lineage.","sourceIds":["hermetica","kybalion","kybalion-catalog"]},{"id":"kybalion-quantum-origin","from":"kybalion-1908","to":"schrodinger-1926","type":"unsupported","claim":"A causal link from the Kybalion to Schrödinger's equation is not established in this corpus.","evidence":"The inspected primary physics paper identifies de Broglie and Einstein as inspirations.","limits":"Absence in this bounded search is not proof that no uninspected contact ever occurred.","sourceIds":["kybalion","schrodinger-equivalence"]},{"id":"gnosis-measurement","from":"nag-hammadi-witness","to":"von-neumann-1932","type":"analogy","claim":"Questions about knowing can generate a comparison with measurement records.","evidence":"The manuscript is a textual witness; the measurement model specifies systems, interactions, and outcomes.","limits":"Shared epistemic vocabulary does not establish a common physical mechanism or historical influence.","sourceIds":["nag-hammadi-iv","zeh"]},{"id":"mentalism-collapse","from":"kybalion-1908","to":"zurek-2003","type":"unsupported","claim":"Mentalism does not establish a consciousness-induced collapse mechanism.","evidence":"The modern text makes a metaphysical claim; decoherence models specify physical system–environment interactions.","limits":"A proposed new mechanism must add operational predictions and survive a discriminating test.","sourceIds":["kybalion","zurek"]},{"id":"correspondence-scale","from":"kybalion-1908","to":"wilson-rg-1971","type":"analogy","claim":"Correspondence can prompt a test of whether two scales share a defined transformation.","evidence":"Wilson's equations provide variables, flow, and fixed-point conditions for such a test.","limits":"Similarity of words or pictures is insufficient; scaling predictions can fail.","sourceIds":["kybalion","wilson-rg"]},{"id":"vibration-spectrum","from":"kybalion-1908","to":"bohr-1913","type":"analogy","claim":"A claim of vibration can be translated into a request for a measurable spectrum.","evidence":"Bohr's transition relation assigns frequencies to specified energy differences.","limits":"A stationary density need not visibly oscillate; spiritual 'frequency' has no physical unit until defined.","sourceIds":["kybalion","bohr-lecture"]},{"id":"polarity-commutator","from":"kybalion-1908","to":"born-jordan-1925","type":"unsupported","claim":"A pair of verbal opposites does not imply a quantum conjugate pair.","evidence":"The commutator is a defined algebraic operation; the principle is a verbal classification.","limits":"One must identify actual operators and test their algebra.","sourceIds":["kybalion","born-jordan"]},{"id":"rhythm-markov","from":"kybalion-1908","to":"lindblad-1976","type":"analogy","claim":"Rhythm can prompt a search for oscillatory modes in a dynamics model.","evidence":"A generator's spectrum can distinguish oscillation from relaxation.","limits":"Exponential decay and incommensurate modes provide counterexamples to a universal repeating-period claim.","sourceIds":["kybalion","lindblad"]},{"id":"causation-bell","from":"kybalion-1908","to":"bell-1964","type":"analogy","claim":"A general interest in causation can become a precise test of a local response model.","evidence":"Bell specifies mathematical assumptions and a correlation constraint.","limits":"A metaphysical causation principle does not select which statistical causal assumptions hold.","sourceIds":["kybalion","bell"]},{"id":"gender-spin","from":"kybalion-1908","to":"dirac-electron-1928","type":"unsupported","claim":"The book's gender principle does not identify the electron's spin components.","evidence":"Dirac's construction uses relativistic algebra and observable spectral structure.","limits":"Biological or symbolic gender labels add no tested prediction to that algebra.","sourceIds":["kybalion","dirac-electron"]},{"id":"textual-diff-model-diff","from":"nag-hammadi-witness","to":"wave-matrix-equivalence","type":"analogy","claim":"Comparing versions requires preserving what each version actually asserts.","evidence":"Textual witnesses and mathematical representations both require explicit comparison units.","limits":"A translation variant and an operator equivalence are different evidential operations.","sourceIds":["nag-hammadi-iv","schrodinger-equivalence"]}],"cases":[{"id":"radiation","title":"A successful equation can survive a dispute about its explanation.","period":"1900–1924","question":"What changed when radiation became a quantum problem?","paragraphs":["Planck's account connects thermal-radiation measurements with entropy and probability. The action constant became useful across phenomena, but a compact formula did not immediately supply a complete microscopic theory. The upstream inputs were measured spectral limits and statistical reasoning; the downstream work needed additional claims about emission, absorption, and momentum.","Einstein's light-quantum proposal made a frequency–energy relation testable. Millikan then separated two questions in the same paper: whether the equation fitted carefully corrected measurements and whether its proposed explanation was acceptable. His agreement with the relation and disagreement with the mechanism are both preserved here. A graph that labels this entire episode 'confirmation' would erase the actual divergence.","Compton added a different observable: wavelength shift as a function of scattering angle, with recoil accounting. Bose supplied a counting argument for thermal photons. These are connected developments, but neither same-era activity nor use of the same constant makes them interchangeable evidence.","For a new model, reproduce all three kinds of comparison separately: thermal spectrum, photoelectric stopping potential, and recoil kinematics. Fit parameters on one regime, reserve another for prediction, and record surface corrections, instrumental uncertainty, and the free-electron approximation. A model that matches one curve and fails the held-out observable has not unified the phenomena."],"nodeIds":["planck-1900","einstein-1905","millikan-1916","compton-1923","bose-1924"],"edgeIds":["radiation-quantum","planck-bose","einstein-millikan","einstein-compton"],"equationChanges":[{"before":"A classical thermal spectrum must be compared with measured limits.","after":"uν=8πhν³/[c³(exp(hν/kBT)−1)].","meaning":"The new functional form connects frequency and temperature through h; it is not the whole quantum theory.","sourceIds":["planck-lecture"]},{"before":"The energy delivered to an electron needs an operational prediction.","after":"eVs=hν−Φ; Δλ=h(1−cosθ)/(mec).","meaning":"Separate apparatuses test separate relations, with distinct material and kinematic assumptions.","sourceIds":["millikan-photoelectric","compton-scattering"]}],"observables":["Spectral radiance","Stopping potential","Threshold frequency","Angular wavelength shift","Recoil energy"],"nextStep":"Build a linked set of plots with uncertainty bars and a toggle for the approximation used. Require a proposed common mechanism to predict data outside the calibration set.","sourceIds":["planck-lecture","einstein-light","millikan-photoelectric","compton-scattering","bose-statistics"]},{"id":"mechanics","title":"Different mathematical starting points can lead to compatible predictions.","period":"1913–1932","question":"Which relationships are influence, which are equivalence, and which are new interpretation?","paragraphs":["Bohr organized atomic line frequencies through stationary states and transitions. Heisenberg's 1925 introduction lists concrete failures of the older quantum rules and proposes a description in terms of observable transition quantities. Born and Jordan explicitly turn that approach into matrix mechanics; their sequel with Heisenberg extends it to many coordinates and perturbation theory.","Schrödinger takes a different route through an eigenvalue problem. His first paper credits mathematical help from Weyl; the equivalence paper credits de Broglie and Einstein while denying awareness of a genetic connection to Heisenberg's starting point. This is unusually useful evidence because it distinguishes documented inspiration from a later mathematical connection.","The representation map connects wave functions and matrix elements, but it does not tell us what the wave means. Born's scattering interpretation supplies probabilities, and von Neumann provides an operator language. Robertson's variance inequality is then a precise consequence of inner-product geometry, with conditions on the state and operators.","An implementation should show an oscillator or another explicitly solvable system in both bases, compare eigenvalues and selected matrix elements, and vary the basis truncation. Agreement after convergence tests demonstrates the represented calculation. It does not establish that every philosophical reading of the model is equivalent, or that a finite truncation preserves every operator identity."],"nodeIds":["bohr-1913","heisenberg-1925","born-jordan-1925","bhj-1926","schrodinger-1926","wave-matrix-equivalence","born-probability","robertson-1929","von-neumann-1932"],"edgeIds":["bohr-heisenberg","heisenberg-born-jordan","born-jordan-bhj","broglie-schrodinger","bhj-equivalence","schrodinger-equivalence","heisenberg-schrodinger-origin","commutator-uncertainty"],"equationChanges":[{"before":"Classical coordinate multiplication commutes.","after":"[X,P]=iℏI.","meaning":"Changing the algebra changes the admissible relationships between observables.","sourceIds":["born-jordan"]},{"before":"A wave equation and a transition matrix look different.","after":"Anm=⟨ψn|A|ψm⟩.","meaning":"An explicit representation map is stronger evidence than similar vocabulary or a shared prediction at one parameter value.","sourceIds":["schrodinger-equivalence"]},{"before":"Uncertainty is described only verbally.","after":"σAσB≥|⟨[A,B]⟩|/2.","meaning":"A variance statement can be derived and tested on repeated preparations; a disturbance model is a separate construction.","sourceIds":["robertson"]}],"observables":["Energy spectrum","Transition matrix elements","Outcome frequencies","Variance products","Truncation error"],"nextStep":"Use one model in two numerical representations and publish convergence diagnostics. Label inspiration, algebraic equivalence, and interpretation as separate edges.","sourceIds":["bohr-lecture","heisenberg-1925","born-jordan","born-heisenberg-jordan","schrodinger-eigenvalue","schrodinger-equivalence","born-scattering","born-lecture","robertson","von-neumann"]},{"id":"fields","title":"Relativity and interacting fields add new constraints.","period":"1927–1954","question":"What does an improved formalism explain, and what does it still leave unproved?","paragraphs":["Dirac's electron paper begins with observed spectral structure and a requirement that the Hamiltonian fit relativity and quantum transformation theory. Its spinor structure changes the mathematical substrate. Quantized radiation is a separate construction that allows occupation to change during emission and absorption; a single-particle wave equation and a quantum field are not synonyms.","Dyson's 1949 paper connects the approaches of Tomonaga, Schwinger, and Feynman and simplifies radiative calculations. Its abstract is also an explicit limit on overclaiming: it does not attempt a general convergence proof of higher-order effects. Practical predictive success and a complete existence theorem are different forms of achievement.","Yang and Mills then formulate local isotopic gauge invariance. The resulting nonlinear field equations are not just electromagnetism with names changed. Their source explicitly cites earlier QED work, supporting an engagement edge; later use in other gauge theories requires its own group, matter content, and assumptions.","A useful research comparison should preserve the symmetry, the state space, and the observable being calculated. If a proposed cross-domain mapping changes any of these, write the change as an additional assumption. Numerical agreement for a selected perturbative order should include the regulator, renormalization convention, truncation, and uncertainty that made the comparison meaningful."],"nodeIds":["dirac-radiation-1927","dirac-electron-1928","dyson-1949","yang-mills-1954"],"edgeIds":["transition-field","dirac-dyson","dirac-electron-qed","dyson-yang-mills","wave-dirac"],"equationChanges":[{"before":"A nonrelativistic scalar wave equation describes a restricted regime.","after":"(iℏγμ∂μ−mc)ψ=0.","meaning":"Relativistic spinor structure changes the representation and constraints; interactions require further work.","sourceIds":["dirac-electron"]},{"before":"An Abelian field strength contains derivative terms.","after":"Fμν=∂μAν−∂νAμ−ig[Aμ,Aν].","meaning":"The commutator term expresses non-Abelian self-interaction in the stated convention.","sourceIds":["yang-mills"]}],"observables":["Fine structure","Radiative corrections","Gauge-invariant correlation functions","Dependence on perturbative order"],"nextStep":"Compare a concrete observable at increasing orders or resolutions. Keep formal-series agreement, regulator removal, and nonperturbative existence as separate verification tasks.","sourceIds":["dirac-electron","dirac-radiation","dyson-qed","yang-mills"]},{"id":"entanglement","title":"A disagreement becomes more useful when it yields a discriminating test.","period":"1935–2015","question":"Which assumptions are actually constrained by a Bell experiment?","paragraphs":["EPR combines a criterion of reality with predictions for separated correlated systems and argues that the wave-function description is incomplete. Bohr's reply directly contests the criterion. These are documented contemporaneous differences; they should not be dissolved into a retrospective claim that everyone was saying the same thing.","Bohm demonstrates why 'all hidden variables are impossible' is too broad. Bell explicitly recognizes the nonlocal construction and formulates the obstruction to a local response model. CHSH then produces a correlation inequality suitable for practical experiments. The shift is from a philosophical dispute to a specified statistical incompatibility.","Aspect, Dalibard, and Roger vary analyzer settings in a photon experiment. Hensen and collaborators later use separated electron spins in a protocol that addresses locality and detection together. The platforms, timing, trial-selection rules, and statistical analyses are part of the evidence; a single number without them is incomplete.","The notebook can enumerate all deterministic binary local strategies and compare their CHSH values with a specified quantum state and measurement settings. That calculation verifies the chosen finite model. Laboratory inference additionally needs reliable trial accounting and setting assumptions. Teleportation provides a useful downstream check: even with entanglement, the protocol requires a classical message."],"nodeIds":["epr-1935","bohr-reply-1935","bohm-1952","bell-1964","chsh-1969","aspect-1982","hensen-2015","teleportation-1993"],"edgeIds":["epr-bohr","epr-bell","bohm-bell","bell-chsh","chsh-aspect","bell-hensen","aspect-hensen","bell-teleport"],"equationChanges":[{"before":"Local outcomes are represented by A(a,λ) and B(b,λ).","after":"|Eab+Eab′+Ea′b−Ea′b′|≤2.","meaning":"The bound follows under the specified common-distribution and local-response assumptions.","sourceIds":["bell","chsh"]},{"before":"The local response family has a finite bound.","after":"A suitable quantum setup gives |S|=2√2.","meaning":"A concrete state-and-observable calculation separates the models; it is not permission for instantaneous communication.","sourceIds":["chsh","teleportation"]}],"observables":["Correlation counts","Setting choices","Timing and separation","Detection probability","Predefined statistical significance"],"nextStep":"Display assumptions beside the correlation model and retain every trial in an auditable table. Ask which premise a proposed alternative changes before declaring it excluded.","sourceIds":["epr","bohr-epr","bohm","bell","chsh","aspect","hensen","teleportation"]},{"id":"measurement","title":"A stable record requires a model of the interaction.","period":"1932–2003","question":"How much of the measurement problem does reduced-state dynamics explain?","paragraphs":["Von Neumann's framework makes the apparatus part of the mathematical problem. A unitary interaction can correlate a system state with different pointer states. Everett's relative-state description treats the combined state without adding a separate collapse to that dynamics; this is an interpretive proposal, not a theorem that every interpretation must be identical.","Zeh examines why statistical ignorance about the apparatus cannot simply be substituted for a dynamical account. Zurek's account explains how environmental monitoring favors stable pointer states and suppresses interference in a reduced description. These mechanisms explain observable record stability under specified interactions.","Lindblad's generator gives a precise class of Markovian reduced-state models. The useful link to engineering is explicit: measured relaxation and dephasing can inform a channel model, which can then be compared with a protection scheme's assumptions. The link fails if correlations or environmental memory dominate outside the approximation.","A small demonstrator can evolve a qubit coupled to an environment, show the total-state correlations, then trace out the environment. It should distinguish a diagonal reduced matrix from a proof that exactly one global outcome has been selected. To claim a new physical collapse mechanism, specify a difference in outcome statistics or interference visibility and test it against the unitary account."],"nodeIds":["von-neumann-1932","everett-1957","zeh-1970","zurek-2003","lindblad-1976","shor-code-1995"],"edgeIds":["measurement-zeh","von-neumann-everett","everett-decoherence","zeh-zurek","density-lindblad","lindblad-decoherence","lindblad-qec"],"equationChanges":[{"before":"iℏd|Ψ⟩/dt=H|Ψ⟩ for a closed combined system.","after":"ρS=TrE|ΨSE⟩⟨ΨSE|.","meaning":"Discarding degrees of freedom changes the available description while the joint state can remain pure.","sourceIds":["zeh","zurek"]},{"before":"The reduced evolution may retain memory of the environment.","after":"dρ/dt=−i[H,ρ]/ℏ+Σj(LjρLj†−{Lj†Lj,ρ}/2).","meaning":"This generator applies after the stated Markovian and mathematical conditions are justified.","sourceIds":["lindblad"]}],"observables":["Interference visibility","Purity Tr(ρ²)","Relaxation and dephasing times","Record stability","Noise correlations"],"nextStep":"Fit both a Markovian model and a model with memory to held-out decay data. Use residuals to decide where a simple master equation is adequate.","sourceIds":["von-neumann","everett","zeh","zurek","lindblad","shor-code"]},{"id":"chemistry","title":"Molecular predictions depend on the approximation as well as the equation.","period":"1927–2014","question":"Which neglected degrees of freedom explain a calculation's error?","paragraphs":["Born–Oppenheimer separates electronic and nuclear motion; Heitler–London examines exchange in a bond. Hartree develops practical radial calculations, and the Fock construction incorporates exchange in a mean-field treatment. These methods address different pieces of an expensive many-particle problem. They are not interchangeable names for an exact solution.","Hohenberg–Kohn expresses the ground-state energy through a density functional. Kohn–Sham supplies a self-consistent orbital construction and approximate ways to include exchange and correlation. The exact theorem and a selected approximate functional must remain separate records, because the theorem does not certify every functional's errors.","Quantum computing offers another representation and resource tradeoff. The chemical-dynamics algorithm explicitly includes electrons and nuclei, while the VQE demonstration uses a parameterized trial state for a small molecular energy calculation. Neither removes the obligation to account for preparation, basis, measurement, and numerical error.","A benchmark should hold the geometry, charge, basis, and observable fixed, then compare approximations. Stretching a bond or approaching a surface crossing is particularly useful because it tests the conditions hidden by an easy equilibrium example. Plot error against the relevant control parameter, not only a visually persuasive molecular rendering."],"nodeIds":["born-oppenheimer-1927","heitler-london-1927","hartree-1928","fock-1930","hohenberg-kohn-1964","kohn-sham-1965","chemical-dynamics-2008","vqe-2014"],"edgeIds":["wave-molecules","schrodinger-heitler-london","bo-hl-comparison","wave-hartree","hartree-fock","hk-ks","hartree-ks","fock-ks","bo-chemical-dynamics","chemistry-vqe"],"equationChanges":[{"before":"A joint electron–nuclear wave function depends on r and R.","after":"Ψ(r,R)≈ψe(r;R)χ(R).","meaning":"The factorization is an approximation whose nonadiabatic terms need control.","sourceIds":["born-oppenheimer","chemical-dynamics"]},{"before":"A many-electron wave function is the search variable.","after":"E0=minn{F[n]+∫vn}.","meaning":"Density is an alternative variational variable; practical functionals introduce a separate approximation.","sourceIds":["hohenberg-kohn","kohn-sham"]},{"before":"A chosen parameterized state supplies an estimated energy.","after":"E(θ)≥E0 for the same H and a normalized state.","meaning":"The mathematical variational bound does not eliminate statistical error in an experimental energy estimate.","sourceIds":["vqe"]}],"observables":["Potential-energy curves","Bond dissociation error","Density differences","Nonadiabatic transition probabilities","Statistical energy uncertainty"],"nextStep":"Publish a shared benchmark specification and compare at least one equilibrium case with one stressed regime. Report each error source separately before assigning a discrepancy to a new physical mechanism.","sourceIds":["born-oppenheimer","heitler-london","hartree","fock","hohenberg-kohn","kohn-sham","chemical-dynamics","vqe"]},{"id":"scale-and-proof","title":"A finite calculation can guide a theorem without becoming the theorem.","period":"1971–2008","question":"What must survive when a regulator is removed?","paragraphs":["Wilson's critical-phenomena work turns scale changes into differential flow and fixed-point conditions. Gross–Wilczek and Politzer independently show ultraviolet weakening in appropriate non-Abelian theories. Their perturbative short-distance statements do not directly supply a nonperturbative long-distance conclusion.","Wilson's lattice construction preserves gauge invariance and gives a strong-coupling confinement mechanism. The paper itself notes that the strong-coupling limit lacks continuum rotational invariance. Osterwalder–Schrader identifies conditions on Euclidean functions needed to recover a relativistic quantum theory. These sources make the missing steps visible rather than optional.","PACS-CS provides a numerical example with an explicitly stated action, lattice spacing, volume, and calibration inputs. A good numerical program varies these choices and studies systematic uncertainty. A positive energy gap at one finite size does not establish a uniform positive lower bound after all required limits.","The accompanying spin examples are useful as mathematical counterchecks: a model can have a positive finite-size gap that decreases with size, while another has a provable size-independent gap. The inference to test is the uniform bound, not the attractiveness of the finite plot. Relating such a toy system to four-dimensional gauge theory requires a new, explicit bridge."],"nodeIds":["wilson-rg-1971","gross-wilczek-1973","politzer-1973","wilson-lattice-1974","osterwalder-schrader-1973","pacs-cs-2008"],"edgeIds":["rg-asymptotic","af-convergence","yangmills-lattice","rg-lattice","euclidean-lattice","lattice-qcd","asymptotic-lattice","lattice-reconstruction-limit"],"equationChanges":[{"before":"A calculation has finite spacing a and volume L.","after":"Control a→0 and L→∞ while retaining required properties.","meaning":"The order, uniformity, and existence of limits are mathematical obligations.","sourceIds":["wilson-lattice","osterwalder-schrader","pacs-cs"]},{"before":"ΔL>0 for each tested finite L.","after":"A mass-gap claim needs an appropriate limiting theory and Δ≥Δ*>0.","meaning":"Pointwise positivity of a sequence does not imply a positive infimum; this is an elementary logical check, not a new gauge-theory proof.","sourceIds":["osterwalder-schrader"]}],"observables":["Correlation lengths","Finite-size gaps","Scaling exponents","Lattice-spacing dependence","Positivity diagnostics","Systematic error budget"],"nextStep":"Track observables across volume and regulator choices, and turn any conjectured bound into an explicitly uniform statement. Preserve counterexamples that defeat an insufficient inference.","sourceIds":["wilson-rg","gross-wilczek","politzer","wilson-lattice","osterwalder-schrader","pacs-cs"]},{"id":"information-architecture","title":"Computation becomes a physical architecture with measurable costs.","period":"1948–1996","question":"Which resource does each information-theoretic result actually constrain?","paragraphs":["Shannon quantifies uncertainty for a specified message source and channel. Landauer considers physical erasure, and Bennett shows how logically reversible computation can retain the history that an irreversible map discards. These ideas connect information and thermodynamics through an explicit model; they do not turn every use of the word 'information' into the same measurable quantity.","Feynman's simulation question and Deutsch's computational model provide another bridge: physical quantum evolution can implement a different class of information-processing procedures. Shor's factoring algorithm and Grover's search algorithm then make different complexity claims. One is polynomial in the digit count for particular arithmetic problems; the other reduces an oracle query count quadratically.","No-cloning is a constraint on an arbitrary unknown state, not a prohibition on every form of redundancy. Teleportation shows a compatible protocol that uses shared entanglement, a joint measurement, and a classical message. These requirements make the architecture inspectable and rule out a misleading picture of unlimited copying or instantaneous messaging.","For a managed system, record the input representation, output task, error tolerance, memory, preparation, communication, and reset cost. A speedup that leaves an expensive oracle or state-preparation stage outside the accounting may disappear when the complete task is measured."],"nodeIds":["shannon-1948","landauer-1961","bennett-1973","feynman-1982","deutsch-1985","shor-1994","grover-1996","no-cloning-1982","teleportation-1993"],"edgeIds":["shannon-landauer","landauer-bennett","bennett-deutsch","feynman-deutsch","deutsch-shor","deutsch-grover","shor-grover","nocloning-teleport"],"equationChanges":[{"before":"A logical map f can discard which input produced an output.","after":"(x,0)↦(x,f(x)) preserves an input record.","meaning":"Reversible embedding changes information accounting; practical implementation still costs resources.","sourceIds":["bennett"]},{"before":"N candidates require a specified search oracle.","after":"Grover uses O(√N) queries.","meaning":"A query improvement must be combined with the cost of realizing that oracle.","sourceIds":["grover"]}],"observables":["Logical operations","Physical dissipation","State-preparation cost","Queries","Communication latency","Output accuracy"],"nextStep":"Create a full task cost table before claiming acceleration. Compare a quantum procedure with a strong classical method at equal output accuracy and include data movement.","sourceIds":["shannon","landauer","bennett","feynman","deutsch","shor-algorithm","grover","no-cloning","teleportation"]},{"id":"scaling-and-errors","title":"A small demonstration must be tested against its scaling barriers.","period":"1992–2023","question":"What evidence distinguishes a promising prototype from a scalable method?","paragraphs":["White's density-matrix method shows that structure can make important many-body calculations tractable classically. A large formal state space is therefore a starting point for a resource question, not a proof of practical quantum advantage. The baseline must fit the actual family of states and observables.","Shor's memory code protects quantum information, and fault-tolerant procedures extend protection to operations. Aharonov–Ben-Or strengthens the scaling result to a constant threshold under specified noise conditions. These are mathematical results about constructions, with assumptions that must be translated into hardware measurements.","The surface-code experiment supplies one such measurement: logical memory performance improves modestly between the reported distances while error budgets reveal the remaining constraints. VQE supplies a different prototype, using shorter coherent evolutions and classical optimization. Barren-plateau results show why randomly chosen circuit families can develop exponentially weak gradients.","A serious scaling study should vary system size, code distance or ansatz depth, sampling budget, and noise correlations. Include an easy case and a deliberately difficult one. If an apparent benefit disappears under better classical compression or more complete measurement accounting, retain that result as a useful boundary on the proposed approach."],"nodeIds":["dmrg-1992","shor-code-1995","shor-fault-1996","threshold-1997","surface-code-2023","vqe-2014","barren-plateaus-2018"],"edgeIds":["feynman-dmrg","qec-fault","fault-threshold","threshold-surface","shor-hardware","vqe-barren","qec-vqe","surface-managed-systems"],"equationChanges":[{"before":"Physical error is measured on individual operations.","after":"Logical failure is measured across code sizes and complete circuits.","meaning":"The quantity that matters for the task is the end-to-end failure rate, with correlations included.","sourceIds":["surface-code","aharonov-benor"]},{"before":"A variational circuit has an adjustable parameter vector.","after":"Gradient variance can shrink exponentially in specified random ensembles.","meaning":"Expressiveness does not guarantee trainability or affordable gradient estimation.","sourceIds":["barren-plateaus"]}],"observables":["Logical error versus distance","Correlated error bursts","Gradient variance","Measurement shots","Runtime at equal accuracy","Classical truncation error"],"nextStep":"Use a preregistered scaling matrix and report failures as well as favorable points. Choose mitigation only after identifying whether noise, optimization, representation, or readout is the binding constraint.","sourceIds":["dmrg","shor-code","shor-fault-tolerance","aharonov-benor","surface-code","vqe","barren-plateaus"]},{"id":"traditions-and-tests","title":"Historical traditions can generate questions without supplying physical proofs.","period":"Ancient witnesses–1908–modern comparison","question":"How can Hermetic and Gnostic reading contribute without erasing differences?","paragraphs":["The opening of the Corpus Hermeticum is a revelatory dialogue; the Nag Hammadi catalog identifies physical Coptic witnesses; the modern Kybalion explicitly names seven principles. Treatise composition, manuscript copying, translation, and modern publication are different events. The seven-principle list belongs to the identifiable modern text and should not be retroactively assigned to every ancient witness.","There is a real overlap to investigate: Brill's inventory places Hermetic works in Nag Hammadi Codex VI, including the Discourse on the Eighth and Ninth and an Asclepius excerpt. This supports a textual relationship at the collection level. It does not establish common authorship, a single doctrine across the whole collection, or transmission to twentieth-century quantum physics.","The productive use here is heuristic. 'Correspondence' can prompt us to search for an explicit scale map; 'vibration' can prompt a spectral measurement; a concern with knowledge can prompt us to specify who has which record. Each prompt must become a defined observable and a prediction that could fail.","Several comparisons fail immediately when made precise. Two verbal opposites need not be noncommuting operators. A stationary quantum state's density need not oscillate. Two incommensurate sinusoidal frequencies have no common positive period. Consciousness-induced collapse needs an additional physical model and discriminating data; it does not follow from an ancient or modern metaphysical sentence.","Historical transmission should be tested with dated quotations, correspondence, ownership records, or explicit citations. Physical claims should be tested with dimensions, mechanisms, controls, and held-out observations. An inspiring resemblance earns an analogy edge; a failed test earns a retained counterexample and a reassessment of the claim's testable assumptions."],"nodeIds":["hermetic-dialogue","nag-hammadi-witness","coptic-hermetica","kybalion-1908","schrodinger-1926","wilson-rg-1971","lindblad-1976"],"edgeIds":["coptic-witness-comparison","hermetic-coptic","ancient-modern-principles","kybalion-quantum-origin","gnosis-measurement","mentalism-collapse","correspondence-scale","vibration-spectrum","polarity-commutator","rhythm-markov","causation-bell","gender-spin","textual-diff-model-diff"],"equationChanges":[{"before":"A resemblance is described in broad language.","after":"Specify objects, map, units, preserved structure, and a falsifier.","meaning":"This is a proposed research discipline, not a translation of an esoteric sentence into an established physical law.","sourceIds":["kybalion","hermetica"]},{"before":"Everything repeats with one exact period.","after":"f(t)=sin(t)+sin(√2t) has no common positive period.","meaning":"The irrational frequency ratio gives a mathematical counterexample to that precise universal-period claim; it does not adjudicate every metaphorical reading.","sourceIds":["kybalion"]}],"observables":["Witness-specific wording","Dated citation trails","Units and symmetries of a proposed mapping","Held-out prediction error","Negative-control performance"],"nextStep":"Keep a two-column ledger: the historical passage as a located text, and the independently defined scientific hypothesis it suggests. Promote a connection only after the relevant historical or experimental evidence is supplied.","sourceIds":["hermetica","hermetica-ii","hermetic-dating","nag-hammadi-iv","coptic-library","kybalion","kybalion-catalog","schrodinger-equivalence","wilson-rg","lindblad"]}],"heuristics":[{"id":"correspondence-test","title":"Ask what a proposed correspondence preserves.","tradition":"The Kybalion's modern correspondence principle, used as a question-generating analogy.","prompt":"If two descriptions appear related, can we write the map between their objects and predict what stays invariant?","operationalization":"Choose two models, define a map between variables, retain units, and specify a measurable invariant or scaling exponent. Estimate parameters on one range and predict a withheld range. Wilson's flow supplies an example of what a precise scale relationship looks like.","observable":"Prediction error after the specified transformation; symmetry, spectrum, or scaling exponent preserved by the map.","nullModel":"A shuffled pairing of variables or a freely refitted curve with the same number of parameters.","failureCondition":"The apparent relation needs inconsistent units, changes the map after every failed prediction, or performs no better than the shuffled pairing.","scope":"A tested mathematical correspondence can be useful without any historical transmission from an esoteric text. Universality classes require explicit assumptions.","sourceIds":["kybalion","wilson-rg"]},{"id":"vibration-test","title":"Require a spectrum before calling something a vibration.","tradition":"The Kybalion's modern vibration principle; comparison with physical spectral analysis.","prompt":"Which quantity varies, in what unit, relative to which time variable, and through what substrate?","operationalization":"Define a time series or a Hamiltonian transition, state boundary conditions, and estimate frequencies with an uncertainty model. Compare the inferred frequencies with a mechanism's prediction, such as energy differences divided by h.","observable":"Spectral peaks, dispersion relation, amplitude, phase, and their reproducibility under changed conditions.","nullModel":"Instrument noise, an aperiodic process, or a stationary state whose probability density does not vary with time.","failureCondition":"No stable peak survives controls, predicted frequencies have the wrong units, or a global wave-function phase is mistaken for oscillation of an observable density.","scope":"The statement that a model has oscillatory modes does not establish that every spiritual, mental, or material category is a physical frequency.","sourceIds":["kybalion","bohr-lecture","schrodinger-eigenvalue"]},{"id":"rhythm-test","title":"Test whether recurrence is exact, approximate, or absent.","tradition":"The Kybalion's modern rhythm principle, translated into a bounded recurrence question.","prompt":"Does a claimed cycle predict a future observation better than a nonperiodic baseline?","operationalization":"Predeclare a candidate period and tolerance, fit on an initial segment, and predict a later segment. Use sin(t)+sin(√2t) as a counterexample to a universal exact-period claim: a common period would require a rational frequency ratio.","observable":"Out-of-sample phase error, recurrence distance, and confidence interval for the period.","nullModel":"A relaxation curve, a stochastic process with similar autocorrelation, or a quasiperiodic signal without one exact common period.","failureCondition":"The period is selected only after seeing the future data, drifts beyond the stated tolerance, or no common period exists for the specified frequencies.","scope":"This falsifies a precise mathematical claim of universal exact repetition; metaphorical or theological meanings require a different kind of interpretation.","sourceIds":["kybalion","lindblad"]},{"id":"polarity-test","title":"Replace verbal opposites with defined operations.","tradition":"The Kybalion's modern polarity principle; analogy tested against operator algebra.","prompt":"Are the proposed opposites actually a symmetry pair, a conjugate pair, two extrema, or merely two labels?","operationalization":"Specify operators or state transformations and calculate a commutator, inverse, or conservation law. Two distinct diagonal matrices provide a failure example: they can represent different labels while commuting exactly.","observable":"Commutator norm, transformed expectation values, and experimentally accessible variance bounds.","nullModel":"Arbitrary binary labeling that preserves no mathematical operation or predictive relation.","failureCondition":"Changing the labels changes the alleged law, or the claimed conjugate relation is absent from the defined algebra.","scope":"Position–momentum conjugacy has a mathematical structure and domain conditions. A verbal pair does not inherit that structure by resemblance.","sourceIds":["kybalion","born-jordan","robertson"]},{"id":"causation-test","title":"Separate a correlation from the causal assumptions that explain it.","tradition":"The Kybalion's modern cause-and-effect principle, used to demand an explicit causal model.","prompt":"Which intervention or conditional independence would distinguish the proposed mechanism from a common cause?","operationalization":"Draw the variables and allowable influences, specify how settings are chosen, and derive a constraint before observing the result. Bell and CHSH provide a concrete example where a family of local response models has a testable bound.","observable":"Conditional distributions, intervention response, and the statistic derived from the predeclared model.","nullModel":"A common-cause model or local response model with its assumptions stated explicitly.","failureCondition":"The claimed mechanism predicts no difference from the null, introduces unobserved exceptions after each result, or relies on selection that invalidates the bound.","scope":"Rejecting a particular local model does not remove every notion of cause, prove faster-than-light communication, or select a metaphysical worldview.","sourceIds":["kybalion","bell","chsh","teleportation"]},{"id":"knowledge-record-test","title":"Specify who has a record and what that record predicts.","tradition":"Questions of knowing in Hermetic and Gnostic reading; no assumed physical equivalence.","prompt":"Does a change in someone's knowledge change the physical record, the available prediction, or only the description?","operationalization":"List the system, apparatus, environment, and observer's accessible information. Compare a model using ordinary unitary interaction and reduced states with any proposed added mechanism. Require the latter to change a defined observable under controlled conditions.","observable":"Interference visibility, outcome distribution, record correlations, and performance of predictions made from specified information.","nullModel":"A physical interaction model in which consciousness adds no separate dynamical term.","failureCondition":"The proposal merely redescribes the same probabilities, cannot distinguish private belief from an instrument state, or adds no measurable prediction.","scope":"A metaphysical claim can remain a philosophical position; it does not become a physical collapse law without a specified model and evidence.","sourceIds":["hermetica","nag-hammadi-iv","zeh","zurek"]},{"id":"gender-category-test","title":"Check the category before assigning complementary roles.","tradition":"The Kybalion's modern gender principle; a deliberately restrictive test of its scientific applicability.","prompt":"Does the proposed pair describe an actual mechanism, or are biological and symbolic terms being projected onto unrelated variables?","operationalization":"Replace the metaphor with the real objects and operations: exchange symmetry in a two-electron state, a sign of charge, or a matrix component. Derive a prediction using those definitions and compare it with the original metaphor's added content.","observable":"A measurable quantity changed by the proposed mechanism, such as a symmetry-dependent energy difference.","nullModel":"The standard model stated entirely in physical variables, with no added symbolic labels.","failureCondition":"The metaphor changes no prediction, conflates human gender with spin or charge, or fails for a system with a different number of components.","scope":"This screen will often reject the proposed correspondence. Rejecting a physical mapping does not judge the text's symbolic or religious use.","sourceIds":["kybalion","heitler-london","dirac-electron"]},{"id":"witness-transmission-test","title":"Treat a transmission claim as a historical hypothesis.","tradition":"Critical comparison of Hermetic and Coptic manuscript traditions.","prompt":"What dated document shows that one author or community encountered the specific idea being attributed to it?","operationalization":"Identify the witness, language, edition, date range, and exact passage. Search quotations, correspondence, ownership evidence, and explicit citations; compare variant wording and plausible alternative sources.","observable":"A traceable citation or quotation chain, a shared distinctive passage, and dated evidence of access.","nullModel":"Independent use of common vocabulary, later translation choices, or parallel responses to different problems.","failureCondition":"The only evidence is chronological overlap, a generic word such as light or knowledge, or a modern paraphrase projected into an ancient text.","scope":"Hermetic material in Nag Hammadi is a documented collection relationship. It does not establish a causal path to any particular quantum paper.","sourceIds":["hermetica-ii","coptic-library","nag-hammadi-iv","schrodinger-equivalence"]},{"id":"disagreement-triage","title":"Preserve a disagreement until a comparison resolves it.","tradition":"Comparative historical and mathematical inquiry.","prompt":"Do two accounts disagree about data, assumptions, equations, interpretations, or the domain where a result applies?","operationalization":"Write each claim in its own terms, align the observable and conditions, and locate the exact difference. Use Millikan's confirmation of an equation alongside rejection of its explanation as a case where one label cannot describe both outcomes.","observable":"A reproducible difference in prediction, a stated premise that differs, or a demonstrated representation map.","nullModel":"An apparent contradiction caused by different domains or definitions; alternatively, a real unresolved disagreement.","failureCondition":"Reconciliation is asserted without a map or test, a failed prediction is excused without changing a testable assumption, or opposing claims are silently rewritten.","scope":"Some contradictions dissolve under clearer definitions; some expose an error or a substantive unresolved question. The method does not assume that every historical claim must ultimately agree.","sourceIds":["millikan-photoelectric","schrodinger-equivalence","epr","bohr-epr"]},{"id":"substrate-accounting","title":"Include the physical substrate in any proposed transfer.","tradition":"Cross-domain heuristic inspired by correspondence; evaluated with information physics and engineering.","prompt":"What changes when an abstract procedure is implemented in a different material, machine, or communication channel?","operationalization":"List preparation, computation, storage, readout, reset, and communication. Give each stage a cost and error model; compare the complete task at equal output accuracy against a suitable baseline.","observable":"End-to-end runtime, energy, failure probability, measurement count, and scaling with input size.","nullModel":"A strong classical implementation or a simpler physical model with the same task and accuracy.","failureCondition":"The claimed improvement depends on free data loading, hidden erasure, ignored sampling, an unbuilt oracle, or an unmatched accuracy requirement.","scope":"A useful analogy becomes an engineering transfer only after the substrate-specific constraints are accounted for. No universal quantum advantage is assumed.","sourceIds":["landauer","bennett","grover","chemical-dynamics","surface-code"]}]},"millennium":{"schema":"xlvii.millennium.research.v1","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","title":"The Millennium problems have distinct proof obligations.","summary":"Seven dossiers trace the definitions, historical developments, established results and explicit gaps behind the Millennium Prize Problems. As checked on 19 November 2026, Clay lists five problems as Unsolved, Navier–Stokes as Active, and Poincaré as Solved.","prizeContext":{"summary":"Clay designated one million US dollars for each of the original seven problems. A mathematical result, an announced resolution and a prize decision are different records.","rules":"Before Clay considers a proposed solution, its published rules require publication in a qualifying outlet, at least two years since publication, and general acceptance by the global mathematics community. Clay does not accept direct proposed-solution submissions.","currentDistinction":"Navier–Stokes has an announced forced C/D construction and published formalization. Clay acknowledges an apparent resolution while retaining an Active category. This dossier has not independently checked the complete analytical or formal proof and does not record an awarded Navier–Stokes prize.","sourceIds":["clay-status","clay-rules","clay-ns-announcement","openai-ns-announcement","openai-ns-repository"]},"method":"The research compares exact formulations, eras, author statements, primary papers and counterexamples. A historical association is recorded separately from a mathematical dependency; a shared equation or visual pattern does not establish causation. Hermetic or Gnostic interpretations may suggest questions, but they supply no proof of a mathematical or physical claim here. The approaches below are scoped research proposals with explicit failure conditions, not claimed novel solutions.","verification":{"scope":"Seven independent exact-arithmetic examples were executed successfully. They test restricted inferences and model calculations; they do not certify a Millennium proof.","calculationCount":7,"sourceRecordCount":40,"limitations":"Primary-source inspection ranges from exact official formulations and theorem statements to author abstracts; each source records its inspection depth. Full literature coverage, line-by-line reconstruction of every cited proof and external formal-proof replay are not claimed."},"sources":[{"id":"clay-status","title":"The Millennium Prize Problems","url":"https://www.claymath.org/millennium-problems/","publisher":"Clay Mathematics Institute","scope":"Current official categories and original seven-prize fund.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Official page opened; Active, Unsolved and Solved headings inspected."},{"id":"clay-rules","title":"Rules for the Millennium Prize Problems","url":"https://www.claymath.org/millennium-problems/rules/","publisher":"Clay Mathematics Institute","scope":"Qualifying publication, two-year waiting period, general acceptance and no direct submissions.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Current official rules summary inspected; not a determination of eligibility for any submission."},{"id":"clay-ns-announcement","title":"Navier-Stokes Announcement, 11 September 2026","url":"https://www.claymath.org/news/navier-stokes-announcement/","publisher":"Clay Mathematics Institute","scope":"Acknowledgement of an announced apparent resolution and the intended evaluation process.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Full short announcement inspected; it announces no prize award or completed adjudication."},{"id":"clay-ns","title":"Existence and Smoothness of the Navier–Stokes Equation","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/navierstokes.pdf","publisher":"Charles L. Fefferman / Clay Mathematics Institute","scope":"Official alternatives A–D; domain, forcing, smoothness and energy requirements.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Official PDF formulation, regularity assumptions and partial-results discussion inspected."},{"id":"clay-ym","title":"Quantum Yang–Mills Theory","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/yangmills.pdf","publisher":"Arthur Jaffe and Edward Witten / Clay Mathematics Institute","scope":"Existence of nontrivial four-dimensional QFT for every compact simple gauge group and positive mass gap.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Official PDF statement, axiom requirements and distinction between mass gap and confinement inspected."},{"id":"clay-pnp","title":"The P versus NP Problem","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/pvsnp.pdf","publisher":"Stephen Cook / Clay Mathematics Institute","scope":"Classical deterministic computation, polynomial certificates and exact decision question.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Definitions, problem statement, historical discussion and barriers sections inspected; full references not independently reconstructed."},{"id":"clay-rh","title":"Problems of the Millennium: the Riemann Hypothesis","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/riemann.pdf","publisher":"Enrico Bombieri / Clay Mathematics Institute","scope":"Zeta continuation, critical-line statement, prime-counting consequence and historical context.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Official PDF statement and consequences inspected; historical numerical counts are not treated as current records."},{"id":"clay-hodge","title":"The Hodge Conjecture","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/hodge.pdf","publisher":"Pierre Deligne / Clay Mathematics Institute","scope":"Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties; divisor case and restrictions.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Official PDF formulation, exponential-sequence argument and integral-counterexample discussion inspected."},{"id":"clay-bsd","title":"The Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer Conjecture","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/birchswin.pdf","publisher":"Andrew Wiles / Clay Mathematics Institute","scope":"Rank equals order of vanishing for elliptic curves over Q; stronger leading-coefficient refinement.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Official PDF question, stronger refinement and partial-results discussion inspected; the refinement is not silently substituted for the stated rank question."},{"id":"clay-poincare","title":"The Poincaré Conjecture","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/poincare.pdf","publisher":"John Milnor / Clay Mathematics Institute","scope":"Closed simply connected three-manifold statement and historical false generalizations.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Official PDF statement and counterexamples in the early-missteps section inspected; this historical description predates the accepted resolution."},{"id":"clay-poincare-status","title":"Poincaré Conjecture: Solved","url":"https://www.claymath.org/millennium/poincare-conjecture/","publisher":"Clay Mathematics Institute","scope":"Accepted solution by Perelman and relation to Hamilton and geometrization.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Current official status and linked proof resources inspected."},{"id":"openai-ns-announcement","title":"On the Navier–Stokes Millennium Prize Problem","url":"https://openai.com/index/navier-stokes-solution/","publisher":"OpenAI","scope":"Author announcement dated 8 September 2026; claimed forced alternatives C/D and stated intention not to claim the prize.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Announcement and linked primary materials inspected. An author's claim is distinct from independent validation."},{"id":"openai-ns-paper","title":"Finite Time Blowup for Navier–Stokes","url":"https://cdn.openai.com/pdf/32d9f210-8b73-45e0-91bc-82a30aef8a9a/navier-stokes.pdf","publisher":"OpenAI","scope":"Theorem 1.1 claims smooth compact forcing, initially resting fluid, bounded energy and finite-time velocity blowup; periodic corollary.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Theorem 1.1, historical context, proof outline and localization section located. The 166-page proof was not independently line-checked."},{"id":"openai-ns-repository","title":"NavierStokesAndEuler","url":"https://github.com/openai/NavierStokesAndEuler","publisher":"OpenAI","scope":"Published Lean formalization repository and instructions for independent certificate checking.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"README and result statements inspected. No checkout, build, axiom audit or independent certificate replay was performed."},{"id":"tao-averaged","title":"Finite time blowup for an averaged three-dimensional Navier–Stokes equation","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/1402.0290","publisher":"Terence Tao / arXiv; JAMS 2016","scope":"Blowup in an averaged equation preserving energy cancellation; limitation on arguments using only that coarse structure.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author abstract and journal introduction inspected; original equation is explicitly distinguished from its averaged modification."},{"id":"os-reconstruction","title":"Axioms for Euclidean Green's Functions II","url":"https://projecteuclid.org/journals/communications-in-mathematical-physics/volume-42/issue-3/Axioms-for-Euclidean-Greens-functions-II-with-an-Appendix-by/cmp/1103899050.pdf","publisher":"Konrad Osterwalder and Robert Schrader / Communications in Mathematical Physics","scope":"1975 reconstruction conditions extending and correcting the 1973 paper.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Primary PDF abstract and reconstruction outline inspected; all technical hypotheses must be checked in any application."},{"id":"wilson-lattice","title":"Confinement of quarks","url":"https://journals.aps.org/prd/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevD.10.2445","publisher":"Kenneth G. Wilson / Physical Review D","scope":"1974 gauge-invariant lattice construction and strong-coupling confinement mechanism.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher abstract inspected; no continuum-limit proof is attributed to the strong-coupling result."},{"id":"gross-wilczek","title":"Ultraviolet Behavior of Non-Abelian Gauge Theories","url":"https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.30.1343","publisher":"David J. Gross and Frank Wilczek / Physical Review Letters","scope":"1973 short-distance asymptotic freedom calculation.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher abstract inspected; perturbative ultraviolet behavior is not treated as a nonperturbative gap theorem."},{"id":"gap-undecidability","title":"Undecidability of the Spectral Gap","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/1502.04573","publisher":"Toby Cubitt, David Perez-Garcia and Michael M. Wolf / arXiv","scope":"Undecidability across specially constructed families of translation-invariant two-dimensional lattice Hamiltonians.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author abstract and stated model class inspected; no undecidability claim is made for the specific Yang–Mills problem."},{"id":"bgs-relativization","title":"Relativizations of the P = ? NP Question","url":"https://cse.ucdenver.edu/~cscialtman/complexity/Relativizations%20of%20the%20P%3DNP%20Question%20%28Original%29.pdf","publisher":"Theodore Baker, John Gill and Robert Solovay / SIAM Journal on Computing","scope":"1975 opposite oracle outcomes and the relativization barrier.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Primary paper reproduction inspected, especially abstract, definitions and oracle theorem statements."},{"id":"natural-proofs","title":"Natural Proofs","url":"https://mit6875.github.io/PAPERS/natural_proofs.pdf","publisher":"Alexander Razborov and Steven Rudich / Journal of Computer and System Sciences","scope":"Constructivity, largeness and usefulness; conditional barrier based on pseudorandomness assumptions.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Primary 1997 paper reproduction inspected, including definitions and the conditional nature of the main barrier."},{"id":"algebrization","title":"Algebrization: A New Barrier in Complexity Theory","url":"https://www.scottaaronson.com/papers/algstoc.pdf","publisher":"Scott Aaronson and Avi Wigderson / STOC 2008","scope":"Low-degree oracle extensions and limitations on algebrizing techniques.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author-hosted extended abstract inspected; no assertion that every possible proof is barred."},{"id":"shor","title":"Polynomial-Time Algorithms for Prime Factorization and Discrete Logarithms on a Quantum Computer","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9508027","publisher":"Peter W. Shor / arXiv","scope":"Quantum polynomial-time algorithms for factoring and discrete logarithms, announced at FOCS 1994.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author abstract and submission history inspected; this result is not a classical polynomial-time SAT algorithm."},{"id":"platt-trudgian","title":"The Riemann hypothesis is true up to 3 · 10^12","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2004.09765","publisher":"Dave Platt and Tim Trudgian / arXiv","scope":"Rigorous interval-arithmetic verification for all nontrivial zeros up to a finite imaginary height.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author abstract inspected; 2020 result used as an explicit finite certificate, not as the latest computational record."},{"id":"odlyzko-spacing","title":"On the distribution of spacings between zeros of the zeta function","url":"https://www.ams.org/mcom/1987-48-177/S0025-5718-1987-0866115-0/S0025-5718-1987-0866115-0.pdf","publisher":"Andrew M. Odlyzko / Mathematics of Computation","scope":"Numerical zero-spacing work and the relationship with Montgomery's pair correlation and random matrices.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Primary PDF introduction inspected; statistical agreement is kept separate from a spectral realization proving every zero lies on the line."},{"id":"atiyah-hirzebruch","title":"Analytic cycles on complex manifolds","url":"https://hirzebruch.mpim-bonn.mpg.de/id/eprint/151/1/29_Analytic%20cycles%20on%20complex%20manifolds.pdf","publisher":"Michael F. Atiyah and Friedrich Hirzebruch / Topology","scope":"Integral cycle obstructions from torsion cohomology operations; published 1962.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author archive copy, introduction and stated projective counterexamples inspected; rational conjecture remains distinct."},{"id":"voisin-kahler","title":"A Counterexample to the Hodge Conjecture Extended to Kähler Varieties","url":"https://webusers.imj-prg.fr/~claire.voisin/Articlesweb/hodgeimrn.pdf","publisher":"Claire Voisin / IMRN 2002","scope":"Failure of a generalized Kähler statement even using Chern classes of coherent sheaves.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author-hosted paper introduction inspected; counterexample does not satisfy the original smooth projective scope."},{"id":"gross-zagier","title":"Heegner points and derivatives of L-series","url":"https://wstein.org/papers/bib/Gross-Zagier_Heegner_points_and_derivatives_of_Lseries.pdf","publisher":"Benedict H. Gross and Don B. Zagier / Inventiones Mathematicae 1986","scope":"Heegner-point height formula and first derivatives of suitable L-series.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Primary journal-paper reproduction inspected at introduction, Theorem 6.1 and elliptic-curve consequence; the long internal proof was not independently reconstructed."},{"id":"kolyvagin","title":"On the Mordell–Weil and Shafarevich–Tate groups for Weil elliptic curves","url":"https://www.mathnet.ru/eng/im1225","publisher":"Victor A. Kolyvagin / Mathematics of the USSR-Izvestiya 1989","scope":"Heegner-point methods controlling rational points and Tate–Shafarevich groups under explicit hypotheses.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher archive abstract inspected; low-rank consequences are cross-checked against Wiles's official problem discussion."},{"id":"modularity","title":"On the Modularity of Elliptic Curves over Q: Wild 3-Adic Exercises","url":"https://math.stanford.edu/~conrad/papers/tswfinal.pdf","publisher":"Christophe Breuil, Brian Conrad, Fred Diamond and Richard Taylor / JAMS 2001","scope":"Every elliptic curve over Q is modular; completes preceding Wiles–Taylor work.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author-hosted paper introduction and Theorem A inspected; draft typography carries placeholders, so publication year comes from author institutional record."},{"id":"bhargava-shankar","title":"Ternary cubic forms having bounded invariants, and the existence of a positive proportion of elliptic curves having rank 0","url":"https://annals.math.princeton.edu/2015/181-2/p04","publisher":"Manjul Bhargava and Arul Shankar / Annals of Mathematics 2015","scope":"Average 3-Selmer size and positive-proportion rank-zero results with stated ordering.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Publisher abstract inspected; average or positive-proportion statements are not generalized to each curve."},{"id":"hamilton","title":"Three-manifolds with positive Ricci curvature","url":"https://math.cs.kitami-it.ac.jp/~kouno/paper/Hamilton1982.pdf","publisher":"Richard S. Hamilton / Journal of Differential Geometry 1982","scope":"Ricci flow for compact three-manifolds initially carrying positive Ricci curvature.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Primary paper reproduction and main theorem located; positive-curvature assumption is retained."},{"id":"perelman-entropy","title":"The entropy formula for the Ricci flow and its geometric applications","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0211159","publisher":"Grisha Perelman / arXiv 2002","scope":"Monotonic entropy, noncollapsing and the geometrization program.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author abstract and submission date inspected; physical entropy interpretation is not used as a substitute for geometric estimates."},{"id":"perelman-surgery","title":"Ricci flow with surgery on three-manifolds","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0303109","publisher":"Grisha Perelman / arXiv 2003","scope":"Construction and control of Ricci flow with surgery.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author abstract inspected, including its explicit correction of an earlier irrelevant claim."},{"id":"perelman-extinction","title":"Finite extinction time for the solutions to the Ricci flow on certain three-manifolds","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0307245","publisher":"Grisha Perelman / arXiv 2003","scope":"Finite extinction under the specified prime-decomposition hypothesis.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author abstract inspected; finite extinction is not asserted for every closed three-manifold."},{"id":"rodgers-tao","title":"The De Bruijn–Newman constant is non-negative","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/1801.05914v5","publisher":"Brad Rodgers and Terence Tao / arXiv; Forum of Mathematics, Pi","scope":"The lower bound Λ ≥ 0; RH would additionally require Λ ≤ 0.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author abstract, theorem scope and 2021 revision notice inspected. Version 5 corrects boundary-energy treatment in Section 8."},{"id":"civ-analytic","title":"Regularity of asymptotically axisymmetric solutions to the 3D Navier–Stokes equations with analytic forcing","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.20803v2","publisher":"Peter Constantin, Mihaela Ignatova and Vlad Vicol / arXiv","scope":"Regularity under exact core axisymmetry, specified anisotropic bounds and analytic forcing; a structural obstruction to carrying the announced forced mechanism into the unforced setting.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author abstract and version history inspected. This is a scoped preprint theorem, not a proof of general unforced regularity or a refutation of smooth nonanalytic forcing."},{"id":"hou-scope","title":"OpenAI’s Navier-Stokes Construction: What C∞ Forcing Changes","url":"https://www.siam.org/publications/siam-news/articles/openai-s-navier-stokes-construction-what-c-infty-forcing-changes/","publisher":"Thomas Y. Hou / SIAM News, 2 November 2026","scope":"Author's expert commentary on forcing assumptions, proof-assessment obligations and physical interpretation.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Full commentary and bibliography inspected. Hou explicitly states this is not an independent verification; mathematical theorem claims are traced to primary papers."},{"id":"hodge-locus","title":"On the Locus of Hodge Classes","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/alg-geom/9402009","publisher":"Eduardo Cattani, Pierre Deligne and Aroldo Kaplan / arXiv; JAMS 1995","scope":"Algebraicity of the parameter locus where a transported class retains Hodge type; distinct from algebraicity of a representing cycle.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author abstract and IAS-hosted primary introduction inspected; the result is not the full Hodge conjecture."},{"id":"tao-pnt","title":"246B, Notes 4: The Riemann zeta function and the prime number theorem","url":"https://terrytao.wordpress.com/2021/02/12/246b-notes-4-the-riemann-zeta-function-and-the-prime-number-theorem/","publisher":"Terence Tao, authored UCLA course notes","scope":"The 1896 Hadamard and de la Vallée Poussin attribution; prime-number theorem and zero-free boundary distinguished from RH.","checkedOn":"2026-11-19","inspection":"Author's original lecture notes opened. Date, historical attribution, theorem 1, zeta functional equation and theorem 9 on the zero-free boundary inspected. This is a modern proof exposition, not a retrieval of the complete 1896 original papers."}],"problems":[{"id":"yang-mills","title":"Yang–Mills existence and mass gap","status":"open","officialStatus":"Unsolved","field":"Quantum field theory and analysis","question":"Can four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills theory be constructed rigorously, with a strictly positive energy threshold above its vacuum?","formulation":"For every compact simple gauge group G, construct a nontrivial quantum Yang–Mills theory on R⁴ satisfying axiomatic requirements at least as strong as the specified Wightman or Osterwalder–Schrader frameworks, and establish a mass gap Δ > 0. A classical gauge-field solution or a finite lattice calculation does not meet this formulation.","proofObligations":["Specify the physical observables and Hilbert space, recover relativistic locality and positivity, and construct a nontrivial continuum theory.","Control removal of the short-distance regulator and the infinite-volume limit; estimates must remain meaningful in physical units.","Prove that the energy spectrum has no positive values below a fixed Δ, without assuming the desired gap in a compactness or reconstruction step."],"timeline":[{"year":"1954","title":"Yang and Mills introduce non-Abelian gauge fields.","body":"Their framework connects local internal symmetry with a gauge connection; the quantum existence question later becomes a separate constructive problem.","sourceIds":["clay-ym"]},{"year":"1973","title":"Short-distance behavior becomes calculable.","body":"Gross and Wilczek's asymptotic-freedom calculation concerns ultraviolet behavior. It does not establish long-distance mass generation.","sourceIds":["gross-wilczek"]},{"year":"1974–1975","title":"Lattices and Euclidean reconstruction supply complementary tools.","body":"Wilson preserves gauge symmetry on a lattice; Osterwalder and Schrader specify when Euclidean correlations reconstruct a relativistic theory.","sourceIds":["wilson-lattice","os-reconstruction"]},{"year":"2015","title":"A general spectral-gap algorithm encounters an undecidability boundary.","body":"Cubitt, Perez-Garcia and Wolf construct undecidable families of two-dimensional spin models. Their result does not determine the status of this particular four-dimensional gauge theory.","sourceIds":["gap-undecidability"]}],"knownResults":[{"title":"Strong coupling gives a controlled lattice regime.","body":"Wilson's strong-coupling expansion yields a confinement mechanism on the regulator lattice. The regime lacks the required continuum rotational symmetry; extrapolating it to a continuum limit needs additional arguments.","sourceIds":["wilson-lattice"]},{"title":"A reconstruction theorem is a bridge with hypotheses.","body":"Euclidean invariance, positivity and suitable regularity conditions enable reconstruction. Presenting plausible correlators without establishing these conditions leaves the bridge incomplete.","sourceIds":["os-reconstruction"]},{"title":"Mass gap and confinement ask different questions.","body":"The Clay formulation explicitly treats confinement and isolated one-particle states as further goals. A proposed proof should state which spectral property it establishes.","sourceIds":["clay-ym"]}],"dependencies":[{"name":"Gauge connections and curvature","role":"These define the classical action and gauge-invariant observables whose quantum theory is sought.","sourceIds":["clay-ym"]},{"name":"Renormalization","role":"The dependence of couplings and observables on the regulator must be controlled before any continuum conclusion.","sourceIds":["gross-wilczek","clay-ym"]},{"name":"Euclidean reconstruction","role":"This connects correlation estimates to a physical Hilbert space and energy spectrum when its hypotheses hold.","sourceIds":["os-reconstruction"]},{"name":"Uniform spectral bounds","role":"A bound that deteriorates with lattice spacing or volume cannot certify a positive limiting gap.","sourceIds":["clay-ym"]}],"approaches":[{"title":"Investigate a uniform correlation-decay certificate.","idea":"Choose a gauge-invariant observable and seek an exponential decay estimate with constants controlled through both limiting procedures. Record the physical units, regulator dependence and vacuum subtraction explicitly.","obstacle":"A fitted exponential over a finite distance window can coexist with slower asymptotic decay. A proof also needs convergence and nontriviality; decay alone cannot manufacture a quantum theory.","nextTest":"For a restricted lattice model, derive a rigorous bound and identify exactly where its constants cease to remain uniform. This is a tractable obstruction audit, not a claimed new mass-gap proof.","sourceIds":["clay-ym","wilson-lattice","os-reconstruction"]},{"title":"Test whether a perturbative estimate survives increasing volume.","idea":"Start with a solvable gapped Hamiltonian, introduce a bounded interaction, and track the dependency of a spectral lower bound on system size.","obstacle":"The crude norm of an extensive perturbation grows with volume. A valid small-system estimate can therefore become useless even when the actual model remains gapped.","nextTest":"Compare local stability estimates with the global operator-norm bound on a spin chain; then identify which additional gauge-specific arguments a Yang–Mills application would require.","sourceIds":[]}],"calculations":[{"title":"Positive gaps at every finite size do not imply a uniform gap.","setup":"Consider the exactly diagonal matrices H_N = diag(0, 1/N), for positive integers N.","result":"Every matrix has gap Δ_N = 1/N > 0, while inf_N Δ_N = 0. Exact rational checks at N = 1, 2, 4, 8, 16 reproduce this sequence; the limit follows directly from 1/N.","scope":"This is a logical counterexample to an inference from finite spectra. These matrices are not a Yang–Mills model, and no conclusion about its actual gap follows.","sourceIds":[]}],"implications":[{"condition":"If existence and a mass gap are proved.","consequence":"A central interacting four-dimensional gauge theory would acquire a rigorous spectral foundation; long-distance clustering would follow under the relevant axioms.","sourceIds":["clay-ym"]},{"condition":"If a computation observes a positive gap.","consequence":"It supplies evidence for the specified regulator, volume and observable. Uniform limits and axiom verification remain separate obligations.","sourceIds":[]}],"quantumConnection":"This problem is directly about quantum field theory. Spin-chain spectra, quantum simulation and Hamiltonian complexity provide useful test environments, but a spin-model analogy is not an equivalence to four-dimensional Yang–Mills.","sourceIds":["clay-status","clay-ym","wilson-lattice","gross-wilczek","os-reconstruction","gap-undecidability"]},{"id":"p-vs-np","title":"P versus NP","status":"open","officialStatus":"Unsolved","field":"Computational complexity","question":"Does every decision problem with efficiently verifiable certificates also have an efficient classical algorithm for finding the answer?","formulation":"P contains languages decided by a deterministic Turing machine in polynomial worst-case time. NP contains languages admitting polynomial-length witnesses checked in polynomial time. Establish P = NP or P ≠ NP in this ordinary classical model.","proofObligations":["For equality, supply a correct algorithm and polynomial bound for every input of an NP-complete problem such as SAT.","For separation, rule out every deterministic polynomial-time algorithm for at least one language in NP; a slow solver or hard benchmark family is insufficient.","Track input encoding and bit complexity. A primitive operation that hides exponential precision, memory or advice does not establish the required runtime."],"timeline":[{"year":"1971–1973","title":"Cook and Levin make verification central.","body":"NP-completeness links apparently different search and decision problems through polynomial reductions. Cook's publication appeared in 1971; Levin's independent work appeared in 1973.","sourceIds":["clay-pnp"]},{"year":"1975","title":"Oracle constructions expose a proof-method limitation.","body":"Baker, Gill and Solovay construct oracle worlds with opposite answers to P versus NP.","sourceIds":["bgs-relativization"]},{"year":"1994–1997","title":"Natural proofs identify a conditional circuit barrier.","body":"Razborov and Rudich study properties that are large, efficiently recognizable from truth tables, and useful for lower bounds.","sourceIds":["natural-proofs"]},{"year":"2008","title":"Algebrization refines the oracle boundary.","body":"Aaronson and Wigderson show that low-degree algebraic access still cannot resolve several central separations.","sourceIds":["algebrization"]}],"knownResults":[{"title":"Relativizing arguments cannot settle the original question.","body":"An argument valid uniformly with arbitrary common oracles would contradict one of the opposite oracle examples. This limits a class of techniques, rather than proving independence from standard axioms.","sourceIds":["bgs-relativization"]},{"title":"The natural-proofs barrier has an assumption.","body":"Under the relevant strong pseudorandomness hardness assumption, a constructive, large property cannot prove superpolynomial lower bounds for general circuits. Omitting the assumption changes the theorem.","sourceIds":["natural-proofs"]},{"title":"Arithmetic structure alone does not guarantee escape.","body":"Algebrization captures many methods that surpass ordinary relativization. A candidate proof needs an identified step outside the applicable barrier, not merely algebraic notation.","sourceIds":["algebrization"]}],"dependencies":[{"name":"Polynomial reductions","role":"A reduction transfers a solver or hardness statement only with a proved encoding and runtime bound.","sourceIds":["clay-pnp"]},{"name":"Uniform computation and circuit size","role":"A circuit family may contain advice unavailable to one uniform algorithm; nonuniform lower bounds can be stronger targets.","sourceIds":["natural-proofs"]},{"name":"Worst-case quantifiers","role":"A lower bound ranges over all algorithms, not the particular heuristics tested by an experiment.","sourceIds":["clay-pnp"]},{"name":"Pseudorandomness assumptions","role":"These determine when the natural-proofs obstruction applies and must remain visible in a dependency graph.","sourceIds":["natural-proofs"]}],"approaches":[{"title":"Audit a candidate algorithm before scaling it.","idea":"Write a correctness invariant and count operations in terms of the binary input length. Include branching, numerical precision, preprocessing and the cost of recognizing failure.","obstacle":"Average-case success can hide rare exponential cases. Replacing a difficult subproblem with an oracle merely relocates the difficulty.","nextTest":"Search for an adversarial input family that breaks the invariant or makes a purportedly bounded parameter grow. A counterexample can invalidate a specific algorithm without settling P versus NP.","sourceIds":[]},{"title":"Use restricted lower bounds to test a proof idea.","idea":"State the exact circuit class or proof system first, then test whether the proposed invariant is useful, large or constructive in the relevant formal sense.","obstacle":"A separation for bounded depth, monotone circuits or a chosen proof system does not automatically extend to unrestricted polynomial computation.","nextTest":"Document the first lemma requiring a restricted gate set; attempt a counterexample after adding one missing operation. Treat any surviving extension as a research lead pending a proof.","sourceIds":["natural-proofs","algebrization"]}],"calculations":[{"title":"An exponential search space can encode a linear-time problem.","setup":"Let F_n = x₁ ∧ x₂ ∧ … ∧ x_n. Enumerate assignments in increasing binary order, so the sole satisfying assignment is last.","result":"For n = 4, 8, 12, direct enumeration visits 16, 256, 4096 assignments respectively. Yet reading the n unit clauses immediately supplies the all-true witness in O(n) work.","scope":"The calculation disproves the inference that 2^n possible assignments force every algorithm to take exponential time. It is not a SAT lower bound.","sourceIds":[]}],"implications":[{"condition":"If P = NP with a usable algorithm.","consequence":"Polynomially checkable discrete optimization and search tasks can often be solved through decision-to-search reductions. Polynomial degree and constants still determine practical usefulness.","sourceIds":["clay-pnp"]},{"condition":"If P ≠ NP.","consequence":"Some verifiable tasks lack polynomial worst-case classical algorithms. This alone does not prove average-case hardness or the security of a particular cryptosystem.","sourceIds":["natural-proofs"]}],"quantumConnection":"Shor's algorithm gives quantum polynomial-time factoring and discrete logarithms. Its computational model differs from deterministic classical P, and these algorithms do not settle classical P versus NP. Quantum simulation speedups must be described through their own input and output costs.","sourceIds":["clay-status","clay-pnp","bgs-relativization","natural-proofs","algebrization","shor"]},{"id":"navier-stokes","title":"Navier–Stokes existence and smoothness","status":"active-review","officialStatus":"Active","field":"Partial differential equations and fluid mechanics","question":"Which admissible three-dimensional viscous flows remain smooth, and can a smooth force generate a finite-time singularity?","formulation":"For incompressible velocity u, solve ∂ₜu + (u·∇)u = −∇p + νΔu + f, with div u = 0 and ν > 0. Fefferman's alternatives A/B require global smooth solutions for every admissible smooth divergence-free initial velocity with f = 0 on R³ or the periodic torus. C/D permit a counterexample with forcing satisfying the stated smoothness and decay conditions.","proofObligations":["Choose the exact alternative and retain its domain, initial-data, forcing, global-time and energy requirements.","For a forced breakdown construction, prove that f extends smoothly through and beyond the singular time, with every required derivative and decay bound.","Establish genuine blowup and exclude a globally smooth solution with the same data; a numerical spike or a singular forcing term does not suffice."],"timeline":[{"year":"1934","title":"Leray constructs global weak solutions.","body":"Weak solutions and an energy inequality establish a durable existence framework; they do not by themselves establish global classical smoothness.","sourceIds":["clay-ns"]},{"year":"1982","title":"Partial regularity restricts possible singular sets.","body":"Caffarelli, Kohn and Nirenberg show that the singular set of suitable weak solutions has zero one-dimensional parabolic Hausdorff measure. Isolated singularities are still compatible with that bound.","sourceIds":["clay-ns"]},{"year":"2014–2016","title":"An averaged equation isolates an energy-method barrier.","body":"Tao constructs blowup after modifying the nonlinear operator while preserving its energy cancellation.","sourceIds":["tao-averaged"]},{"year":"8–11 September 2026","title":"A forced resolution is announced and Clay changes its category.","body":"OpenAI publishes a claimed C/D construction and Lean repository. Clay acknowledges an apparent resolution and describes a deliberately unhurried evaluation process; its current category is Active.","sourceIds":["openai-ns-announcement","openai-ns-paper","clay-ns-announcement","clay-status"]},{"year":"September–November 2026","title":"Analytic forcing exposes a precise structural boundary.","body":"Constantin, Ignatova and Vicol study a related symmetry-and-scaling class with analytic forcing. Hou's subsequent commentary explains why this does not refute the smooth nonanalytic construction.","sourceIds":["civ-analytic","hou-scope"]}],"knownResults":[{"title":"The current claim has explicit forcing hypotheses.","body":"Theorem 1.1 in OpenAI's manuscript claims that, for every ν > 0, zero initial velocity and a force f in C∞c(R³ × (0,∞)) produce a flow smooth before t = 1, with bounded L² norm and unbounded L∞ norm as t approaches 1. A periodic corollary is claimed. This dossier inspected those statements and did not independently verify the 166-page proof or replay Lean certificates.","sourceIds":["openai-ns-paper","openai-ns-repository"]},{"title":"Analytic forcing is a stricter condition than smooth forcing.","body":"The Constantin–Ignatova–Vicol preprint proves regularity with exact axisymmetry in a collapsing core, specified anisotropic Type II bounds, and spatially analytic forcing under its stated uniformity assumptions. It does not prove general unforced regularity, and its assumptions differ from the announced smooth nonanalytic forcing.","sourceIds":["civ-analytic"]},{"title":"Award status is a separate record.","body":"Clay's announcement does not announce an awarded prize or completed adjudication. OpenAI's announcement states that it does not intend to claim the prize. The source record therefore separates an announced resolution, published formalization, independent validation and prize decision.","sourceIds":["clay-ns-announcement","openai-ns-announcement","clay-rules"]}],"dependencies":[{"name":"Energy and function spaces","role":"The norm being bounded determines what kind of regularity can follow; kinetic energy does not directly control maximum velocity.","sourceIds":["clay-ns"]},{"name":"All-order residual cancellation","role":"The forced construction must cancel singular terms in ∂ₜu + (u·∇)u − νΔu + ∇p to every required order.","sourceIds":["openai-ns-paper"]},{"name":"Weak–strong comparison","role":"Agreement before the singular time is needed to exclude a different globally smooth solution with the same data.","sourceIds":["openai-ns-paper"]},{"name":"Certificate semantics","role":"A formal check must prove the intended analytic hypotheses rather than assuming them as axioms; matching the formal statement to C/D is part of the work.","sourceIds":["openai-ns-repository"]}],"approaches":[{"title":"Audit one proof dependency at a time.","idea":"A concrete next research task is to isolate smooth force extension, summability of corrections and the comparison argument. Pin the manuscript and formalization revision before reconstructing the dependency graph.","obstacle":"A successful build alone cannot show that formal definitions match the physical PDE; conversely, an explanatory diagram does not check every estimate.","nextTest":"Replay the published independent-checking procedure in an isolated approved environment, inspect theorem assumptions and identify the exact statement checked. That replay has not been performed here.","sourceIds":["openai-ns-repository","hou-scope"]},{"title":"Continue the unforced regularity investigation with a stronger invariant.","idea":"Seek a scale-critical quantity whose evolution uses the actual nonlinearity and pressure structure. Compare any candidate estimate against known model counterexamples.","obstacle":"The energy inequality is too weak by itself, and the published analytic-forcing obstruction blocks a direct transfer of the announced mechanism within its specific structural class.","nextTest":"Derive the candidate differential inequality before discretizing it; record which stretching or nonlocal pressure term prevents closure.","sourceIds":["tao-averaged","civ-analytic"]}],"calculations":[{"title":"The basic energy norm loses control at small scales.","setup":"For the unforced equation on R³, use u_λ(x,t) = λu(λx,λ²t). A change of variables gives ||u_λ||²₂ = λ⁻¹||u||²₂ and ||u_λ||₃ = ||u||₃.","result":"At λ = 1, 4, 16, the squared-energy scale factors are 1, 1/4, 1/16, while the L³ factor stays 1. Increasing concentration can therefore reduce the quantity controlled by the energy estimate.","scope":"This dimensional calculation identifies a limitation of the unforced energy-only route. It neither constructs blowup nor independently validates the announced forced solution.","sourceIds":[]}],"implications":[{"condition":"If the announced forced C/D proof survives independent scrutiny.","consequence":"It resolves an allowed breakdown alternative in the official prize formulation; it does not automatically decide unforced global smoothness or show that the constructed mechanism occurs in ordinary physical flows.","sourceIds":["clay-ns","openai-ns-paper","civ-analytic"]},{"condition":"If a candidate estimate controls only total kinetic energy.","consequence":"It still needs an argument that excludes concentration or controls a stronger continuation criterion.","sourceIds":["tao-averaged"]}],"quantumConnection":"These equations are classical continuum dynamics. Connections to statistical mechanics, hydrodynamic limits and field-theory methods require explicit assumptions; quantum terminology does not repair an unclosed regularity estimate.","sourceIds":["clay-status","clay-ns","clay-ns-announcement","clay-rules","openai-ns-announcement","openai-ns-paper","openai-ns-repository","tao-averaged","civ-analytic","hou-scope"]},{"id":"riemann","title":"Riemann hypothesis","status":"open","officialStatus":"Unsolved","field":"Analytic number theory","question":"Do all nontrivial zeros of the Riemann zeta function lie on the vertical line Re(s) = 1/2?","formulation":"Continue ζ(s) = Σₙ≥₁ n⁻ˢ from Re(s) > 1 to its meromorphic extension. The required statement is that every nontrivial zero ρ satisfies Re(ρ) = 1/2. The functional equation and conjugation symmetry constrain zeros but do not alone place them on that line.","proofObligations":["Cover every nontrivial zero, including arbitrarily large imaginary heights and all allowed multiplicities.","Justify continuation, interchange of infinite sums and integrals, and every limiting estimate used in a candidate proof.","For a spectral route, construct the operator, prove self-adjointness on a specified domain, and prove the exact correspondence between its spectrum and all relevant zeros."],"timeline":[{"year":"1748–1859","title":"Prime products become a complex-analytic question.","body":"Euler's product connects prime numbers with ζ; Riemann's 1859 memoir connects prime counting with the function's zeros.","sourceIds":["clay-rh"]},{"year":"1896","title":"The prime number theorem establishes the leading asymptotic.","body":"Hadamard and de la Vallée Poussin prove the needed zero-free boundary result. A leading asymptotic is weaker than the error control predicted by RH.","sourceIds":["tao-pnt"]},{"year":"1973–1987","title":"Zero statistics connect with random matrices.","body":"Montgomery's pair-correlation work and Odlyzko's numerical investigations link normalized zero spacings to random-matrix statistics.","sourceIds":["odlyzko-spacing"]},{"year":"2018–2021","title":"The de Bruijn–Newman lower bound is proved and revised.","body":"Rodgers and Tao establish Λ ≥ 0; their 2021 revision corrects treatment of boundary-energy contributions. RH would require the complementary bound Λ ≤ 0.","sourceIds":["rodgers-tao"]},{"year":"2020","title":"Interval arithmetic certifies a large finite height.","body":"Platt and Trudgian verify the critical-line property through height at least 3 × 10¹². This is a bounded theorem, not an all-height proof or a claim about the latest record.","sourceIds":["platt-trudgian"]}],"knownResults":[{"title":"Finite verification can be rigorous and still finite.","body":"A certificate counting every zero in a region is stronger than plotting zeros found on the line. Its finite upper boundary remains explicit.","sourceIds":["platt-trudgian"]},{"title":"The Newman result leaves a precise missing direction.","body":"For the heat-deformed xi family, all zeros are real exactly beyond the threshold Λ. The nonnegativity theorem establishes one side; combining it with RH would give Λ = 0.","sourceIds":["rodgers-tao"]},{"title":"Spectral statistics provide evidence, not identification.","body":"Agreement of pair-correlation or spacing distributions does not construct a self-adjoint operator with exactly the zeta zeros as spectral parameters. Statistics can miss a sparse exceptional set.","sourceIds":["odlyzko-spacing"]}],"dependencies":[{"name":"Analytic continuation and functional equation","role":"These define the global object and its symmetries; they are prerequisites rather than the desired conclusion.","sourceIds":["clay-rh"]},{"name":"Explicit formulae","role":"They translate zero-location statements into quantified prime-counting errors.","sourceIds":["clay-rh"]},{"name":"Certified zero counts","role":"A finite computation needs both inclusion of zeros on the line and completeness of the count in its chosen region.","sourceIds":["platt-trudgian"]},{"name":"Spectral domains and positivity","role":"An operator analogy becomes relevant only after its mathematical domain, spectrum and correspondence are established.","sourceIds":["odlyzko-spacing"]}],"approaches":[{"title":"Search for a positivity criterion with an exact equivalence.","idea":"Choose one reformulation of RH and isolate the inequality whose proof would suffice. Keep the kernel, test-function class and normalization fixed.","obstacle":"Proving positivity on a sampled basis or a finite interval leaves uncontrolled directions. Some apparent positivity arguments smuggle RH into a contour deformation or assumed expansion.","nextTest":"Try the proposed inequality on deliberately constructed symmetric entire functions with off-line zeros. If the proof accepts them, identify the missing arithmetic property of ζ.","sourceIds":[]},{"title":"Explore the heat-flow threshold without assuming its value.","idea":"Track the dynamics of zeros in the de Bruijn–Newman deformation and reproduce a controlled finite approximation.","obstacle":"A numerical trajectory does not bound every zero or the infinite-height tail. The known lower bound cannot be inverted into the missing upper bound.","nextTest":"Separate truncation error, finite-height certificate and an analytic tail bound; report any interval for Λ with its actual hypotheses.","sourceIds":["rodgers-tao"]}],"calculations":[{"title":"Reflection and conjugation symmetry permit off-line zeros.","setup":"Define P(s) = ((s − 1/5)² + 1)((s − 4/5)² + 1).","result":"Exact rational expansion gives P(s) = s⁴ − 2s³ + (83/25)s² − (58/25)s + 1066/625. Its coefficients are real and P(1 − s) = P(s), yet its roots are 1/5 ± i and 4/5 ± i.","scope":"This explicit countermodel defeats a proof using only those two symmetries. P is not ζ or the completed xi function and has no corresponding Euler product.","sourceIds":[]}],"implications":[{"condition":"If RH is proved.","consequence":"The prime-counting error obeys π(x) = Li(x) + O(√x log x), with the usual asymptotic interpretation. Statements requiring generalized RH for other L-functions still need their own hypotheses.","sourceIds":["clay-rh"]},{"condition":"If an off-line zero is rigorously certified.","consequence":"RH is false. A floating-point near-zero requires an error-controlled existence argument and a certified real part away from 1/2.","sourceIds":[]}],"quantumConnection":"Random-matrix ensembles also model quantum spectral statistics, so the comparison is mathematically substantive. A shared statistical law does not establish a historical causal chain or prove a Hilbert–Pólya spectral realization.","sourceIds":["clay-status","clay-rh","platt-trudgian","odlyzko-spacing","rodgers-tao","tao-pnt"]},{"id":"hodge","title":"Hodge conjecture","status":"open","officialStatus":"Unsolved","field":"Algebraic geometry and topology","question":"Which topological classes on a smooth projective complex variety come from algebraic subvarieties?","formulation":"For a smooth projective complex variety X and any p, every class in H²ᵖ(X,Q) ∩ Hᵖ,ᵖ(X) should be a rational linear combination of cohomology classes of codimension-p algebraic cycles. Rational coefficients, projectivity and smoothness are part of the question.","proofObligations":["Start with an arbitrary rational Hodge class in the stated category and construct algebraic cycles with the required rational cohomology class.","Distinguish a harmonic differential-form representative from an algebraic-cycle representative.","Keep integral, rational, projective and general Kähler variants separate; a theorem or counterexample in one category may not transfer."],"timeline":[{"year":"1950","title":"Hodge formulates the geometric question.","body":"The conjecture appears in his International Congress contribution on topological invariants of algebraic varieties, published in the proceedings in 1952.","sourceIds":["clay-hodge"]},{"year":"1953","title":"Divisor classes provide the accessible model.","body":"The line-bundle argument through the exponential sequence gives the degree-two case; extending its conclusion to arbitrary codimension requires new input.","sourceIds":["clay-hodge"]},{"year":"1962","title":"Atiyah and Hirzebruch disprove the integral strengthening.","body":"They find torsion cohomological obstructions to classes represented by analytic cycles, including examples in the projective category.","sourceIds":["atiyah-hirzebruch"]},{"year":"1994–1995","title":"The locus of Hodge classes is shown to be algebraic.","body":"Cattani, Deligne and Kaplan prove a precise result about variation in algebraic families without assuming the full conjecture.","sourceIds":["hodge-locus"]},{"year":"2001–2002","title":"Voisin tests the Kähler extension.","body":"Her counterexample shows that even Chern classes of coherent analytic sheaves need not generate all rational Hodge classes on general compact Kähler manifolds.","sourceIds":["voisin-kahler"]}],"knownResults":[{"title":"The codimension-one case has an explicit mechanism.","body":"An integral class of type (1,1) lifts to the first Chern class of a line bundle through the exponential exact sequence; in the projective setting divisors then supply algebraic classes.","sourceIds":["clay-hodge"]},{"title":"Topological obstructions survive before rationalization.","body":"Atiyah–Hirzebruch obstructions use torsion operations. Their failure of an integral statement leaves open the rational statement, where torsion disappears.","sourceIds":["atiyah-hirzebruch"]},{"title":"An algebraic parameter locus does not provide every cycle.","body":"The Hodge-locus theorem controls where a class remains of the necessary type in a family. It does not assert that every such class has the required algebraic representative.","sourceIds":["hodge-locus"]},{"title":"Projectivity cannot be dropped casually.","body":"Voisin's examples distinguish analytic subsets, vector bundles and coherent sheaves on compact Kähler spaces; equivalences available in projective geometry need not survive that enlargement.","sourceIds":["voisin-kahler"]}],"dependencies":[{"name":"Hodge decomposition","role":"This supplies the (p,p) condition that a rational cohomology class must satisfy.","sourceIds":["clay-hodge"]},{"name":"Cycle-class maps","role":"These connect algebraic subvarieties and their formal combinations to cohomology.","sourceIds":["atiyah-hirzebruch"]},{"name":"Line bundles and Chern classes","role":"The divisor case gives a constructive model, while higher Chern classes expose a richer obstruction problem.","sourceIds":["clay-hodge","voisin-kahler"]},{"name":"Variations of Hodge structure","role":"Transport through families allows the necessary Hodge condition to be studied geometrically in parameter space.","sourceIds":["hodge-locus"]}],"approaches":[{"title":"Construct cycles in a specified family and compare spans.","idea":"Choose a family with computable cohomology, list geometric cycles and calculate their rational span inside the Hodge subspace. State exactly which codimensions and fibers are covered.","obstacle":"A match in a special family does not exhaust all smooth projective varieties. Dimension counting may depend on an unproved claim that every Hodge class has been found.","nextTest":"Independently certify the Hodge-space dimension and cycle-class matrix in a bounded example; retain any unresolved rank calculation as a gap.","sourceIds":[]},{"title":"Investigate deformation with the representation problem visible.","idea":"Transport a class along its Hodge locus and ask whether a known cycle can deform with it. Track the obstruction to extending the actual cycle, rather than only its cohomology class.","obstacle":"The algebraicity of the locus does not imply a global family of representing cycles. Monodromy, special fibers and extension obstructions can intervene.","nextTest":"Produce a local deformation calculation in one family, then name the theorem that would justify passage to arbitrary fibers. If that theorem is the conjecture itself, the argument is circular.","sourceIds":["hodge-locus"]}],"calculations":[{"title":"Rational generation and integral generation differ.","setup":"Use the additive subgroup 2Z inside Z as a simple model for the coefficient distinction.","result":"Its rational span contains 1 because (1/2)·2 = 1, but no integer multiple of 2 equals 1. An exact rational check confirms the first identity; reduction modulo 2 proves the second claim.","scope":"This is an elementary algebraic counterexample to conflating coefficient systems. It is not itself a geometric counterexample to the Hodge conjecture.","sourceIds":[]}],"implications":[{"condition":"If the rational Hodge conjecture holds.","consequence":"The specified rational topological classes acquire algebraic representatives. This would strengthen the bridge between cohomological invariants and algebraic correspondences.","sourceIds":["clay-hodge"]},{"condition":"If a counterexample is proposed.","consequence":"It must remain smooth and projective and use a rational Hodge class with no rational algebraic representative; integral torsion or a nonprojective Kähler example is insufficient.","sourceIds":["atiyah-hirzebruch","voisin-kahler"]}],"quantumConnection":"Hodge theory and algebraic geometry occur in mathematical physics, but their shared use does not make this conjecture a quantum-mechanical prediction. No inspected source here establishes a quantum experiment that would decide the universal algebraic-cycle question.","sourceIds":["clay-status","clay-hodge","atiyah-hirzebruch","voisin-kahler","hodge-locus"]},{"id":"birch-swinnerton-dyer","title":"Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer conjecture","status":"open","officialStatus":"Unsolved","field":"Arithmetic geometry and L-functions","question":"Can the order of vanishing of an elliptic curve's L-function determine the number of independent rational points?","formulation":"For every elliptic curve E over Q, write E(Q) ≅ Zʳ ⊕ E(Q)tors. The official rank question asserts ordₛ₌₁ L(E,s) = r. The stronger leading-coefficient formula also involves periods, the regulator, local factors, torsion and the Tate–Shafarevich group; it is a separate refinement.","proofObligations":["Relate an analytic order of vanishing to the algebraic rank for each elliptic curve in the stated scope, including higher-rank cases.","Certify independence and completeness when proposing generators; finding several rational points gives only a lower bound.","For the stronger formula, retain exact normalizations and all local factors, and prove the necessary finiteness statement instead of assuming it."],"timeline":[{"year":"1922","title":"Mordell proves finite generation.","body":"The group of rational points has finite rank plus finite torsion, making the rank a well-defined arithmetic invariant.","sourceIds":["clay-bsd"]},{"year":"Early 1960s","title":"Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer turn computations into a conjecture.","body":"Experiments with an EDSAC computer connect local point counts with rational-point behavior. Those observations motivate a universal statement rather than prove it.","sourceIds":["clay-bsd"]},{"year":"1986–1989","title":"Heegner points and Euler systems connect analysis with arithmetic.","body":"Gross–Zagier's height formula and Kolyvagin's methods produce decisive low-rank results under the relevant modular and nonvanishing hypotheses.","sourceIds":["gross-zagier","kolyvagin"]},{"year":"2001","title":"Modularity reaches every elliptic curve over Q.","body":"Breuil, Conrad, Diamond and Taylor complete the modularity theorem, building on Wiles and Taylor–Wiles.","sourceIds":["modularity"]},{"year":"2015","title":"Counting methods control positive proportions.","body":"Bhargava and Shankar's 3-Selmer work proves average and positive-proportion statements when curves are ordered by height.","sourceIds":["bhargava-shankar"]}],"knownResults":[{"title":"Analytic rank zero and one are established regimes for rank equality.","body":"Combined modularity and Gross–Zagier–Kolyvagin results yield algebraic rank equal to analytic rank when the latter is 0 or 1. This should not be expanded into an unrestricted assertion of every refined BSD factor for every curve.","sourceIds":["clay-bsd","gross-zagier","kolyvagin","modularity"]},{"title":"A first derivative can detect a non-torsion Heegner point.","body":"Gross and Zagier connect a suitable L-series derivative to a canonical height. A simple zero supplies a rational point of infinite order in their modular elliptic-curve consequence; this does not alone exclude additional independent points.","sourceIds":["gross-zagier"]},{"title":"A density theorem does not settle each exceptional curve.","body":"The average size of the 3-Selmer group is 4 in the Bhargava–Shankar height ordering. Their result gives positive proportions with relevant rank properties, while a universal conjecture still requires every curve.","sourceIds":["bhargava-shankar"]}],"dependencies":[{"name":"Mordell–Weil group and canonical height","role":"Rank is algebraic; height pairings provide a way to test independence of proposed points.","sourceIds":["clay-bsd","gross-zagier"]},{"name":"Local point counts and Euler factors","role":"At a good prime p, a_p = p + 1 − #E(F_p) determines the factor (1 − a_pp⁻ˢ + p¹⁻²ˢ)⁻¹.","sourceIds":["clay-bsd"]},{"name":"Modularity and analytic continuation","role":"These make the central L-function behavior accessible through modular forms.","sourceIds":["modularity"]},{"name":"Selmer groups and Tate–Shafarevich groups","role":"They measure constraints and obstructions between local arithmetic and global rational points.","sourceIds":["kolyvagin","bhargava-shankar"]}],"approaches":[{"title":"Compare independently certified algebraic and analytic bounds.","idea":"For one explicit curve, compute a rigorous lower bound from independent points and an upper bound through descent; separately certify the analytic order with error-controlled evaluation.","obstacle":"A tiny numerical L-value is not proof of exact vanishing. An unresolved Selmer contribution can prevent an algebraic upper bound from matching the points found.","nextTest":"Publish the curve model, conductor, bad primes, height-pairing certificate, error bounds and unresolved factors. A successful curve-level verification is valuable without implying the universal theorem.","sourceIds":[]},{"title":"Look for a higher-rank replacement of the low-rank mechanism.","idea":"Ask what arithmetic object would produce several independent points and match a higher derivative, then state the exact reciprocity or height identity needed.","obstacle":"The first-derivative formula becomes silent when that derivative vanishes. Reusing it with a new name does not produce higher-rank information.","nextTest":"Identify a restricted family and one missing identity; compare it with known Euler-system or modularity hypotheses before investing in computation. This is a proposed research question, not a new theorem.","sourceIds":["gross-zagier","kolyvagin"]}],"calculations":[{"title":"Local counts can be reproduced exactly.","setup":"For E: y² = x³ − x, enumerate all pairs modulo the good primes 5, 7, 11, 13 and 17, adding the point at infinity.","result":"The exact counts are #E(F_p) = 8, 8, 12, 8, 16, giving a_p = −2, 0, 0, 6, 2 respectively. Two enumeration methods agree, and each satisfies a_p² ≤ 4p.","scope":"This checks local Euler-factor input. These five factors do not determine the full L-function's vanishing order, and this calculation makes no independent claim about the rational rank.","sourceIds":[]}],"implications":[{"condition":"If rank equality is proved universally.","consequence":"The central analytic zero order would determine the rank of E(Q) in the official scope. Effective generator-finding still requires attention to constructive bounds and stronger arithmetic information.","sourceIds":["clay-bsd"]},{"condition":"If a point search finds no non-torsion point.","consequence":"Only the searched height range has been exhausted. A proof of rank zero needs an arithmetic upper bound or a theorem that certifies the analytic regime.","sourceIds":[]}],"quantumConnection":"Elliptic curves also occur in cryptography, but BSD concerns rational points and a central L-value. Shor's quantum discrete-logarithm algorithm addresses a different computational task; it neither proves BSD nor makes BSD equivalent to breaking an elliptic-curve cryptosystem.","sourceIds":["clay-status","clay-bsd","gross-zagier","kolyvagin","modularity","bhargava-shankar","shor"]},{"id":"poincare","title":"Poincaré conjecture","status":"solved","officialStatus":"Solved","field":"Geometric topology and geometric analysis","question":"Is every closed simply connected three-dimensional manifold a three-sphere?","formulation":"If M is a closed connected three-manifold with trivial fundamental group, then M is homeomorphic to S³. Clay records this problem as solved by Grigori Perelman's 2002–2003 work, building on Richard Hamilton's Ricci flow.","proofObligations":["Preserve the word closed, meaning compact without boundary, and the full fundamental-group condition.","Control geometric singularities during the flow and justify every topological change introduced by surgery.","Connect the controlled evolution back to the original manifold; resemblance to a round shape or agreement of homology groups does not suffice."],"timeline":[{"year":"1900–1904","title":"Poincaré corrects his earlier homology criterion.","body":"The homology-sphere example shows that sphere-like homology need not imply sphere topology; the fundamental group becomes essential.","sourceIds":["clay-poincare"]},{"year":"1982","title":"Hamilton establishes Ricci-flow control under positive curvature.","body":"A compact three-manifold initially admitting strictly positive Ricci curvature also admits constant positive curvature. The curvature hypothesis is a real restriction.","sourceIds":["hamilton"]},{"year":"November 2002","title":"Perelman introduces new monotonic quantities.","body":"The entropy paper controls geometric degeneration and develops key parts of the Hamilton program.","sourceIds":["perelman-entropy"]},{"year":"March–July 2003","title":"Surgery and finite extinction complete the route for the relevant topology.","body":"Perelman's subsequent papers construct the surgery flow and establish extinction for the stated class of prime decompositions.","sourceIds":["perelman-surgery","perelman-extinction"]},{"year":"2010","title":"Clay recognizes the accepted resolution.","body":"The official solved page links its March 2010 prize announcement and detailed expositions of the proof.","sourceIds":["clay-poincare-status"]}],"knownResults":[{"title":"Positive curvature is not an arbitrary starting metric.","body":"Hamilton's theorem treats a strong geometric hypothesis. A proof for all simply connected closed three-manifolds needs machinery that also handles metrics lacking that initial positivity.","sourceIds":["hamilton"]},{"title":"Monotonicity controls degeneration.","body":"Perelman's entropy and noncollapsing results supply geometric control near singularities. The word entropy names a defined functional and its proved behavior, not a universal physical principle imported without assumptions.","sourceIds":["perelman-entropy"]},{"title":"The surgery and extinction statements retain their scope.","body":"The surgery paper explicitly corrects an earlier unjustified assertion that was unnecessary for the conclusions. The extinction theorem applies when the prime decomposition has no aspherical factors, rather than to every closed three-manifold.","sourceIds":["perelman-surgery","perelman-extinction"]},{"title":"The accepted proof is the reference result.","body":"This dossier does not offer a replacement proof. Its restricted calculations examine why simpler geometric pictures do not by themselves establish the topological theorem.","sourceIds":["clay-poincare-status"]}],"dependencies":[{"name":"Fundamental group","role":"This encodes the contraction of loops; homology alone forgets information required by the conjecture.","sourceIds":["clay-poincare"]},{"name":"Ricci flow","role":"The metric evolves by ∂ₜg = −2 Ric(g); the evolution is a geometric tool for understanding the manifold.","sourceIds":["hamilton"]},{"name":"Noncollapsing and singularity models","role":"Geometric estimates constrain which local degenerations can occur and support controlled continuation.","sourceIds":["perelman-entropy","perelman-surgery"]},{"name":"Surgery and topological bookkeeping","role":"Each removal or gluing must have a justified effect on the original manifold's decomposition.","sourceIds":["perelman-surgery","perelman-extinction"]}],"approaches":[{"title":"Reconstruct a limited proof dependency graph.","idea":"Begin with the accepted proof and choose one controlled lemma: a monotonic functional, a round-neck model or the extinction comparison. Write the hypotheses and the exact downstream use.","obstacle":"A local computation can omit the global compactness and topological arguments that make the lemma useful. Replacing a hard step with a suggestive visualization leaves the proof incomplete.","nextTest":"Verify the chosen lemma in a symmetric model, then list which assumptions fail for a general evolving metric. Preserve the accepted proof as the standard against which the reconstruction is checked.","sourceIds":["perelman-entropy","perelman-surgery"]},{"title":"Use counterexamples to test weakened statements.","idea":"Compare simple connectivity with homology and compare closed manifolds with open manifolds. Ask which property a proposed shortcut actually uses.","obstacle":"The homology-sphere and open-manifold histories show that changing one quantifier or topological condition can create a false statement.","nextTest":"Make an explicit invariant table for S³, a nontrivial homology sphere and an open contractible example, with the distinction justified by topology rather than rendered appearance.","sourceIds":["clay-poincare"]}],"calculations":[{"title":"A round three-sphere becomes extinct under unnormalized Ricci flow.","setup":"Write g(t) = r(t)²g_unit on S³. Since Ric(g(t)) = 2g_unit, the flow gives d(r²)/dt = −4.","result":"Thus r(t)² = r₀² − 4t. With r₀ = 2, the exact extinction time is 1; at t = 0, 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, the squared radii are 4, 3, 2, 1.","scope":"The algebra and ODE are independently checked. A round model already assumes sphere topology; its extinction is not a proof for an arbitrary closed simply connected manifold.","sourceIds":["hamilton"]}],"implications":[{"condition":"For a closed simply connected three-manifold.","consequence":"The accepted theorem identifies its topological type as S³. A new visualization can explain this result, but does not create another unresolved prize problem.","sourceIds":["clay-poincare-status"]},{"condition":"When geometric-flow methods are transferred elsewhere.","consequence":"One must identify an appropriate monotonic quantity, compactness theorem and controlled singularity treatment in the new setting. The success of the Poincaré proof does not establish those ingredients automatically.","sourceIds":[]}],"quantumConnection":"Perelman's entropy paper includes a statistical interpretation, and geometric analysis overlaps with field-theory language. The proof remains a theorem about metrics and three-manifold topology; no quantum experiment is required to establish its conclusion.","sourceIds":["clay-status","clay-poincare","clay-poincare-status","hamilton","perelman-entropy","perelman-surgery","perelman-extinction"]}]},"calculations":{"schema":"xlvii.quantum-calculations.v1","computedOn":"2026-11-19","scope":"Restricted calculations and proof diagnostics. No Millennium solution or independent validation of an announced solution.","environment":{"python":"3.12.13","numpy":"2.4.6","scipy":"1.18.0","sympy":"1.14.0","seed":47,"threads":1},"spin":{"hamiltonian":"H = -J Σ Z_i Z_(i+1) - h Σ X_i; Pauli eigenvalues ±1; periodic chain; J=1.","method":"Sparse Lanczos eigensolver; two lowest algebraic eigenvalues; deterministic starting vectors; residuals retained.","rows":[{"n":4,"h":0.5,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":16,"groundEnergy":-4.271558410139713,"firstEnergy":-4.236067977499788,"gap":0.03549043263992502,"maxResidual":5.064479955569564e-15,"weylLowerBound":-7},{"n":4,"h":1,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":16,"groundEnergy":-5.226251859505506,"firstEnergy":-4.828427124746189,"gap":0.39782473475931734,"maxResidual":3.40070935689254e-15,"weylLowerBound":-6,"criticalReference":0.397824734759316,"criticalAbsoluteError":1.3322676295501878e-15},{"n":4,"h":1.5,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":16,"groundEnergy":-6.760008550556146,"firstEnergy":-5.605551275463988,"gap":1.1544572750921578,"maxResidual":4.3749007500860206e-15,"weylLowerBound":-5},{"n":6,"h":0.5,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":64,"groundEnergy":-6.384694563603677,"firstEnergy":-6.377802118633477,"gap":0.006892444970199918,"maxResidual":1.8819677205248835e-14,"weylLowerBound":-11},{"n":6,"h":1,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":64,"groundEnergy":-7.727406610312555,"firstEnergy":-7.464101615137751,"gap":0.26330499517480455,"maxResidual":4.949033568926758e-12,"weylLowerBound":-10,"criticalReference":0.26330499517479167,"criticalAbsoluteError":1.2878587085651816e-14},{"n":6,"h":1.5,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":64,"groundEnergy":-10.056946423167577,"firstEnergy":-9.00465025460528,"gap":1.0522961685622967,"maxResidual":1.6989863613107938e-14,"weylLowerBound":-9},{"n":8,"h":0.5,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":256,"groundEnergy":-8.50908223514027,"firstEnergy":-8.507626387639506,"gap":0.0014558475007628857,"maxResidual":2.351819198049687e-14,"weylLowerBound":-15},{"n":8,"h":1,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":256,"groundEnergy":-10.251661790966017,"firstEnergy":-10.054678984251682,"gap":0.19698280671433466,"maxResidual":1.74310979926084e-14,"weylLowerBound":-14,"criticalReference":0.1969828067143285,"criticalAbsoluteError":6.161737786669619e-15},{"n":8,"h":1.5,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":256,"groundEnergy":-13.385005233150737,"firstEnergy":-12.365559826020153,"gap":1.0194454071305845,"maxResidual":1.40001170117205e-13,"weylLowerBound":-13},{"n":10,"h":0.5,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":1024,"groundEnergy":-10.635604409347966,"firstEnergy":-10.635283682667284,"gap":0.0003207266806821707,"maxResidual":9.755794773631752e-15,"weylLowerBound":-19},{"n":10,"h":1,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":1024,"groundEnergy":-12.784906442999317,"firstEnergy":-12.62750302935008,"gap":0.15740341364923616,"maxResidual":1.509808843026947e-12,"weylLowerBound":-18,"criticalReference":0.15740341364923688,"criticalAbsoluteError":7.216449660063518e-16},{"n":10,"h":1.5,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":1024,"groundEnergy":-16.723024913948443,"firstEnergy":-15.715455069836976,"gap":1.007569844111467,"maxResidual":2.4490511159280414e-12,"weylLowerBound":-17},{"n":12,"h":0.5,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":4096,"groundEnergy":-12.762569151024028,"firstEnergy":-12.762496682237135,"gap":0.00007246878689315395,"maxResidual":1.6657523193717389e-12,"weylLowerBound":-23},{"n":12,"h":1,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":4096,"groundEnergy":-15.322595151080765,"firstEnergy":-15.191508225450297,"gap":0.1310869256304681,"maxResidual":1.6078473921886788e-14,"weylLowerBound":-22,"criticalReference":0.13108692563047644,"criticalAbsoluteError":8.354428260304303e-15},{"n":12,"h":1.5,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":4096,"groundEnergy":-20.064624685045114,"firstEnergy":-19.06159667777287,"gap":1.0030280072722455,"maxResidual":8.96336962212855e-13,"weylLowerBound":-21},{"n":14,"h":0.5,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":16384,"groundEnergy":-14.889630066250596,"firstEnergy":-14.889613412651977,"gap":0.00001665359861924287,"maxResidual":2.0678779314254065e-14,"weylLowerBound":-27},{"n":14,"h":1,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":16384,"groundEnergy":-17.862808540761026,"firstEnergy":-17.75049094993948,"gap":0.11231759082154724,"maxResidual":1.2231034675821421e-13,"weylLowerBound":-26,"criticalReference":0.11231759082149897,"criticalAbsoluteError":4.826694599557868e-14},{"n":14,"h":1.5,"J":1,"boundary":"periodic","dimension":16384,"groundEnergy":-23.40758298202166,"firstEnergy":-22.406349774262186,"gap":1.0012332077594728,"maxResidual":1.2834656712995186e-12,"weylLowerBound":-25}],"exactRestrictedResult":"For H0=-h Σ X_i with h>0, the commuting X_i have a joint ±1 eigenbasis. Energies are -hN+2hk for k=0,...,N. The unique ground state has k=0 and the spectral gap is exactly 2h for every finite N.","perturbationResult":"For V=-J Σ Z_i Z_(i+1), ||V||≤N|J|. Weyl inequalities give Δ(H0+V)≥2h-2N|J|. This lower bound is uninformative when nonpositive; it does not prove the true gap closes.","criticalReference":"At J=h=1, the periodic chain's lowest gap is 2 tan(π/(4N)), tending to π/(2N). The numerical spectrum is checked against this exact finite-size reference.","limit":"These are one-dimensional spin systems at finite N, not a construction of four-dimensional continuum Yang–Mills. E1−E0 is the finite-chain first-level separation. For h<1 its decrease reflects the ordered phase’s nearly degenerate ground-state doublet; it is not the bulk excitation gap above the ground-state manifold. A finite positive separation alone gives no uniform infinite-volume or cutoff-removal bound. Numerical residuals certify approximate eigenpairs, not complete spectral ordering; the exact critical comparison is an additional check."},"chsh":{"state":"|Φ+⟩=(|00⟩+|11⟩)/√2","settings":"A0=Z; A1=X; B0=cosθ Z+sinθ X; B1=cosθ Z−sinθ X","classicalAssignments":[{"a0":-1,"a1":-1,"b0":-1,"b1":-1,"S":2},{"a0":-1,"a1":-1,"b0":-1,"b1":1,"S":2},{"a0":-1,"a1":-1,"b0":1,"b1":-1,"S":-2},{"a0":-1,"a1":-1,"b0":1,"b1":1,"S":-2},{"a0":-1,"a1":1,"b0":-1,"b1":-1,"S":2},{"a0":-1,"a1":1,"b0":-1,"b1":1,"S":-2},{"a0":-1,"a1":1,"b0":1,"b1":-1,"S":2},{"a0":-1,"a1":1,"b0":1,"b1":1,"S":-2},{"a0":1,"a1":-1,"b0":-1,"b1":-1,"S":-2},{"a0":1,"a1":-1,"b0":-1,"b1":1,"S":2},{"a0":1,"a1":-1,"b0":1,"b1":-1,"S":-2},{"a0":1,"a1":-1,"b0":1,"b1":1,"S":2},{"a0":1,"a1":1,"b0":-1,"b1":-1,"S":-2},{"a0":1,"a1":1,"b0":-1,"b1":1,"S":-2},{"a0":1,"a1":1,"b0":1,"b1":-1,"S":2},{"a0":1,"a1":1,"b0":1,"b1":1,"S":2}],"angles":[{"degrees":0,"S":1.9999999999999996,"localBound":2},{"degrees":1,"S":2.0346002031873494,"localBound":2},{"degrees":2,"S":2.0685806474431927,"localBound":2},{"degrees":3,"S":2.101930981995035,"localBound":2},{"degrees":4,"S":2.134641048007899,"localBound":2},{"degrees":5,"S":2.166700881678807,"localBound":2},{"degrees":6,"S":2.198100717271853,"localBound":2},{"degrees":7,"S":2.228830990092938,"localBound":2},{"degrees":8,"S":2.258882339403271,"localBound":2},{"degrees":9,"S":2.288245611270737,"localBound":2},{"degrees":10,"S":2.3169118613582764,"localBound":2},{"degrees":11,"S":2.344872357648417,"localBound":2},{"degrees":12,"S":2.3721185831031293,"localBound":2},{"degrees":13,"S":2.3986422382582,"localBound":2},{"degrees":14,"S":2.424435243751328,"localBound":2},{"degrees":15,"S":2.449489742783178,"localBound":2},{"degrees":16,"S":2.4737981035106356,"localBound":2},{"degrees":17,"S":2.497352921371544,"localBound":2},{"degrees":18,"S":2.5201470213402017,"localBound":2},{"degrees":19,"S":2.542173460112947,"localBound":2},{"degrees":20,"S":2.5634255282231537,"localBound":2},{"degrees":21,"S":2.5838967520850034,"localBound":2},{"degrees":22,"S":2.6035808959653983,"localBound":2},{"degrees":23,"S":2.622471963883428,"localBound":2},{"degrees":24,"S":2.640564201436802,"localBound":2},{"degrees":25,"S":2.657852097554698,"localBound":2},{"degrees":26,"S":2.6743303861764884,"localBound":2},{"degrees":27,"S":2.6899940478558286,"localBound":2},{"degrees":28,"S":2.704838311289635,"localBound":2},{"degrees":29,"S":2.718858654771465,"localBound":2},{"degrees":30,"S":2.7320508075688767,"localBound":2},{"degrees":31,"S":2.7444107512243323,"localBound":2},{"degrees":32,"S":2.755934720779261,"localBound":2},{"degrees":33,"S":2.7666192059209016,"localBound":2},{"degrees":34,"S":2.7764609520515764,"localBound":2},{"degrees":35,"S":2.785456961280075,"localBound":2},{"degrees":36,"S":2.7936044933348407,"localBound":2},{"degrees":37,"S":2.8009010663986813,"localBound":2},{"degrees":38,"S":2.80734445786476,"localBound":2},{"degrees":39,"S":2.8129327050136164,"localBound":2},{"degrees":40,"S":2.8176641056110343,"localBound":2},{"degrees":41,"S":2.8215372184265584,"localBound":2},{"degrees":42,"S":2.8245508636725045,"localBound":2},{"degrees":43,"S":2.8267041233633377,"localBound":2},{"degrees":44,"S":2.8279963415952962,"localBound":2},{"degrees":45,"S":2.8284271247461894,"localBound":2},{"degrees":46,"S":2.8279963415952962,"localBound":2},{"degrees":47,"S":2.8267041233633377,"localBound":2},{"degrees":48,"S":2.8245508636725045,"localBound":2},{"degrees":49,"S":2.8215372184265584,"localBound":2},{"degrees":50,"S":2.8176641056110343,"localBound":2},{"degrees":51,"S":2.8129327050136164,"localBound":2},{"degrees":52,"S":2.8073444578647604,"localBound":2},{"degrees":53,"S":2.8009010663986817,"localBound":2},{"degrees":54,"S":2.7936044933348407,"localBound":2},{"degrees":55,"S":2.785456961280075,"localBound":2},{"degrees":56,"S":2.776460952051577,"localBound":2},{"degrees":57,"S":2.7666192059209016,"localBound":2},{"degrees":58,"S":2.755934720779261,"localBound":2},{"degrees":59,"S":2.7444107512243323,"localBound":2},{"degrees":60,"S":2.7320508075688767,"localBound":2},{"degrees":61,"S":2.718858654771465,"localBound":2},{"degrees":62,"S":2.704838311289635,"localBound":2},{"degrees":63,"S":2.6899940478558286,"localBound":2},{"degrees":64,"S":2.6743303861764884,"localBound":2},{"degrees":65,"S":2.657852097554698,"localBound":2},{"degrees":66,"S":2.640564201436802,"localBound":2},{"degrees":67,"S":2.6224719638834277,"localBound":2},{"degrees":68,"S":2.6035808959653983,"localBound":2},{"degrees":69,"S":2.583896752085004,"localBound":2},{"degrees":70,"S":2.5634255282231537,"localBound":2},{"degrees":71,"S":2.5421734601129464,"localBound":2},{"degrees":72,"S":2.5201470213402017,"localBound":2},{"degrees":73,"S":2.497352921371544,"localBound":2},{"degrees":74,"S":2.4737981035106356,"localBound":2},{"degrees":75,"S":2.449489742783178,"localBound":2},{"degrees":76,"S":2.4244352437513275,"localBound":2},{"degrees":77,"S":2.3986422382582,"localBound":2},{"degrees":78,"S":2.3721185831031293,"localBound":2},{"degrees":79,"S":2.3448723576484176,"localBound":2},{"degrees":80,"S":2.3169118613582764,"localBound":2},{"degrees":81,"S":2.288245611270737,"localBound":2},{"degrees":82,"S":2.258882339403271,"localBound":2},{"degrees":83,"S":2.228830990092938,"localBound":2},{"degrees":84,"S":2.198100717271853,"localBound":2},{"degrees":85,"S":2.166700881678807,"localBound":2},{"degrees":86,"S":2.134641048007899,"localBound":2},{"degrees":87,"S":2.1019309819950354,"localBound":2},{"degrees":88,"S":2.068580647443193,"localBound":2},{"degrees":89,"S":2.0346002031873494,"localBound":2},{"degrees":90,"S":1.9999999999999996,"localBound":2}],"maximum":2.8284271247461903,"visibilityThreshold":0.7071067811865475,"reducedDensityMatrix":[[0.4999999999999999,0],[0,0.4999999999999999]],"scope":"Classical bound assumes a setting-independent shared hidden-variable distribution and local outcomes. Convex mixtures of deterministic assignments obey the bound. The modeled quantum correlations do not permit signalling and are not experimental observations. The visibility threshold applies only to ρ_v=v|Φ+⟩⟨Φ+|+(1−v)I/4 at θ=45°; S=2√2 v and violation occurs for v>1/√2. It is not a universal entanglement threshold."},"riemann":{"polynomial":"s**4 - 2*s**3 + 27*s**2/8 - 19*s/8 + 425/256","symmetryDifference":"0","roots":[{"real":0.25,"imaginary":1},{"real":0.25,"imaginary":-1},{"real":0.75,"imaginary":1},{"real":0.75,"imaginary":-1}],"claim":"Conjugation symmetry and reflection s→1−s do not alone force zeros onto Re(s)=1/2.","scope":"This polynomial is not the Riemann zeta function or its completion. It only refutes the proposed symmetry-only inference, not the Riemann hypothesis."},"fluidScaling":{"equation":"u_λ(x,t)=λu(λx,λ²t); p_λ(x,t)=λ²p(λx,λ²t); f_λ(x,t)=λ³f(λx,λ²t)","normLaw":"||u_λ||_p=λ^(1−3/p)||u||_p on R³; ||u_λ||_∞=λ||u||_∞.","rows":[{"lambdaValue":1,"L2Norm":1,"L2Squared":1,"L3Norm":1,"LInfinity":1,"enstrophy":1},{"lambdaValue":2,"L2Norm":0.7071067811865476,"L2Squared":0.5,"L3Norm":1,"LInfinity":2,"enstrophy":2},{"lambdaValue":4,"L2Norm":0.5,"L2Squared":0.25,"L3Norm":1,"LInfinity":4,"enstrophy":4},{"lambdaValue":8,"L2Norm":0.3535533905932738,"L2Squared":0.125,"L3Norm":1,"LInfinity":8,"enstrophy":8},{"lambdaValue":16,"L2Norm":0.25,"L2Squared":0.0625,"L3Norm":1,"LInfinity":16,"enstrophy":16},{"lambdaValue":32,"L2Norm":0.1767766952966369,"L2Squared":0.03125,"L3Norm":1,"LInfinity":32,"enstrophy":32},{"lambdaValue":64,"L2Norm":0.125,"L2Squared":0.015625,"L3Norm":1,"LInfinity":64,"enstrophy":64},{"lambdaValue":128,"L2Norm":0.08838834764831845,"L2Squared":0.0078125,"L3Norm":1,"LInfinity":128,"enstrophy":128},{"lambdaValue":256,"L2Norm":0.0625,"L2Squared":0.00390625,"L3Norm":1,"LInfinity":256,"enstrophy":256}],"energy":"For smooth, decaying, divergence-free unforced solutions, (1/2)d||u||₂²/dt + ν||∇u||₂² = 0. With force, add ∫f·u on the right.","scope":"The rows are scaling multipliers relative to each quantity’s own value at λ=1, not measured norms of a specified fluid. They show why finite kinetic energy alone cannot bound pointwise velocity in three dimensions. They are not a singular Navier–Stokes solution or an independent check of the 2026 forced construction."},"checks":{"spinSpectra":18,"criticalFormulaComparisons":6,"classicalAssignments":16,"quantumAngleComparisons":91,"symbolicSymmetry":true,"symbolicRoots":4,"reducedDensityCheck":true,"elapsedSeconds":0.388}},"media":{"videos":[{"id":"finite-chain-separation","title":"The first separation changes with chain size.","description":"Six finite periodic Ising chains compare three field strengths. The exact critical reference and the ground-state doublet distinction stay visible.","model":"Periodic transverse-field Ising chain, Pauli normalization, J=1; first-level separation E1−E0 at finite N.","sourceUrls":[{"title":"Pfeuty, The one-dimensional Ising model with a transverse field (1970)","url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/0003-4916(70)90270-8"}],"transcript":["The first separation changes with chain size. This periodic transverse-field Ising chain has H = -sum Z_i Z_(i+1) - h sum X_i, with J = 1 and Pauli eigenvalues plus or minus one.","The film reveals the notebook's computed first-level separation, E1 minus E0, for N = 4, 6, 8, 10, 12 and 14, comparing h = 0.5, 1 and 1.5. The vertical axis is logarithmic. Lines join computed points and do not add measurements.","At h = 1, the exact finite-size reference 2 tan(pi/(4N)) agrees with the numerical values. Ringed orange points mark this comparison.","For h < 1, the first pair approaches a nearly degenerate ground-state doublet. Its splitting is not the bulk excitation gap above that manifold.","These finite one-dimensional spin calculations do not construct four-dimensional Yang–Mills theory or establish a Millennium solution."],"src":"/media/quantum/finite-chain-separation.mp4","poster":"/media/quantum/finite-chain-separation.webp","captions":"/media/quantum/finite-chain-separation.vtt","durationSeconds":12,"width":720,"height":450,"parametersPath":"/media/quantum/finite-chain-separation.parameters.json"},{"id":"chsh-settings-and-visibility","title":"The settings determine the CHSH value.","description":"An angle sweep shows the Bell-state CHSH value, followed by an explicitly defined white-noise visibility sweep with the classical bound held at two.","model":"Bell state |Φ+>, A0=Z, A1=X, B0=cosθ Z+sinθ X, B1=cosθ Z−sinθ X; then ρ_v=v|Φ+><Φ+|+(1−v)I/4 at θ=45°.","sourceUrls":[{"title":"Clauser, Horne, Shimony and Holt, Proposed Experiment to Test Local Hidden-Variable Theories (1969)","url":"https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.23.880"},{"title":"CHSH paper correction (1970)","url":"https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.24.549"}],"transcript":["The settings determine the CHSH value. The chosen Bell state is |Phi+> = (|00> + |11>)/sqrt(2).","Alice measures A0 = Z and A1 = X. Bob measures B0 = cos(theta) Z + sin(theta) X and B1 = cos(theta) Z - sin(theta) X.","For this state and these settings, S(theta) = 2(cos(theta) + sin(theta)). The first half sweeps theta from zero to ninety degrees through the notebook's computed one-degree samples.","At theta = 45 degrees, S = 2 sqrt(2), about 2.828. The local hidden-variable bound is |S| <= 2, assuming local outcomes and a setting-independent shared hidden-variable distribution.","The second half fixes theta at 45 degrees and adds white noise: rho_v = v|Phi+><Phi+| + (1-v)I/4. Visibility v increases from zero to one.","Here S = 2 sqrt(2) v, so violation occurs only for v > 1/sqrt(2), about 0.7071. This is specific to the stated family and settings; it is not a universal entanglement threshold.","The film presents theoretical correlations, not experimental trials. These modeled correlations do not enable signalling."],"src":"/media/quantum/chsh-settings-and-visibility.mp4","poster":"/media/quantum/chsh-settings-and-visibility.webp","captions":"/media/quantum/chsh-settings-and-visibility.vtt","durationSeconds":12,"width":720,"height":450,"parametersPath":"/media/quantum/chsh-settings-and-visibility.parameters.json"}]},"historyEvidence":{"sourceDigest":"721e6d912c4d9c61b5e421f099fb036aa49b7aab09d9987a056240be93dffa0b","method":"Historical transmission, formal dependency and chronology retain separate fields. Imported classifications preserve the earlier source inspection notes. Chronology requires explicit source-availability evidence; event date labels alone do not establish it.","edges":[{"id":"radiation-quantum","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["planck-lecture","millikan-photoelectric","einstein-light"]},{"id":"planck-bose","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["bose-statistics"]},{"id":"einstein-millikan","relation":"empirical_test","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["millikan-photoelectric"]},{"id":"einstein-compton","relation":"empirical_test","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["compton-scattering"]},{"id":"planck-bohr","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["bohr-lecture","planck-lecture"]},{"id":"bohr-heisenberg","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["heisenberg-1925"]},{"id":"broglie-schrodinger","relation":"documentary_transmission","historicalStatus":"documentary","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["schrodinger-equivalence"]},{"id":"heisenberg-born-jordan","relation":"documentary_transmission","historicalStatus":"documentary","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["born-jordan"]},{"id":"born-jordan-bhj","relation":"documentary_transmission","historicalStatus":"documentary","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["born-jordan","born-heisenberg-jordan"]},{"id":"bhj-equivalence","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["schrodinger-equivalence"]},{"id":"schrodinger-equivalence","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["schrodinger-equivalence"]},{"id":"heisenberg-schrodinger-origin","relation":"unsupported_connection","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["schrodinger-equivalence"]},{"id":"broglie-diffraction","relation":"empirical_test","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["davisson-germer"]},{"id":"wave-scattering-probability","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["born-scattering","born-lecture"]},{"id":"commutator-uncertainty","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["born-jordan","robertson"]},{"id":"wave-hilbert","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["von-neumann","schrodinger-equivalence","zeh"]},{"id":"probability-density","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["zeh","von-neumann"]},{"id":"wave-dirac","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["dirac-electron"]},{"id":"field-occupation","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["bose-statistics","dirac-radiation"]},{"id":"transition-field","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["bohr-lecture","dirac-radiation"]},{"id":"wave-molecules","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["born-oppenheimer","chemical-dynamics"]},{"id":"schrodinger-heitler-london","relation":"documentary_transmission","historicalStatus":"documentary","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["heitler-london"]},{"id":"bo-hl-comparison","relation":"analogy","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["born-oppenheimer","heitler-london"]},{"id":"wave-hartree","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["hartree"]},{"id":"hartree-fock","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["hartree","fock","kohn-sham"]},{"id":"exchange-hf","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["heitler-london","fock"]},{"id":"commutators-epr","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["epr"]},{"id":"epr-bohr","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["bohr-epr"]},{"id":"born-bohm","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["bohm"]},{"id":"epr-bell","relation":"documentary_transmission","historicalStatus":"documentary","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["bell"]},{"id":"bohm-bell","relation":"documentary_transmission","historicalStatus":"documentary","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["bell"]},{"id":"bell-chsh","relation":"documentary_transmission","historicalStatus":"documentary","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["chsh"]},{"id":"chsh-aspect","relation":"empirical_test","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["aspect","chsh"]},{"id":"bell-hensen","relation":"empirical_test","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["hensen"]},{"id":"aspect-hensen","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["aspect","hensen"]},{"id":"von-neumann-everett","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["everett","zeh","von-neumann"]},{"id":"measurement-zeh","relation":"documentary_transmission","historicalStatus":"documentary","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["zeh"]},{"id":"everett-decoherence","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["everett","zeh"]},{"id":"zeh-zurek","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["zeh","zurek"]},{"id":"density-lindblad","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["lindblad"]},{"id":"lindblad-decoherence","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["lindblad","zurek"]},{"id":"dirac-dyson","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["dirac-radiation","dyson-qed"]},{"id":"dirac-electron-qed","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["dirac-electron","dyson-qed"]},{"id":"dyson-yang-mills","relation":"documentary_transmission","historicalStatus":"documentary","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["yang-mills"]},{"id":"yangmills-gross","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["gross-wilczek"]},{"id":"yangmills-politzer","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["politzer"]},{"id":"af-convergence","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["gross-wilczek","politzer"]},{"id":"rg-asymptotic","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["wilson-rg","gross-wilczek"]},{"id":"yangmills-lattice","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["wilson-lattice"]},{"id":"rg-lattice","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["wilson-rg","wilson-lattice"]},{"id":"euclidean-lattice","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["osterwalder-schrader","wilson-lattice"]},{"id":"lattice-qcd","relation":"engineering_transfer","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["pacs-cs","wilson-lattice"]},{"id":"asymptotic-lattice","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["gross-wilczek","pacs-cs"]},{"id":"lattice-reconstruction-limit","relation":"unsupported_connection","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["pacs-cs","osterwalder-schrader"]},{"id":"bo-density","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["born-oppenheimer","hohenberg-kohn"]},{"id":"hk-ks","relation":"documentary_transmission","historicalStatus":"documentary","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["kohn-sham"]},{"id":"hartree-ks","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["kohn-sham"]},{"id":"fock-ks","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["kohn-sham"]},{"id":"shannon-landauer","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["shannon","landauer"]},{"id":"landauer-bennett","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["bennett","landauer"]},{"id":"bennett-deutsch","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["bennett","deutsch"]},{"id":"feynman-deutsch","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["feynman","deutsch"]},{"id":"deutsch-shor","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["shor-algorithm","deutsch"]},{"id":"deutsch-grover","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["grover"]},{"id":"shor-grover","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["shor-algorithm","grover"]},{"id":"unitarity-cloning","relation":"analogy","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["no-cloning","deutsch"]},{"id":"nocloning-qec","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["shor-code","no-cloning"]},{"id":"decoherence-code","relation":"engineering_transfer","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["shor-code","zurek"]},{"id":"qec-fault","relation":"documentary_transmission","historicalStatus":"documentary","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["shor-fault-tolerance","shor-code"]},{"id":"fault-threshold","relation":"documentary_transmission","historicalStatus":"documentary","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["aharonov-benor","shor-fault-tolerance"]},{"id":"threshold-surface","relation":"empirical_test","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["surface-code","aharonov-benor"]},{"id":"lindblad-qec","relation":"engineering_transfer","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["lindblad","shor-code"]},{"id":"shor-hardware","relation":"engineering_transfer","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["surface-code","shor-algorithm"]},{"id":"rg-dmrg","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["dmrg","wilson-rg"]},{"id":"density-dmrg","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["dmrg"]},{"id":"feynman-dmrg","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["dmrg","feynman"]},{"id":"feynman-chemistry","relation":"engineering_transfer","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["chemical-dynamics","feynman"]},{"id":"bo-chemical-dynamics","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["chemical-dynamics"]},{"id":"hartree-vqe","relation":"analogy","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["hartree","vqe"]},{"id":"chemistry-vqe","relation":"engineering_transfer","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["chemical-dynamics","vqe"]},{"id":"hk-vqe","relation":"analogy","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["hohenberg-kohn","vqe"]},{"id":"vqe-barren","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["barren-plateaus","vqe"]},{"id":"qec-vqe","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["shor-code","vqe"]},{"id":"epr-teleport","relation":"engineering_transfer","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["teleportation"]},{"id":"nocloning-teleport","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["teleportation","no-cloning"]},{"id":"bell-teleport","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["teleportation","bell"]},{"id":"information-records","relation":"formal_dependence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"asserted","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["zurek","shannon"]},{"id":"surface-managed-systems","relation":"analogy","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["shannon","surface-code"]},{"id":"coptic-witness-comparison","relation":"analogy","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["nag-hammadi-iv","coptic-library"]},{"id":"hermetic-coptic","relation":"analogy","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["hermetica-ii","coptic-library"]},{"id":"ancient-modern-principles","relation":"divergence","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["hermetica","kybalion","kybalion-catalog"]},{"id":"kybalion-quantum-origin","relation":"unsupported_connection","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["kybalion","schrodinger-equivalence"]},{"id":"gnosis-measurement","relation":"analogy","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["nag-hammadi-iv","zeh"]},{"id":"mentalism-collapse","relation":"unsupported_connection","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["kybalion","zurek"]},{"id":"correspondence-scale","relation":"analogy","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["kybalion","wilson-rg"]},{"id":"vibration-spectrum","relation":"analogy","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["kybalion","bohr-lecture"]},{"id":"polarity-commutator","relation":"unsupported_connection","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["kybalion","born-jordan"]},{"id":"rhythm-markov","relation":"analogy","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["kybalion","lindblad"]},{"id":"causation-bell","relation":"analogy","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["kybalion","bell"]},{"id":"gender-spin","relation":"unsupported_connection","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["kybalion","dirac-electron"]},{"id":"textual-diff-model-diff","relation":"analogy","historicalStatus":"unassessed","formalStatus":"unassessed","chronologyStatus":"unassessed","assertionBasis":"reported","sourceIds":["nag-hammadi-iv","schrodinger-equivalence"]}]},"failureAtlas":{"url":"/atlas/failures","dataset":"/research-audit.json","originalSource":"/failure-atlas-source.json","manifestations":340,"auditDimensions":27,"preservation":"Original records remain separate; historical transmission and formal dependency have independent evidence fields."}}